Ponytail Review

Diff-scoped over-engineering review: "/ponytail-review", before committing framework changes, or when the close-out hook nudges it. One-line findings over the uncommitted diff, applies nothing - the operator decides.

Encod3d-Sec Updated 340 repo stars

File contents

ponytail-review

Review the uncommitted framework diff (scripts/, skills/, setup/) against the ponytail ladder (Skill(ponytail)). From the Torchv2 root:

git diff --stat
git diff -- scripts/ skills/ setup/

For every hunk, one-line findings only:

  • UNNEEDED <file>:<line> - the rung-1/2 finding: built at all / already exists in-repo (name the existing helper).
  • ABSTRACTION <file>:<line> - an abstraction nobody asked for.
  • DEPENDENCY <file>:<line> - new dependency the stdlib covers.
  • BIGGER-DIFF-THAN-NEEDED <file>:<line> - a one-guard-shared-function fix exists with a smaller diff.
  • MISSING-MARKER <file>:<line> - a deliberate corner cut with no ponytail: comment naming the ceiling.
  • MISSING-CHECK <file>:<line> - non-trivial logic with no runnable check.

Applies NOTHING. Report, stop. The operator (or a follow-up request) applies.

For repo-wide (not diff-scoped): run /ponytail-audit shape instead - rank every finding biggest-cut-first across the whole repo.

Encod3d-Sec/ZTORCH commit c61b020b61

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add encod3d-sec/ponytail-review