Ageing and Life-Extension Screening
Use this skill when a maintenance history has to answer a life-extension question: is this equipment getting worse, and will it still do its job in year N? It turns a list of corrective-failure dates into a trend verdict, a fitted failure-intensity model, a projection to a target year, and a maintain-versus-replace crossover.
When to Use
- A life-extension or lifetime-programme decision must be justified from failure history.
- A user asks whether failures are becoming more frequent (ageing) or less frequent (reliability growth).
- A projection is needed of how many failures to expect between today and a required end-of-life year.
- A maintain-versus-replace comparison is needed at screening level.
- A recurring failure has to be characterised across many years of records.
- A study (tie-back, economics, emissions, capacity increase, concept selection) needs a production or operating horizon: establish the technical life basis first (see below).
- A question asks how long an installation or equipment population can operate, or what limits technical life.
Do NOT Use For
- A single non-repairable item's time-to-failure distribution — that is a lifetime (Weibull) problem, not a point-process problem.
- Structural fatigue or corrosion remaining-life — those need a damage model, not a failure-count trend.
- A qualified life-extension assessment or regulatory submission. This is screening input to one.
Technical Life Basis (establish this before any study that uses a horizon)
Any study that needs a field life, production horizon, tie-in tail, NPV window or remaining-life statement (tie-back, debottlenecking, capacity increase, concept selection, emissions or economics roll-up) must first establish an explicit technical life basis for the host and for each life-limiting equipment population. Do not assume a horizon; read it, state its source, and carry it into the study as an input with a data-gap flag when it is missing.
Horizons to read and keep separate. They are different numbers and routinely disagree:
| Horizon | What it is | Typical source |
|---|---|---|
| Design life | Original design basis (often 20-30 years) | Design basis, datasheets |
| Economic cut-off year | Last year with positive production-forecast cash flow | Production forecast / resource report |
| Life-extension programme validity | Date to which the lifetime programme or consent is valid | Lifetime programme, regulator consent |
| Cessation year | Planned decommissioning / cessation of production | Cessation plan; report "not found" if absent |
| Equipment-specific end of life | Design life expiry or inspection-based residual life per population | Integrity records, class/inspection reports |
Report the extension ratio (horizon divided by design life). A ratio above 1 means life extension is already assumed by the horizon, so the question is which populations limit it, not whether to extend.
Limiter classes to screen for every installation. Rank them by how early their end of life falls against the horizon:
- Dynamic and flexible risers and umbilicals (fatigue and design-life expiry; check whether a replacement programme is approved, deferred or cancelled).
- Station-keeping and marine systems for floating hosts: mooring lines, winches, ballast and bilge pumps, hull condition. Distinguish approved from draft (unapproved) cost cases.
- Export and infield pipelines (design-life expiry year, corrosion and metal-loss status).
- Obsolescence of control, telemetry, safety and electrical systems (vendor support end dates).
- Rotating equipment and compression headroom late in field life (recycle onset, turndown), which limits tail-end tie-in capacity.
- Structural and hull integrity (condition survey required; state when none was read).
Verdict vocabulary. Use the verdicts of this skill at installation level as well: retain, retain-with-measures, partial-replacement (name the populations), replace, insufficient-data-for-decision. Combine them per limiter, e.g. "retain with measures to the cut-off year, with partial replacement of risers".
Consequences for dependent studies.
- A tie-back or new-resource study must cap the host tail at the earliest unmitigated limiter, not at the cut-off year. State the usable host tail in years from the tie-in start year and list the limiter checks (riser life, pipeline design-life expiry, compression headroom) that must pass before a tie-in is assumed.
- Economics and emissions roll-ups must use the stated horizon and show the sensitivity to the earliest limiter (a truncated-life case).
- Capacity-increase and debottlenecking studies must not recommend capital on a population whose end of life precedes the payback period without flagging it.
Evidence rules (what may and may not be concluded).
- Aggregate failure counts that are flat or falling do not demonstrate absence of ageing. Say "no ageing trend demonstrated, no cohort or trend analysis run" unless the per-cohort trend with a plant-wide control (see the data-quality gate) has actually been computed.
- A missing hull, mooring or integrity survey is a data gap, never an implicit pass.
- A missing cessation year is reported as "not found", never replaced by the design life or by the cut-off year without saying so.
- Record the retrieval date and source of every horizon, since forecasts and programmes are revised.
- The result is screening input; human review is required before it is used in a decision.
Minimum output block for any study that uses this basis: horizon table (with sources and dates), extension ratio, ranked limiter list with end-of-life years, per-limiter verdict, usable host tail for tie-ins, the sources not read, and the data gaps.
The Modelling Trap This Skill Exists to Prevent
A population that is repaired and returned to service is a stochastic point process, not a lifetime distribution. Fitting a two-parameter Weibull to the inter-arrival times of a repairable system and reporting the shape parameter as "the ageing parameter" is a standard and consequential error: it assumes every repair restores the item to as-good-as-new, which is exactly the assumption a life-extension study must not make.
The correct screening statistic is the trend in the rate of occurrence of failures (ROCOF). This skill uses two independent, complementary tests of that trend so a single statistic cannot carry the conclusion alone.
Inputs
failure_times_years: corrective-failure times in years measured from the start of the observation window, each in(0, observation_years].observation_years: length of the observation window in years (time-truncated).target_year_offset: years from the end of the window to the required end-of-life. Observed to 2026, required to 2037 ⇒11.0.population_size: number of items, used to normalise reported rates (default 1).replacement_cost,corrective_cost_per_failure,annual_cost_of_ownership,discount_rate: optional economics in one consistent currency unit.
Outputs
laplace_u,laplace_verdict:deteriorating/improving/no-significant-trend/insufficient-data.crow_amsaa_beta,crow_amsaa_lambda,beta_confidence_low,beta_confidence_high.rate_now_per_year,rate_at_target_per_year,rate_ratio_target_over_now.expected_failures_to_target,expected_failures_if_no_ageing,excess_failures_from_ageing.ageing_verdict:significant-ageing/ageing-suspected/no-ageing-detected/improving/insufficient-data.life_extension_verdict:replace/extend-with-measures/extend/insufficient-data-for-decision.replacement_crossover_year: first year in which cumulative discounted keep-cost exceeds replacement cost, orNone.assumptions: the public assumptions actually applied.
Engineering Method
Laplace centroid trend test. For a time-truncated process observed over $T$ with failures at $t_i$,
$$ U = \frac{\bar t - T/2}{T \big/ \sqrt{12 n}}, \qquad \bar t = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n} t_i $$
$U$ is approximately standard normal under the no-trend (homogeneous Poisson) null. $U > 1.96$ means failures cluster late in the window — deterioration. $U < -1.96$ means they cluster early — improvement. The statistic is scale-invariant, so the choice of time unit cannot change the verdict.
Crow-AMSAA / NHPP power-law intensity. The mean cumulative function is modelled as
$$ N(t) = \lambda t^{\beta}, \qquad \rho(t) = \frac{\mathrm{d}N}{\mathrm{d}t} = \lambda \beta t^{\beta - 1} $$
with the time-truncated maximum-likelihood estimates
$$ \hat\beta = \frac{n}{\sum_{i=1}^{n} \ln!\left(T / t_i\right)}, \qquad \hat\lambda = \frac{n}{T^{\hat\beta}} $$
$\beta > 1$ is an increasing ROCOF (system-level wear-out), $\beta = 1$ is a homogeneous Poisson process, $\beta < 1$ is reliability growth. The asymptotic standard error of $\hat\beta$ is $\hat\beta/\sqrt{n}$, which gives the reported confidence band. Ageing is only called significant-ageing when the lower confidence bound on $\beta$ exceeds 1 — a point estimate above 1 on a short record is not evidence.
Projection to the target year. Expected failures between the end of the window $T$ and the target $T + \Delta$ are $\lambda\big[(T+\Delta)^{\beta} - T^{\beta}\big]$, compared against the no-ageing baseline $\bar\rho \Delta$. The difference is reported as excess_failures_from_ageing so the ageing penalty is separated from the base load.
Maintain-versus-replace crossover. Year-by-year the projected failure count is costed, an annual ownership cost is added, the stream is discounted, and the first year where the cumulative keep-cost exceeds the replacement cost is reported.
The Data-Quality Gate (read before trusting any verdict)
The trend statistics assume a stationary reporting regime. Every real CMMS record set violates that somewhere, and each violation biases the trend in a predictable direction:
| Artefact | Effect on the trend | Required action |
|---|---|---|
| System migration stamping thousands of legacy records on one date | Huge fake early cluster ⇒ false improving |
Truncate the series to start after the migration date |
| Tags created mid-window (modification, life-extension project) | Fake late cluster ⇒ false deteriorating |
Normalise by the exposed population per year, or start the window at the tag creation date |
| A yard stay / shutdown period with no operation | Silent gap ⇒ both tests biased | Subtract the non-operating period from the exposure time |
| Campaign inspections raising a burst of notifications | Fake late cluster | Screen campaign-driven notifications out or treat the campaign as one event |
| Change in notification practice (new work-order regime) | Step change in rate misread as ageing | Compare the item's rate against the plant-wide rate as a control |
The last row is the strongest defence: always compute the same trend on a control population from the same plant and report both. A rising rate that matches the plant-wide rise is a reporting change, not ageing.
Python Usage Pattern
from ageing_life_extension_screening import AgeingLifeExtensionModel
model = AgeingLifeExtensionModel()
result = model.evaluate(
failure_times_years=[2.1, 5.4, 8.8, 11.2, 12.9, 14.1, 15.6, 16.4, 17.2, 17.9],
observation_years=18.0, # 2008 -> 2026
target_year_offset=11.0, # required to 2037
population_size=168,
replacement_cost=1.0e7,
corrective_cost_per_failure=1.2e5,
discount_rate=0.07,
)
print(result.laplace_verdict, result.crow_amsaa_beta)
print(result.expected_failures_to_target, result.excess_failures_from_ageing)
print(result.ageing_verdict, result.life_extension_verdict)
Interpreting the Verdicts
life_extension_verdict |
Meaning | Typical follow-up |
|---|---|---|
extend |
No trend evidence and economics do not favour replacement | Keep the current maintenance concept; re-screen at the next review |
extend-with-measures |
Trend or economics give one warning but not both | Strengthen the maintenance concept, add condition monitoring, target the dominant failure mode |
replace |
Significant ageing AND the keep-cost crosses replacement cost inside the target horizon | Build a replacement business case |
insufficient-data-for-decision |
Fewer than four usable failure records | Report the data gap; do not report a rate |
A replace verdict is a screening signal. It has to be combined with the consequence side — for a safety-critical element, a barrier-performance and regulatory assessment governs, not the economics.
Validation Checklist
- At least four usable corrective failure records, otherwise the verdict is
insufficient-data-for-decisionand no rate is reported. - The data-quality gate above has been walked: migration date, mid-window tag creation, yard stays, and campaign inspections all screened out.
- The same trend has been computed on a plant-wide control population and both are reported.
-
observation_yearscovers operating time only, with non-operating periods subtracted. - Costs are on one basis (same currency, same year) and the discount rate is stated.
- The verdict is presented as screening, with the consequence side handled separately for safety-critical elements.
Common Mistakes
| Symptom | Cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
Strong improving trend with no engineering reason |
Legacy records stamped on the migration date | Truncate the series to start after the migration |
Strong deteriorating trend across a whole plant |
Notification practice changed, not the equipment | Compare against the plant-wide control rate |
| Rate jumps in one year | A campaign inspection raised a burst of notifications | Treat the campaign as one event or screen it out |
| Availability looks worse than field experience | Non-operating periods counted as exposure | Subtract yard stays from observation_years |
replace on a protective function |
Economics used alone | Add the barrier-performance and regulatory assessment |
Related Skills and Agents
neqsim-reliability-data-screening— MTBF / availability once a failure rate is agreed. Use this skill first to establish whether that rate is constant; use that skill second to turn it into availability.neqsim-safety-function-coverage-screening— when the item is a protective function.neqsim-asset-value-npv-screening,neqsim-energy-emissions-screening,neqsim-capex-opex-screening,neqsim-step-out-screening— take their horizon from the technical life basis, not from an assumed field life.neqsim-reservoir-facility-value-chainand the tie-in, concept-selection, debottlenecking and capacity agents — cap the host tail at the earliest unmitigated limiter.neqsim-subsea-slot-tee-reuse-inventory— useslifetime_check(ok / monitor / life-extend / refurbish / replace / data-gap) for reused slots, tees and lines against the tie-in horizon; take the life basis from this skill.- A private enterprise wrapper (written by the company) — regulatory framing, maintenance/tag-register evidence requirements, safety-critical-element gating, and review handoff.
- A private maintenance-history reader — pulls the corrective-failure history that feeds
failure_times_years. - A private RAM policy skill — company acceptance policy on the resulting availability.
Limitations
- Screening only. Not a qualified life-extension assessment, technical-condition survey, or regulatory submission.
- The NHPP assumes minimal repair; a genuinely as-good-as-new renewal is not represented.
- Verdicts are driven by open thresholds, not by any operator's acceptance criteria.
- No failure-mode resolution: the projection covers all corrective failures together. Split the series by failure mode when one mode dominates.
References
- ISO 14224, Collection and Exchange of Reliability and Maintenance Data for Equipment.
- NORSOK Z-008, Risk Based Maintenance and Consequence Classification.
- Crow, L. H., Reliability Analysis for Complex, Repairable Systems, in Reliability and Biometry, SIAM, 1974 — the Crow-AMSAA / NHPP power-law model.
- Ascher, H., and Feingold, H., Repairable Systems Reliability, Marcel Dekker, 1984 — the Laplace trend test and the minimal-repair assumption.
- NeqSim repository: https://github.com/equinor/neqsim