Concept Long-List to Short-List Screening
Early field-development decisions fail most often not in the detailed
comparison but before it: the "alternatives" are three sizes of one concept, an
option nobody wrote down was never evaluated, or a concept was dropped on an
opinion. This skill makes the funnel from a wide long list to a defensible
short list explicit, reproducible and auditable. It produces screening results
for human review; it does not select a concept.
When to Use
- Building the concept long list for an opportunity (DG0/DG1-type framing).
- Reducing a long list to a short list of two to four concepts that a detailed
comparison (
concept-selection-agent) and economics can carry forward.
- Checking that a proposed set of cases is a real choice and not capacity
variants of one topology.
- Showing why each concept was eliminated, and what evidence would revive it.
Inputs
| Key |
Meaning |
elements |
Decision element to options (default DEFAULT_DECISION_ELEMENTS: host, wells, oil export, gas disposal, drive, power) |
rules |
Compatibility rules {"if": {...}, "then_not": {...}, "reason": ...} (default DEFAULT_RULES) |
givens |
Decisions already taken (policy decisions); fixed, not varied |
concepts |
Alternatively a hand-made list {"id", "choices", "sizing"} instead of generation |
must_pass |
Non-compensatory criteria {"id", "name"} |
assessments |
{concept: {criterion: {"result": pass/fail/unknown, "evidence": "..."}}} |
criteria |
Weighted ranking criteria {"id", "weight", "direction": benefit/cost} |
scores |
Raw score per concept and criterion (from screening skills, see below) |
confidence |
Optional {concept: {criterion: high/medium/low}} |
reference |
Concept id(s) carried as reference / benchmark |
short_list_size, diversity_element, robustness |
Selection settings (n_samples, concentration, seed, acceptability_threshold) |
Outputs
run_screening(study) returns a JSON-serialisable dictionary with
readiness (always SCREENING), long_list, excluded_by_rules (with
reasons), capacity_variants, n_distinct_topologies, coverage,
must_pass_log, decision_matrix (normalised, 1 = best), ranking,
pareto_front, robustness (p_first, p_top_k), crossovers,
gap_to_cutoff, short_list (each with a reason), conditional_short_list,
elimination_log, open_questions, warnings and
human_review_required: true.
Engineering Method
- Frame. Separate givens (decided), decision elements (decided now) and
deferred choices (later gates). A strategy table over the elements is the
long list.
- Generate. Enumerate element combinations, removing incompatible ones by
explicit rules (for example dry-tree wells need a surface wellhead; a
tieback exports through its host). Every exclusion keeps its reason.
- Check the list. Concepts with identical choices that differ only in
sizing are one concept (capacity variants); a single topology is a sizing
study, not a long list. An element with one value in every concept that is
not a given is an unmade decision.
- Must-pass screens (non-compensatory): technical feasibility, water depth,
host reach, regulatory or policy limits. Only an evidenced fail eliminates;
an unknown or unevidenced fail stays as pending with an open question.
- Rank survivors with a weighted sum of min-max normalised scores (cost
criteria inverted) and report the Pareto front, so a concept that wins on
one axis is not hidden by the weights.
- Robustness. Sample weights from a Dirichlet distribution around the base
set and report how often each concept ranks first and in the top k (rank
acceptability); scan each weight from 0 to 1 and report where the leader
changes (crossover weight).
- Short list. Leader, robust contenders, one concept of a different host
if all agree, the reference concept, then fill by rank. Capacity variants
take one slot. Concepts ranked out get their score gap and whether their
low-confidence scores could close it.
Scores come from the other screening skills, computed per concept on the same
basis: neqsim-capex-opex-screening, neqsim-asset-value-npv-screening,
neqsim-energy-emissions-screening, neqsim-step-out-screening,
neqsim-stage-gate-project-timeline (time to first oil) and qualitative
maturity / risk scores with stated confidence.
Python Usage Pattern
from concept_longlist_shortlist import generate_long_list, run_screening
ll = generate_long_list(givens={"drive": "water_injection"})
study = {
"concepts": ll["concepts"][:20],
"must_pass": [{"id": "depth", "name": "Water depth feasible"}],
"assessments": {...},
"criteria": [{"id": "npv", "weight": 0.4},
{"id": "capex", "weight": 0.3, "direction": "cost"},
{"id": "co2", "weight": 0.3, "direction": "cost"}],
"scores": {...},
"reference": [ll["concepts"][0]["id"]],
}
result = run_screening(study)
See examples/basic_screening.py.
Concept Figures
concept_longlist_shortlist.figures draws the standard figure set from a
run_screening result. It needs matplotlib (pip install .[figures]). Every
number on a figure is read from the result, so a rerun reproduces it.
| Function |
Figure |
Shows |
plot_funnel |
Screening funnel |
Combinations → long list → after must-pass → short list, with capacity-variant groups in the title |
plot_decision_matrix |
Heatmap |
Normalised scores (1 = best), ranked, short list marked |
plot_pareto |
Trade-off |
Two criteria; the Pareto front is computed on all criteria |
plot_robustness |
Rank acceptability |
P(rank 1) and P(top k) over the weight samples |
plot_crossovers |
Weight crossovers |
The base weight, and the weight at which the leader changes |
plot_concept_schematic |
Block schematic |
Wells, host, export routes and power for one concept; key_facts come from results only |
from concept_longlist_shortlist import render_screening_figures
entries = render_screening_figures(result, "figures", elements=list(ELEMENTS))
# entries -> results.json "figures": {id, path, caption, linked_results}
The schematic is not georeferenced. For a map-true layout use
neqsim-surf-field-layout-design (render_field_illustration). For concepts
drawn over real existing infrastructure, use the company map tooling through an
enterprise overlay, where one is installed.
Validation Checklist
Common Mistakes
| Mistake |
Fix |
| Three plateau rates on one FPSO called three concepts |
detect_capacity_variants; vary the topology, size later |
| Dropping a concept because "it won't work" |
Record a must-pass fail with evidence, or keep it pending |
| Weights tuned until the favourite wins |
Fix weights before scoring; report crossovers and rank acceptability |
| Mixing NPV at 8 % with NPV at 10 % |
One economic basis for every concept |
| No reference case |
Carry the current best or business-as-usual concept |
| Short list of one host type |
Diversity rule; justify explicitly if alternatives are infeasible |
Limitations
- Weighted-sum ranking is compensatory and linear; it hides threshold effects.
The Pareto front and must-pass screens are there to counter this.
- Min-max normalisation depends on the set of concepts compared; adding or
removing a concept can change ranks.
- The default element matrix and rules are generic offshore examples; review
and adapt them to each opportunity.
- Screening only: it does not replace a concept-selection study, qualified cost
estimates or company decision-gate governance.
References
- Bratvold, R. B. and Begg, S. H., Making Good Decisions, SPE, 2010 (decision
hierarchy, strategy tables).
- Belton, V. and Stewart, T. J., Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis, Kluwer,
2002 (weighted sum, sensitivity of weights).
- Lahdelma, R., Hokkanen, J. and Salminen, P., "SMAA - Stochastic multiobjective
acceptability analysis", European Journal of Operational Research 106, 1998
(rank acceptability indices).
- Pugh, S., Total Design, Addison-Wesley, 1991 (concept screening against a datum).
1---2name: neqsim-concept-longlist-shortlist-screening3calculation_basis: "screening"4version: "0.1.0"5description: "Educational concept long-list to short-list screening for field development: long list from a decision-element matrix with rules and givens, capacity-variant and undecided-element flags, must-pass screens, weighted ranking with Pareto front, weight robustness and crossovers, a robust diverse short list with reference and elimination log, and traceable screening figures. USE WHEN: a concept long list must be generated, reduced to a short list or illustrated."6last_verified: "2026-10-26"7requires:8 python_packages: []9 java_packages: []10 env: []11 network: []12metadata:13 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/equinor/neqsim-concept-longlist-shortlist-screening14---1516# Concept Long-List to Short-List Screening1718Early field-development decisions fail most often not in the detailed19comparison but before it: the "alternatives" are three sizes of one concept, an20option nobody wrote down was never evaluated, or a concept was dropped on an21opinion. This skill makes the funnel from a wide long list to a defensible22short list explicit, reproducible and auditable. It produces screening results23for human review; it does not select a concept.2425## When to Use2627- Building the concept long list for an opportunity (DG0/DG1-type framing).28- Reducing a long list to a short list of two to four concepts that a detailed29 comparison (`concept-selection-agent`) and economics can carry forward.30- Checking that a proposed set of cases is a real choice and not capacity31 variants of one topology.32- Showing why each concept was eliminated, and what evidence would revive it.3334## Inputs3536| Key | Meaning |37|-----|---------|38| `elements` | Decision element to options (default `DEFAULT_DECISION_ELEMENTS`: host, wells, oil export, gas disposal, drive, power) |39| `rules` | Compatibility rules `{"if": {...}, "then_not": {...}, "reason": ...}` (default `DEFAULT_RULES`) |40| `givens` | Decisions already taken (policy decisions); fixed, not varied |41| `concepts` | Alternatively a hand-made list `{"id", "choices", "sizing"}` instead of generation |42| `must_pass` | Non-compensatory criteria `{"id", "name"}` |43| `assessments` | `{concept: {criterion: {"result": pass/fail/unknown, "evidence": "..."}}}` |44| `criteria` | Weighted ranking criteria `{"id", "weight", "direction": benefit/cost}` |45| `scores` | Raw score per concept and criterion (from screening skills, see below) |46| `confidence` | Optional `{concept: {criterion: high/medium/low}}` |47| `reference` | Concept id(s) carried as reference / benchmark |48| `short_list_size`, `diversity_element`, `robustness` | Selection settings (`n_samples`, `concentration`, `seed`, `acceptability_threshold`) |4950## Outputs5152`run_screening(study)` returns a JSON-serialisable dictionary with53`readiness` (always `SCREENING`), `long_list`, `excluded_by_rules` (with54reasons), `capacity_variants`, `n_distinct_topologies`, `coverage`,55`must_pass_log`, `decision_matrix` (normalised, 1 = best), `ranking`,56`pareto_front`, `robustness` (`p_first`, `p_top_k`), `crossovers`,57`gap_to_cutoff`, `short_list` (each with a reason), `conditional_short_list`,58`elimination_log`, `open_questions`, `warnings` and59`human_review_required: true`.6061## Engineering Method62631. **Frame.** Separate givens (decided), decision elements (decided now) and64 deferred choices (later gates). A strategy table over the elements is the65 long list.662. **Generate.** Enumerate element combinations, removing incompatible ones by67 explicit rules (for example dry-tree wells need a surface wellhead; a68 tieback exports through its host). Every exclusion keeps its reason.693. **Check the list.** Concepts with identical choices that differ only in70 `sizing` are one concept (capacity variants); a single topology is a sizing71 study, not a long list. An element with one value in every concept that is72 not a given is an unmade decision.734. **Must-pass screens** (non-compensatory): technical feasibility, water depth,74 host reach, regulatory or policy limits. Only an *evidenced* fail eliminates;75 an unknown or unevidenced fail stays as pending with an open question.765. **Rank** survivors with a weighted sum of min-max normalised scores (cost77 criteria inverted) and report the Pareto front, so a concept that wins on78 one axis is not hidden by the weights.796. **Robustness.** Sample weights from a Dirichlet distribution around the base80 set and report how often each concept ranks first and in the top *k* (rank81 acceptability); scan each weight from 0 to 1 and report where the leader82 changes (crossover weight).837. **Short list.** Leader, robust contenders, one concept of a different host84 if all agree, the reference concept, then fill by rank. Capacity variants85 take one slot. Concepts ranked out get their score gap and whether their86 low-confidence scores could close it.8788Scores come from the other screening skills, computed per concept on the same89basis: `neqsim-capex-opex-screening`, `neqsim-asset-value-npv-screening`,90`neqsim-energy-emissions-screening`, `neqsim-step-out-screening`,91`neqsim-stage-gate-project-timeline` (time to first oil) and qualitative92maturity / risk scores with stated confidence.9394## Python Usage Pattern9596```python97from concept_longlist_shortlist import generate_long_list, run_screening9899ll = generate_long_list(givens={"drive": "water_injection"})100study = {101 "concepts": ll["concepts"][:20],102 "must_pass": [{"id": "depth", "name": "Water depth feasible"}],103 "assessments": {...},104 "criteria": [{"id": "npv", "weight": 0.4},105 {"id": "capex", "weight": 0.3, "direction": "cost"},106 {"id": "co2", "weight": 0.3, "direction": "cost"}],107 "scores": {...},108 "reference": [ll["concepts"][0]["id"]],109}110result = run_screening(study)111```112113See `examples/basic_screening.py`.114115## Concept Figures116117`concept_longlist_shortlist.figures` draws the standard figure set from a118`run_screening` result. It needs matplotlib (`pip install .[figures]`). Every119number on a figure is read from the result, so a rerun reproduces it.120121| Function | Figure | Shows |122|----------|--------|-------|123| `plot_funnel` | Screening funnel | Combinations → long list → after must-pass → short list, with capacity-variant groups in the title |124| `plot_decision_matrix` | Heatmap | Normalised scores (1 = best), ranked, short list marked |125| `plot_pareto` | Trade-off | Two criteria; the Pareto front is computed on all criteria |126| `plot_robustness` | Rank acceptability | P(rank 1) and P(top k) over the weight samples |127| `plot_crossovers` | Weight crossovers | The base weight, and the weight at which the leader changes |128| `plot_concept_schematic` | Block schematic | Wells, host, export routes and power for one concept; `key_facts` come from results only |129130```python131from concept_longlist_shortlist import render_screening_figures132133entries = render_screening_figures(result, "figures", elements=list(ELEMENTS))134# entries -> results.json "figures": {id, path, caption, linked_results}135```136137The schematic is not georeferenced. For a map-true layout use138`neqsim-surf-field-layout-design` (`render_field_illustration`). For concepts139drawn over real existing infrastructure, use the company map tooling through an140enterprise overlay, where one is installed.141142## Validation Checklist143144- [ ] Givens are stated and agreed; every other element has more than one option.145- [ ] `n_distinct_topologies` is at least three for a long list, at least two on the short list.146- [ ] Every elimination in `elimination_log` has a reason; every must-pass fail has evidence.147- [ ] Scores were computed on one basis (same resource case, price deck, discount rate).148- [ ] The short list is stable in the robustness check, or the crossovers are reported.149- [ ] A reference concept is carried.150- [ ] Open questions are assigned before the short list is used in a gate.151152## Common Mistakes153154| Mistake | Fix |155|---------|-----|156| Three plateau rates on one FPSO called three concepts | `detect_capacity_variants`; vary the topology, size later |157| Dropping a concept because "it won't work" | Record a must-pass fail with evidence, or keep it pending |158| Weights tuned until the favourite wins | Fix weights before scoring; report crossovers and rank acceptability |159| Mixing NPV at 8 % with NPV at 10 % | One economic basis for every concept |160| No reference case | Carry the current best or business-as-usual concept |161| Short list of one host type | Diversity rule; justify explicitly if alternatives are infeasible |162163## Limitations164165- Weighted-sum ranking is compensatory and linear; it hides threshold effects.166 The Pareto front and must-pass screens are there to counter this.167- Min-max normalisation depends on the set of concepts compared; adding or168 removing a concept can change ranks.169- The default element matrix and rules are generic offshore examples; review170 and adapt them to each opportunity.171- Screening only: it does not replace a concept-selection study, qualified cost172 estimates or company decision-gate governance.173174## References175176- Bratvold, R. B. and Begg, S. H., *Making Good Decisions*, SPE, 2010 (decision177 hierarchy, strategy tables).178- Belton, V. and Stewart, T. J., *Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis*, Kluwer,179 2002 (weighted sum, sensitivity of weights).180- Lahdelma, R., Hokkanen, J. and Salminen, P., "SMAA - Stochastic multiobjective181 acceptability analysis", *European Journal of Operational Research* 106, 1998182 (rank acceptability indices).183- Pugh, S., *Total Design*, Addison-Wesley, 1991 (concept screening against a datum).