Literature Review Guide
Conduct comprehensive, systematic literature reviews using academic databases.
When to Use
- Conducting systematic literature reviews
- Synthesizing research on a topic
- Writing literature review sections
- Identifying research gaps
- Building bibliographies
Core Workflow
Phase 1: Planning
Define Research Question (PICO framework for clinical)
- Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome
Establish Scope
- Review type: narrative, systematic, scoping
- Time period, geographic scope
- Study types to include
Develop Search Strategy
- Key terms and synonyms
- Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT)
- Database-specific syntax
Phase 2: Searching
Key Databases:
| Database |
Coverage |
| PubMed |
Biomedical, life sciences |
| arXiv |
Physics, CS, math preprints |
| Semantic Scholar |
Broad academic |
| Google Scholar |
Broad coverage |
| Web of Science |
Multidisciplinary |
Search Strategy Template:
(term1 OR synonym1) AND (term2 OR synonym2) AND (term3)
Phase 3: Screening
Title/Abstract Screening
- Apply inclusion/exclusion criteria
- Track reasons for exclusion
Full-Text Review
- Assess eligibility
- Extract key data
Phase 4: Synthesis
Organize Thematically:
## Theme 1: [Topic]
- Finding A (Author, Year)
- Finding B (Author, Year)
- Synthesis and gaps
## Theme 2: [Topic]
...
Comparison Table:
| Study |
Methods |
Sample |
Key Findings |
| Author 2023 |
RCT |
n=100 |
Finding X |
| Author 2022 |
Cohort |
n=500 |
Finding Y |
Phase 5: Writing
Structure:
- Introduction (scope, objectives)
- Methods (search strategy, criteria)
- Results (thematic synthesis)
- Discussion (gaps, future directions)
- Conclusion
Citation Management
Citation Styles
**APA 7:**
Author, A. A., & Author, B. B. (Year). Title. Journal, Volume(Issue), pages. https://doi.org/xxx
**Nature:**
Author, A. A. & Author, B. B. Title. Journal Volume, pages (Year).
**Vancouver:**
Author AA, Author BB. Title. Journal. Year;Volume(Issue):pages.
Tools
- Zotero (free, open source)
- Mendeley (free)
- EndNote (institutional)
Quality Assessment
For RCTs: Cochrane Risk of Bias tool
For Observational: Newcastle-Ottawa Scale
For Qualitative: CASP checklist
PRISMA Flow Diagram
Records identified (n=X)
↓
Duplicates removed (n=X)
↓
Records screened (n=X)
↓
Records excluded (n=X)
↓
Full-text assessed (n=X)
↓
Studies included (n=X)
Best Practices
- Document everything - reproducibility
- Use multiple databases - comprehensive coverage
- Two reviewers - reduce bias (when possible)
- Pre-register protocol - transparency
- Update searches - before publication
Common Pitfalls
- Publication bias (positive results overrepresented)
- Language bias (English-only searches)
- Citation bias (citing famous papers)
- Not updating searches before submission
Resources
1---
2name: literature-review
3description: Use when "literature review", "research synthesis", "systematic review", "academic search", or asking about "find papers", "cite sources", "research gaps", "meta-analysis", "bibliography"
4version: 1.0.0
5metadata:
6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/eyadsibai/literature-review
7---
8
9<!-- Adapted from: claude-scientific-skills/scientific-skills/literature-review -->
10
11# Literature Review Guide
12
13Conduct comprehensive, systematic literature reviews using academic databases.
14
15## When to Use
16
17- Conducting systematic literature reviews
18- Synthesizing research on a topic
19- Writing literature review sections
20- Identifying research gaps
21- Building bibliographies
22
23## Core Workflow
24
25### Phase 1: Planning
26
271. **Define Research Question** (PICO framework for clinical)
28 - Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome
29
302. **Establish Scope**
31 - Review type: narrative, systematic, scoping
32 - Time period, geographic scope
33 - Study types to include
34
353. **Develop Search Strategy**
36 - Key terms and synonyms
37 - Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT)
38 - Database-specific syntax
39
40### Phase 2: Searching
41
42**Key Databases:**
43
44| Database | Coverage |
45|----------|----------|
46| PubMed | Biomedical, life sciences |
47| arXiv | Physics, CS, math preprints |
48| Semantic Scholar | Broad academic |
49| Google Scholar | Broad coverage |
50| Web of Science | Multidisciplinary |
51
52**Search Strategy Template:**
53
54```
55(term1 OR synonym1) AND (term2 OR synonym2) AND (term3)
56```
57
58### Phase 3: Screening
59
601. **Title/Abstract Screening**
61 - Apply inclusion/exclusion criteria
62 - Track reasons for exclusion
63
642. **Full-Text Review**
65 - Assess eligibility
66 - Extract key data
67
68### Phase 4: Synthesis
69
70**Organize Thematically:**
71
72```markdown
73## Theme 1: [Topic]
74- Finding A (Author, Year)
75- Finding B (Author, Year)
76- Synthesis and gaps
77
78## Theme 2: [Topic]
79...
80```
81
82**Comparison Table:**
83
84| Study | Methods | Sample | Key Findings |
85|-------|---------|--------|--------------|
86| Author 2023 | RCT | n=100 | Finding X |
87| Author 2022 | Cohort | n=500 | Finding Y |
88
89### Phase 5: Writing
90
91**Structure:**
92
931. Introduction (scope, objectives)
942. Methods (search strategy, criteria)
953. Results (thematic synthesis)
964. Discussion (gaps, future directions)
975. Conclusion
98
99## Citation Management
100
101### Citation Styles
102
103```markdown
104**APA 7:**
105Author, A. A., & Author, B. B. (Year). Title. Journal, Volume(Issue), pages. https://doi.org/xxx
106
107**Nature:**
108Author, A. A. & Author, B. B. Title. Journal Volume, pages (Year).
109
110**Vancouver:**
111Author AA, Author BB. Title. Journal. Year;Volume(Issue):pages.
112```
113
114### Tools
115
116- Zotero (free, open source)
117- Mendeley (free)
118- EndNote (institutional)
119
120## Quality Assessment
121
122**For RCTs:** Cochrane Risk of Bias tool
123**For Observational:** Newcastle-Ottawa Scale
124**For Qualitative:** CASP checklist
125
126## PRISMA Flow Diagram
127
128```
129Records identified (n=X)
130 ↓
131Duplicates removed (n=X)
132 ↓
133Records screened (n=X)
134 ↓
135Records excluded (n=X)
136 ↓
137Full-text assessed (n=X)
138 ↓
139Studies included (n=X)
140```
141
142## Best Practices
143
1441. **Document everything** - reproducibility
1452. **Use multiple databases** - comprehensive coverage
1463. **Two reviewers** - reduce bias (when possible)
1474. **Pre-register protocol** - transparency
1485. **Update searches** - before publication
149
150## Common Pitfalls
151
152- Publication bias (positive results overrepresented)
153- Language bias (English-only searches)
154- Citation bias (citing famous papers)
155- Not updating searches before submission
156
157## Resources
158
159- PRISMA Guidelines: <http://prisma-statement.org/>
160- Cochrane Handbook: <https://training.cochrane.org/handbook>
161- PROSPERO (protocol registration): <https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/>