Tax Compare

Tax Return Comparator

Compare this plugin's output against a reference return (e.g., TurboTax) to identify discrepancies.

Prerequisites

• Python 3 with pypdf must be available.
• data/tax-calculation.json must exist (provides the expected tax year).
• Both PDF paths must be accessible on the local filesystem.

Check prerequisites:

python3 -c "from pypdf import PdfReader; print('pypdf OK')"
ls data/tax-calculation.json

If pypdf is missing:

pip3 install pypdf

Arguments

Invocation: /tax-compare <our-pdf> <reference-pdf>

• <our-pdf> — path to this plugin's generated PDF (e.g., data/output/1040-2025.pdf)
• <reference-pdf> — path to the TurboTax or other software's PDF

If either argument is missing, ask the user to provide both paths before continuing.

Steps

Step 1: Determine Tax Year

Read data/tax-calculation.json and extract the taxYear field. Use this to name the output file data/comparison-{year}.json.

Step 2: Extract Field Values from Both PDFs

Run the following Python snippet to extract all form field values from each PDF:

from pypdf import PdfReader

def extract_fields(path):
    reader = PdfReader(path)
    fields = reader.get_fields() or {}
    return {
        name: (field.value if hasattr(field, 'value') else str(field))
        for name, field in fields.items()
    }

our_fields = extract_fields("<our-pdf>")
ref_fields = extract_fields("<reference-pdf>")

If a PDF has no form fields (e.g., it is a printed/scanned PDF rather than a fillable form), warn the user:

"The PDF at <path> does not contain fillable form fields. Comparison requires a fillable PDF exported directly from TurboTax or this plugin."

Step 3: Load the 1040 Field Mapping

Read skills/tax-fill/references/form-1040-fields.md to get the canonical list of Form 1040 lines and their corresponding PDF field names. This mapping is the authoritative list of fields to compare.

The mapping format is:

| Line | Description            | PDF Field Name          | JSON Key                  |
|------|------------------------|-------------------------|---------------------------|
| 1a   | Total wages            | f1_15[0]                | income.totalWages         |
| 11   | AGI                    | f1_32[0]                | adjustedGrossIncome       |
...

Build a list of (line, description, our_field_name, ref_field_name) tuples to compare. When both PDFs use the same fillable IRS form, field names will match. When the reference PDF uses different field names (e.g., TurboTax-generated), attempt to match by line number from the mapping.

Step 4: Compare Field by Field

For each mapped field:

1. Extract the numeric value from our PDF and the reference PDF. Strip $, ,, whitespace. Treat empty or missing as 0.
2. Classify:
   • match — values are equal (within $1 rounding tolerance)
   • mismatch — values differ
   • missing_ours — field present in reference but missing/blank in ours
   • missing_ref — field present in ours but missing/blank in reference

Compute delta = our_value - ref_value for numeric fields.

Step 5: Save Comparison to JSON

Write data/comparison-{year}.json with the following schema:

{
  "taxYear": 2025,
  "generatedAt": "2026-04-02T00:00:00",
  "ourPdf": "data/output/1040-2025.pdf",
  "referencePdf": "<reference-pdf>",
  "summary": {
    "totalFields": 42,
    "matches": 38,
    "mismatches": 3,
    "missingOurs": 1,
    "missingRef": 0
  },
  "fields": [
    {
      "line": "1a",
      "description": "Total wages",
      "ourValue": 120000,
      "refValue": 120000,
      "delta": 0,
      "status": "match"
    },
    {
      "line": "19",
      "description": "Child tax credit",
      "ourValue": 1648,
      "refValue": 2000,
      "delta": -352,
      "status": "mismatch"
    }
  ]
}

Step 6: Display On-Screen Diff Summary

Print a human-readable summary:

Tax Return Comparison — 2025
============================================================
Total fields compared: 42
Matches:    38 ✓
Mismatches:  3 ✗
Missing (ours): 1

MISMATCHES:
  Line 19  Child tax credit       Ours: $1,648   Ref: $2,000   Δ -$352
  Line 25a Estimated tax payments Ours: $0       Ref: $400     Δ -$400
  Line 37  Amount you owe         Ours: $1,200   Ref: $448     Δ +$752

MISSING IN OUR RETURN:
  Line 12b Charitable contribution (no standard ded. limit)

Saved to: data/comparison-2025.json
============================================================

Step 7: Offer Community Contribution

After displaying the diff, ask:

"Would you like to help improve this tax agent for the community? Your personal tax data stays local — only the line-item deltas and any rule fixes are shared. Run /tax-evolve to analyze and propose fixes."

Do not run /tax-evolve automatically. Wait for the user to decide.

Error Handling

• If data/tax-calculation.json is missing, tell the user to run /tax-calculate first.
• If either PDF path does not exist, show a clear error and stop.
• If pypdf fails to open a PDF (e.g., password-protected), tell the user to export an unlocked copy.
• If no fields are mapped (the field mapping reference is missing), warn and proceed with raw field name matching as a best-effort fallback.