1---2name: draft-jury-instructions3task_id: litigation-dispute-resolution/draft-jury-instructions4description: Drafting proposed jury instructions for retaliation, whistleblower, and implied contract claims requires adapting pattern instructions to the claims and issues remaining after prior rulings, pairing each instruction with a special verdict form question, and flagging legal disputes in a cover memo.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/draft-jury-instructions8---910# Skill: Draft Proposed Jury Instructions for Title VII Retaliation, Ohio Whistleblower, and Implied Contract Claims1112## 1. Subject-matter triage (only if applicable)1314- Confirm the live claims, defenses, and any resolved issues from prior rulings before drafting anything.15- Draft for the defendant’s trial posture, not the pleadings posture; instructions must track what the jury will actually decide.16- If multiple claims remain, separate them cleanly and identify whether any claim requires a distinct causation, damages, or burden-of-proof formulation.17- If the court has issued a standing order or model-format requirement, conform to it unless a tailored deviation is necessary and supported.18- Treat the cover memo and verdict form as supporting deliverables; the instructions are the primary work product.1920## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting2122- Tracking pattern language mechanically without narrowing it to the surviving issues and prior rulings.23- Drafting instructions that blur liability, causation, and damages into a single undifferentiated charge.24- Omitting the special verdict path that tells the jury which findings are necessary and when later questions become reachable.25- Failing to distinguish statutory retaliation, whistleblower, and implied-contract theories by their separate elements and remedies.26- Writing a perfunctory cover memo instead of a legal memo that identifies disputed language, the governing authorities, and the reasons for the proposed wording.27- Using conclusory statements about the law without naming the controlling authority that supports the instruction.28- Including remedial concepts in the liability charge that belong only in a damages or post-liability instruction.2930## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply3132- Start from the applicable pattern instructions, then modify them only to match the claims, defenses, and evidentiary record remaining in the case.33- For Title VII retaliation, identify protected activity, employer knowledge, materially adverse action, and the required causal link under the governing standard.34- Protected activity should reflect the reasonable good-faith belief framework: the employee may be protected even if the complained-of conduct ultimately was not unlawful, so long as the belief was objectively reasonable.35- For retaliation causation, use the causation standard that controls the claim, and do not mix standards from other statutes or claim types.36- For Ohio whistleblower claims, track the statute’s own elements, notice requirements, and causation language as applied to the surviving theory.37- For implied contract claims based on handbook or policy language, instruct the jury to decide whether the language created a binding promise and whether the employer complied with any promised procedure.38- Damages must be tied to the specific theory being charged; do not collapse contract damages into statutory or tort damages.39- After-acquired evidence, if relevant at all, is remedial; do not inject it into the liability instruction unless the court has directed a separate issue.40- Statutory caps and other limitation rules are for the court or the remedy phase, not for disclosure as a jury ceiling unless the governing law requires it.41- Every legal proposition relied on should be anchored to controlling authority by name and section, rule, or leading case.4243## 4. Analytical scaffolds4445- Identify each surviving claim and each distinct element the jury must find.46- For each claim, ask: what issue is genuinely disputed, what issue is already fixed, and what language best guides a lay jury without overstating the law?47- Draft one instruction per claim or per discrete doctrine, using plain language with precise legal content.48- Pair each instruction with a corresponding verdict-form question so the jury’s answers move logically from liability to any causation or damages question.49- Use sequential verdict questions so later questions are reached only if earlier ones are answered in the required way.50- If a claim has alternative theories or sub-issues, enumerate them first and then draft each instruction and verdict question against the full set rather than blending them.51- In the cover memo, explain each disputed instruction choice, identify the competing formulations, and state why the proposed wording is the better legal fit.52- Cite the rule, statute, regulation, or leading case for every important proposition in the instruction package.53- Check the charge for internal consistency: defined terms should be used the same way throughout, and burden language should not shift between claims.5455## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships (only if applicable)5657- Organize the charge so the jury can move from general instructions to claim-specific instructions, then to verdict questions, then to damages only if reached.58- Keep liability and remedy temporally distinct: first decide whether liability exists, then decide the consequences the law permits.59- If one claim depends on a factual predicate that overlaps another claim, preserve that relationship in the verdict form rather than assuming the jury will infer it.60- Where prior rulings have removed certain issues from the case, do not resurrect them in the instructions, even indirectly.61- If one theory is narrower than another, draft it narrowly; do not let broad language swallow the claim-specific elements.6263## 6. Output structure conventions6465- Produce the proposed jury instructions as a standalone instruction set with numbered instructions and clear headings.66- Pair each instruction with a matching special verdict form question or subgroup of questions.67- Keep the verdict form sequenced and answer-driven, using yes/no questions and damages blanks only where the theory allows them.68- Draft the cover memo as a substantive legal memorandum organized by instruction number or topic, with the dispute, the governing authority, and the proposed resolution.69- Make the memo useful to the court: identify where the parties are likely to disagree, and state the legal basis for the defendant’s proposal concisely.70- Ensure the final files are named exactly `proposed-jury-instructions.docx` and `instruction-cover-memo.docx`.71- Before finishing, confirm that the instruction file is complete and operative, and that the memo exists as a separate non-empty document.