1---2name: draft-markup-concession-agreement-ccgt-mexico3task_id: energy-natural-resources/draft-markup-of-concession-agreement4description: Guides drafting of a project-company-side markup of a concession agreement by prioritizing bankability-critical provisions, structuring termination and currency risk mechanisms, and producing a companion commentary memo with negotiability assessments and fallback positions for each markup.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/draft-markup-concession-agreement-ccgt-mexico8---910# Skill: Draft Markup of Concession Agreement with Commentary — Project Company Perspective1112## 1. Subject-matter triage13- Treat the concession as a bankability document first and a commercial allocation document second.14- Read the lender term sheet, bankability letter, and any direct agreement before revising operative clauses; align the markup to lender-facing requirements even where the grantor resists them.15- Identify whether the agreement already addresses:16 - lender cure and step-in,17 - termination payment mechanics,18 - force majeure and change in law,19 - site delivery and delay relief,20 - currency conversion or tariff adjustment,21 - dispute resolution against a public counterparty,22 - indemnities and security package calibration.23- If any of those topics are missing or thin, treat that as a drafting gap, not a negotiation preference.2425## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting26- Produces cosmetic edits that do not translate into a usable .docx redline or plain-text review record.27- Flags issues without tying them to the actual bankability package the lenders require.28- Describes a problem without stating what to change, why it matters, and where the fallback sits.29- Fails to separate must-have protections from points that can be traded.30- Drafts termination, currency, or dispute provisions in a way that leaves gaps between the concession and the financing documents.31- Gives commentary that is readable but not actionable for negotiation.3233## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply34- Lender step-in and cure rights are a standard project-finance bankability feature; the concession language should not leave lender protections dependent on implied consent.35- Termination compensation should be drafted to address debt exposure, equity recovery concepts, and breakage costs with a clear calculation path; the controlling drafting principle is certainty of remedy in a public-concession context.36- Delay liquidated damages should be capped and paired with a coherent period and rate so the clause functions as a loss allocation mechanism rather than a punitive device.37- Currency risk provisions should use a trigger-and-adjustment structure when project revenues and debt service sit in different currencies; coordinate this with the change in law regime so the same event is not priced twice or left unaddressed.38- Site delivery delays by the grantor should be paired with extension-of-time relief and documented standby-cost recovery tied to actual project delay consequences.39- Dispute resolution with a governmental counterparty should preserve neutrality and enforceability through international arbitration architecture and a neutral seat where possible.40- Indemnity drafting should be mutual, scoped to direct third-party loss concepts where market practice supports it, and calibrated with thresholds and caps that are consistent with the project risk profile.41- Performance security should track market practice for the project type; excess security can distort economics, while insufficient security can undermine lender and grantor acceptance.4243## 4. Analytical scaffolds44- Build the markup provision by provision, and for each provision ask:45 - Is the current drafting acceptable?46 - If not, is it negotiable with improvement or unacceptable as-is?47 - What text should replace or supplement it?48 - What is the negotiated fallback if the grantor rejects the preferred position?49- For every substantive change, use a plain-text marker that survives export:50 - [DELETED: …]51 - [INSERTED: …]52 - [REPLACED: old → new]53 - Add a short [Rationale: …] note immediately adjacent to the change.54- Do not rely on formatting alone to signal redlines; the substantive change must remain visible in the text stream.55- Where a clause has multiple moving parts, draft the full revised clause rather than isolated fragments so the interaction of definitions, triggers, and remedies is clear.56- If the agreement turns on more than one period, party, trigger, or payment condition, separate them before analysis and address each in turn rather than collapsing them into a single representative treatment.57- For termination payment provisions, state the calculation concept in modular form: outstanding debt, accrued amounts, breakage, and equity recovery logic, with a generic illustration only if it clarifies the methodology without importing scenario-specific arithmetic.58- For currency provisions, specify the trigger, the adjustment mechanism, and the interaction with change in law and tariff/payment clauses.59- For dispute resolution, draft the forum, seat, governing procedure, interim relief path, and enforcement-facing language as a coordinated package.6061## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships62- Cross-check the concession against any direct agreement, financing covenant, security document, or permit package that depends on the same default, cure, or payment trigger.63- Make sure a grantor default, force majeure event, change in law event, and prolonged site delay do not create overlapping or contradictory remedies.64- Where one clause depends on another, preserve sequencing:65 - event occurs,66 - notice/cure period runs,67 - compensation or extension right crystallizes,68 - dispute mechanism applies if the parties disagree.69- Keep the project-company and lender perspectives aligned: if lender rights are intended to be exercisable, the concession should not reserve a prohibition elsewhere that nullifies them.70- When a remedy has a cap or threshold, ensure the related definition, timing rule, and recovery formula operate together.71- If the concession includes multiple counterparties or documents, identify the controlling instrument for each remedy and avoid drafting that requires readers to infer priority.7273## 6. Output structure conventions74- Produce two files:75 - `concession-agreement-markup.docx`76 - `markup-commentary-memo.docx`77- The markup file should present the revised agreement text with robust textual redline markers and adjacent rationale notes for each substantive change.78- The commentary memo should be organized by provision, and each entry should include:79 - issue identification,80 - severity on a uniform ordinal scale defined at the top of the memo,81 - rationale for the change,82 - negotiability assessment,83 - fallback position,84 - downstream consequence if left unaddressed.85- Use clear bankability labels in the memo so the reader can distinguish lender-required points from commercially negotiable items.86- For each issue, reference the relevant clause interaction and the practical impact on project cost, schedule, enforceability, or financeability.87- End the memo with a concise Recommended Actions block that assigns each action to a role and a timing anchor tied to the transaction workflow.88- Before finishing, confirm that the markup file and the memo file both exist, are non-empty, and contain operative drafting rather than only commentary about drafting.