1---2name: extract-assessed-items-from-tax-authority-notice3task_id: tax/extract-assessed-items-from-tax-authority-notice4description: Extracting assessed items from a state tax authority notice requires separately cataloging each tax type and each component deficiency, identifying the challenge issues applicable to each line item, and flagging procedural vulnerabilities — not just reading the total deficiency from the cover page.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/extract-assessed-items-from-tax-authority-notice8---910# Skill: Extract Assessed Items from Tax Authority Notice1112## 1. Subject-matter triage1314- Treat the final assessment notice as the controlling extraction source, then reconcile it against the supporting return, schedules, protests, audit workpapers, and correspondence.15- Identify whether the notice assesses one tax type or multiple tax types; if multiple, enumerate them first and analyze each separately before drawing conclusions.16- Separate principal tax, penalty, and interest for every assessed item; do not collapse them into a single total.17- If the notice contains multiple periods, multiple bases, or multiple adjustment categories, treat each as its own item for extraction and challenge review.18- Confirm the petition or reassessment deadline from the notice and any cited statute before doing substantive analysis.1920## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting2122- Reading only the aggregate deficiency from the cover page without disaggregating the notice into component tax types and sub-components.23- Treating the notice as a final merit determination rather than an opening position in an administrative dispute.24- Failing to verify the penalty computation method for each assessed item and whether the cited penalty standard matches the item.25- Missing period-by-period limitation exposure, including assessments that may be time-barred even if other periods are not.26- Ignoring inconsistencies between the narrative and the schedules, including arithmetic errors and missing identifiers.27- Failing to match the final notice against prior submissions and not flagging arguments that were raised but not addressed.28- Omitting the governing authority for a challenge theory and stating a conclusion without the supporting rule.29- Producing a summary that describes the notice but does not extract the assessed items into a usable working table.3031## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply3233- **Multi-item assessment structure:** State tax notices commonly assess principal, penalty, and interest separately, and each component can have a different legal basis and challenge posture.34- **Penalty standards by type:** Negligence, failure-to-pay, understatement, and fraud-type penalties are governed by different statutory standards and proof requirements; the applicable authority must be matched to the notice’s stated penalty basis.35- **Exemption and apportionment rules:** Where an assessment turns on a claimed exemption, partial exemption, or apportionment, the controlling statute, rule, or administrative guidance governs whether the disallowance is correct in whole or only in part.36- **Interest computation rules:** Interest follows the statute’s prescribed rate and compounding method, and deviations across periods or tax types may create an overstatement.37- **Limitation periods:** Assessment authority is bounded by the applicable statutory period, with possible extensions for specified conditions such as substantial understatement or fraud; each period must be tested separately.38- **Procedural completeness:** A final notice should be checked for responses to prior arguments, consistency with supporting schedules, and internal arithmetic integrity.39- **Authority citation discipline:** Every challenge basis should be tied to a cited statute, regulation, administrative rule, or other controlling authority named in the notice or otherwise generally applicable.4041## 4. Analytical scaffolds4243- First enumerate all assessed tax types, periods, and component items visible in the notice.44- For each tax type, extract:45 - the assessed principal amount,46 - the penalty amount and stated basis,47 - the interest amount and stated computation approach,48 - the period covered,49 - the adjustment category or issue description.50- Cross-reference each extracted item to the supporting documents to verify whether the notice matches the underlying records.51- For each item, test the following challenge categories where relevant:52 - exemption or partial exemption,53 - incorrect penalty standard,54 - incorrect penalty calculation,55 - incorrect interest computation,56 - limitation-period defect,57 - unaddressed prior argument,58 - arithmetic or schedule discrepancy,59 - missing or inconsistent identifying information.60- For every challengeable item, state:61 - the governing authority supporting the challenge,62 - the factual mismatch or procedural defect,63 - the likely effect on the assessed amount.64- If the notice cites multiple legal bases, map each assessment line to the specific cited authority rather than treating the notice as a single unit.65- If the record set includes prior protest or response materials, compare them line-by-line to the final notice and note what changed, what remained, and what was omitted.66- Verify the petition, appeal, or hearing deadline and state it prominently.67- If the source materials do not support a dispute point, say so expressly rather than inferring one.6869## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships7071- Work from top-down structure: notice header, tax type grouping, line-item details, then supporting schedules and correspondence.72- Preserve the temporal sequence of the administrative process: preliminary finding, taxpayer response, final assessment, and current deadline.73- Track each assessed period independently; a defect in one period does not automatically carry to another unless the same legal basis applies.74- When a line item has multiple components, keep the component amounts linked to the same tax type and period so the reader can reconcile the notice back to the source documents.75- If the final notice references earlier materials, show the relationship between the earlier position and the final assessed amount.7677## 6. Output structure conventions7879- Use a conventional tax assessment extraction report format rather than a memo disguised as a narrative.80- Begin with a short executive summary stating the overall assessment posture, the deadline, and the main dispute themes.81- Include an assessment inventory table with columns for:82 - tax type,83 - assessment period,84 - component issue,85 - principal,86 - penalty,87 - interest,88 - cited basis,89 - verification status,90 - challenge basis,91 - likely impact.92- Include a discrepancy / challenge table that lists each issue, the governing authority, the mismatch or defect, and the consequence for the taxpayer.93- Include a procedural flags section for limitation, penalty, interest, schedule, and correspondence issues.94- Use an ordinal severity field for each issue entry, defined once and applied consistently across the report.95- If multiple items exist, provide one row per item; do not aggregate separate issues into a single representative row.96- End with a recommended actions section that uses imperative verbs, names the responsible role, and ties each step to the filing deadline or next procedural milestone.97- Keep the document suitable for direct insertion into a .docx report.