1---2name: identify-counterparty-term-sheet-issues-scenario-013task_id: corporate-ma/identify-counterparty-term-sheet-issues/scenario-014description: Guides preparation of a seller-side prioritized issues memo identifying material problems in a buyer's proposed non-binding M&A term sheet, cross-referenced against deal documents and market data at a category level.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/identify-counterparty-term-sheet-issues-scenario-018---910# Skill: Seller-Side Term Sheet Issue Identification1112## 1. Subject-matter triage13- Treat the assignment as a seller-side review of a proposed non-binding M&A term sheet plus supporting deal materials.14- Separate business terms from binding legal terms before analyzing anything else.15- Identify all parties, versions, and deal documents in scope, then confirm whether there is only one operative term sheet or multiple drafts to compare.16- If the source set includes financial summary, diligence findings, or comparable transactions, use them as the factual baseline for valuation and risk-allocation analysis.1718## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting19- Valuation concerns are stated as generic objections without anchoring them to the company’s financial profile, market comparables, or diligence findings.20- The memo reads as a flat issue dump rather than a prioritized seller-side negotiation brief.21- Risk-allocation terms are judged against abstract market norms instead of the specific transaction profile and source materials.22- Exclusivity and no-shop terms are criticized without testing duration, scope, exceptions, and fit with the signing timetable.23- Binding provisions are not isolated from non-binding points, causing the memo to overstate or understate enforceability.24- Issue descriptions stop at identification and do not close the loop on scale, interaction with other terms, and downstream consequence.25- Recommendations are vague, untethered to roles or timing, or disconnected from the transactional milestones in the record.2627## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply28- Non-binding term sheets: identify which provisions are expressly binding and which are indicative only; analyze binding provisions separately and avoid treating commercial points as enforceable unless the document says so.29- Valuation assessment: test the proposed economics against the company’s financial performance, market comparables, and diligence findings; flag seller-unfriendly adjustments, discounts, or contingencies that are not supported by the record.30- Purchase-price mechanics: treat working capital, debt, cash, leakage, and similar adjustments as core economics; assess whether the baseline, measurement method, and true-up process are seller- or buyer-favorable.31- Risk allocation: evaluate indemnity basket, cap, survival, exclusions, escrow, holdback, and related qualifiers as a linked package rather than isolated clauses.32- Earnouts: assess metric choice, operational covenants, anti-manipulation protections, information rights, acceleration, and dispute resolution as a single framework.33- Exclusivity: assess whether the duration and permitted exceptions are narrowly tailored to the diligence and signing process, especially in a competitive process.34- Representation scope: flag overly broad, open-ended, or drafting-ambiguous statements as indicators of where the definitive agreement may become more aggressive.3536## 4. Analytical scaffolds37- Read the term sheet provision by provision from the seller’s perspective and classify each point as economics, risk allocation, process, or drafting.38- For valuation points, compare the proposed price and adjustments against the company materials and any market data in the source set.39- For diligence-dependent points, tie the proposed term to the diligence finding it is said to address; if no factual hook exists, treat the point as buyer-favorable overreach.40- For exclusivity, ask whether the period, carve-outs, and process obligations preserve meaningful run-time for alternatives and signing.41- For each issue, state the concern, the seller-side revision, and the basis in the source materials or generally recognized M&A practice.42- When the analysis admits multiple parties, phases, or term variants, enumerate them first and analyze each separately rather than using a generic pass.43- Avoid unsupported legal conclusions; when a legal proposition is invoked, name the controlling authority, statute, rule, or generally recognized doctrine that supports it.44- Keep the memo focused on negotiation leverage: distinguish points that affect headline economics from those that mainly shape downside protection or drafting hygiene.4546## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships47- Track how a point in the term sheet interacts with the definitive agreement, disclosure schedules, diligence materials, and signing-to-closing timeline.48- If a term depends on later documentation, note the dependency and identify the risk of adverse drift at the definitive-agreement stage.49- Analyze process terms in temporal sequence: diligence, exclusivity, signing, closing, post-closing claims, and any earnout or adjustment period.50- Where one clause changes the practical effect of another, state the interaction explicitly rather than treating the clauses in isolation.51- If only one operative transaction scenario exists, say so affirmatively and proceed on that basis.5253## 6. Output structure conventions54- Produce a single prioritized issues memorandum in the seller’s voice.55- Start with a short executive summary that states the overall assessment and the highest-priority negotiation points.56- Define an ordinal severity scale once at the top and apply it consistently to every issue.57- Organize the body by severity, not by document order, so the memo naturally foregrounds the most material seller-side problems.58- For each issue, include:59 - severity;60 - the issue;61 - why it matters to the seller;62 - the recommended revision;63 - the support from the term sheet and related deal materials;64 - the relevant controlling authority, rule, or market convention if a legal proposition is being stated;65 - the issue’s scale or practical magnitude using facts from the source set;66 - any cross-reference to another clause or document that affects the point;67 - the downstream consequence if left unchanged.68- End with a concise Recommended Actions section that assigns the next step to the relevant role and ties it to the signing, diligence, or drafting milestone.69- Use conventional memo language rather than a checklist format; do not mirror any hidden rubric section headings.70- Keep the writing concise, negotiation-oriented, and decision-ready.