1---2name: identify-opposing-party-filing-issues3task_id: trusts-estates-private-client/identify-opposing-party-filing-issues4description: Closes the gap where agents summarize opposing temporary-orders motions without applying the correct property-characterization doctrine to inherited assets, challenging one-sided asset-freeze requests against the mutual-restraint standard, evaluating third-party declarations for personal-knowledge limitations, and assessing whether a custody reversal request is supported by the applicable best-interest factors.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/identify-opposing-party-filing-issues8---910# Skill: Identify Issues in Opposing Party's Filing1112## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting1314- Accepting an opposing party's claim that family use of an inherited asset converted it to marital property without testing the record against the recognized property-characterization theories15- Missing that a freeze request aimed only at one spouse’s accounts departs from the mutual-restraint norm commonly used in temporary dissolution relief16- Treating third-party declarations as fully reliable without separating personal observation from hearsay and lay-opinion overreach17- Failing to measure a custody reversal request against the governing best-interest framework and the current parenting baseline18- Overlooking valuation misstatements in financial affidavits, especially where compensation or equity interests are labeled without a record-based valuation analysis19- Summarizing defects narratively without turning each issue into a client-facing litigation consequence and action item2021## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply2223- Inherited and separate property: inherited property is generally separate unless the record supports a recognized theory of transmutation, commingling, express agreement, or another doctrine recognized in the governing jurisdiction; family use alone is not enough24- Temporary restraints in dissolution: interim asset restraints are commonly expected to operate evenhandedly; a unilateral freeze request should be tested against the governing temporary-orders standard and any reciprocal restraint already in place25- Evidence from non-party declarations: lay witnesses are limited to personal knowledge under the applicable evidence rules; hearsay, speculation, and expert conclusions offered by non-experts are challengeable under the local evidence code and the rules governing lay opinion26- Custody and residential-parent changes: a request to reverse a primary residential arrangement must be anchored in the jurisdiction’s best-interest factors, with any required showing of changed circumstances, and compared against the current schedule as the operative baseline27- Valuation of compensation interests: unvested or contingent equity interests may still have economic value if supported by the company’s financial condition or other valuation indicators; “zero value” assertions should be tested against available disclosure and valuation documentation28- Caretaking evidence: day-to-day caregiving, work travel, and absences are relevant fact categories in best-interest analysis and should be matched to the client intake record29- Evidentiary weight: unsupported characterizations, legal conclusions dressed as facts, and documents lacking foundation should be identified as weak proof even if they are attached to a motion3031## 4. Analytical scaffolds32331. Read the motion claim-by-claim and map each assertion to its source in the supporting exhibits; for every legal proposition the motion relies on, identify the governing authority by name or rule and note whether the cited material actually satisfies it342. For any inherited-asset issue, identify the asset, the claimed character change, the doctrine invoked, and the facts that would be needed to support that doctrine; if those facts are absent, state the deficiency and the likely counter-position353. For any requested restraint or emergency financial relief, identify the scope of the restraint, who it binds, and the baseline order currently in place; test whether the request is mutual, proportional, and supported by the record364. For each third-party declaration, review each factual statement for personal knowledge, hearsay, and lay-opinion defects; distinguish observations from conclusions and flag any statement that crosses into expert territory375. For each custody-related request, identify the applicable best-interest factors in the governing jurisdiction, the current parenting arrangement, and the degree of change the motion seeks; note whether the motion addresses child-focused evidence, neutral recommendations, or professional input386. For any financial affidavit or exhibit that characterizes compensation or equity interests, compare the characterization to available financial indicators and any disclosure gaps; flag unsupported zero-value or under-valuation claims and note the discovery needed to test them397. Convert each defect into a litigation consequence: what the defect means for temporary orders, proof burdens, hearing posture, or discovery leverage4041## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships4243- Use the client intake notes as the principal factual comparator for caretaking history, asset origin, work travel, account ownership, and any prior agreements or understandings44- Compare the motion and exhibits against the existing temporary orders, because the current order is the baseline from which any requested change must be measured45- Read declarations and exhibits as a set, not in isolation; a statement that appears supported in one exhibit may be undermined by another exhibit, the intake notes, or the financial records46- Treat requests for temporary relief as time-sensitive and prioritize issues that affect immediate financial control, parenting time, disclosure, or litigation leverage4748## 6. Output structure conventions4950- Produce a single issue-identification memorandum51- Open with a short summary of the motion’s requested relief and the core factual themes52- Then organize the memo by issue type: substantive property issues, financial disclosure and valuation issues, evidentiary and procedural issues, custody/parenting issues, and discovery or hearing strategy53- For each issue, include: the claim, the controlling authority or rule, the evidentiary support or gap, the consequence for the client, and the recommended response54- Use an ordinal severity label for every issue, defined once near the start of the memo and applied consistently across the list55- When multiple assets, declarations, periods, or requested forms of relief are implicated, address each one separately rather than collapsing them into a single generalized critique56- End with a recommended actions section that gives concrete next steps, assigned to the appropriate role, with urgency tied to the hearing or disclosure timeline