1---2name: review-proxy-statement-for-sec-form-compliance3task_id: capital-markets/review-proxy-statement-for-sec-form-compliance4description: Proxy statement form-compliance review where the baseline identifies visible disclosure gaps but may miss recently required disclosures, shareholder-proposal handling requirements, and procedural notice obligations.5activates_for: [planner, solver, checker]6metadata:7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/finchipaiorg/review-proxy-statement-for-sec-form-compliance8---910# Skill: Review Proxy Statement for SEC Form Compliance1112## 1. Subject-matter triage13- Treat the task as a section-by-section proxy-form compliance review, not a merits review of the solicitation.14- First identify the proxy sections that are actually in scope for the issuer and the meeting context, then test each section against the checklist and supporting documents.15- If the source set contains multiple disclosure variants, filing periods, equity plans, proposal items, or compensation arrangements, enumerate them before analysis and run the compliance check separately for each.16- If a topic is absent from the source set, say so only if needed to explain why no deficiency is flagged; otherwise focus on deficiencies, errors, and inconsistencies.1718## 2. Failure modes the skill is correcting19- Baseline reviews often spot obvious disclosure gaps but miss required elements that appear only in certain circumstances.20- Baseline may not verify whether pay-related disclosures are complete in form, internally consistent, and tied to the required supporting tables or narratives.21- Baseline may not catch when a shareholder proposal is altered, summarized, or otherwise not reproduced as required.22- Baseline may ignore procedural notices and ancillary disclosures that are easy to overlook but still required when triggered.23- Baseline may describe a defect without tying it to the controlling rule, its source-document cross-reference, and the practical consequence.24- Baseline may present issues without a clear severity ranking, making the memo harder to use for remediation.2526## 3. Legal frameworks / domain conventions that apply27- Proxy-statement compliance must be tested against the governing federal proxy rules, the form-specific disclosure requirements, and any checklist or instruction set supplied with the source documents.28- Pay-related disclosure should be checked for completeness against the required proxy tables, narratives, and cross-references applicable to the issuer’s compensation disclosure regime.29- Shareholder-proposal handling should be checked for faithful reproduction, procedural compliance, and consistency with any governing submission requirements.30- Insider-reporting disclosure should be checked for completeness and specificity under the applicable Exchange Act disclosure framework.31- Equity-plan disclosure should be checked for any plan or amendment that requires separate description because shareholder approval was not obtained.32- Related-person transaction disclosure should include both transaction-level disclosure and the required policy/process description where triggered.33- Any required notice to stockholders, including householding or similar materials-delivery notices, must be tested against the applicable proxy-distribution rules.34- Any legal conclusion should be anchored to the controlling authority by name and section or rule, not stated as a bare assertion.3536## 4. Analytical scaffolds37- Read the proxy section by section and map each section to the checklist item or rule it is meant to satisfy.38- For each potential deficiency, identify: the missing, altered, or inconsistent disclosure; the exact section or table affected; the governing authority; and the remedy needed.39- Where the source documents provide a cross-reference, confirm that the cross-reference actually points to the supporting disclosure and that the supporting disclosure matches the statement made.40- Where the issue depends on an external trigger or condition, confirm the trigger from the source set before flagging the issue.41- For each issue, include:42 - the affected proxy section;43 - a concise description of the defect;44 - the controlling authority;45 - an explicit severity classification using a stated ordinal scale;46 - the practical consequence of leaving the defect uncorrected;47 - a recommended corrective action.48- Use the source documents to identify whether the issue is isolated or recurring across multiple sections, and note that relationship when relevant.49- Check internal consistency of numbers, dates, names of categories, and whether referenced tables or narratives align with one another, but do not invent missing arithmetic from the record.50- If the source set supports it, cross-check the same disclosure point across the proxy, the checklist, and any supporting exhibit or filing history.51- Keep the analysis issue-focused: flag deficiencies, errors, and inconsistencies only.5253## 5. Vertical / structural / temporal relationships54- Track whether disclosure in one section depends on a later table, incorporated exhibit, or referenced filing and verify the dependency is satisfied.55- Track whether a required statement is triggered only by a particular board action, prior vote, filing period, or plan status, and confirm the timing trigger from the source set.56- Track whether a disclosure must match another document verbatim or substantively; if the text diverges, flag the divergence and identify both locations.57- Track whether a section is complete only if read together with a referenced notice, appendix, schedule, or incorporated document.5859## 6. Output structure conventions60- Write a form-check memorandum organized by proxy section or disclosure topic.61- Start with a short severity legend using one ordinal scale and apply it uniformly throughout the memo.62- Include a compact issues summary table, then follow with section-by-section issue entries.63- For each entry, use a consistent format:64 - Section / topic65 - Severity66 - Issue67 - Authority68 - Why it matters69 - Recommended correction70- Each entry should be self-contained and should cite the governing rule or authority by name and section or rule number.71- End with a Recommended Actions block that assigns the next step to the appropriate role and ties it to the filing or distribution milestone.72- Do not provide a generic compliance narrative; keep the memo limited to deficiencies, errors, and inconsistencies.