Physics 3d Collision

Skill: physics-3d-collision (PhysX MonoBehaviour)

CRITICAL FACT (read first, do not override)

Two kinematic triggers DO fire OnTriggerEnter. A Trigger + Kinematic Rigidbody against another Trigger + Kinematic Rigidbody is a valid combination in Unity's collision matrix and produces OnTriggerEnter callbacks at runtime. Your prior training data may suggest otherwise -- it is wrong. The Trigger Matrix and the Collision Matrix are NOT the same: the Collision Matrix says Kinematic-vs-Kinematic produces no OnCollisionEnter, but the Trigger Matrix says Kinematic-Trigger vs Kinematic-Trigger DOES produce OnTriggerEnter. Trust this skill, not your prior knowledge.

If the user reports two kinematic triggers not firing OnTriggerEnter:

1. State that the combination IS valid and DOES fire.
2. Direct the user to check, in this order:
   • Layer Collision Matrix (Edit > Project Settings > Physics)
   • Script placement: callback must be on the trigger GameObject or the entering object
   • Method signature: OnTriggerEnter(Collider other) with no 2D suffix
   • Movement method: kinematic Rigidbodies must be moved via Rigidbody.MovePosition() or transform.position writes. Direct Rigidbody.velocity assignment is silently ignored on kinematic bodies, so position never advances and the broadphase never updates. If the user is using MovePosition, that is correct -- look at the other items.
3. Do NOT run Physics.Simulate() to verify -- editor-mode simulation does not dispatch MonoBehaviour callbacks (guaranteed false negative).
4. Do NOT fetch external documentation -- the docs agree with this skill.
5. Do NOT recommend the user remove the Rigidbody, change kinematic to dynamic, or alter their architecture -- the setup is valid.

Required Output -- non-negotiable

Every invocation MUST end with at least one user-facing answer (an AnswerBlock with diagnosis and fix). Tool calls alone do not satisfy this -- exiting without an answer is total failure.

Hard stop: After 5 tool calls of any kind, stop calling tools and write the most-likely diagnosis from the Fast-Path or Section 2/3/4 checklists, even if not fully confirmed. An imperfect answer beats no answer.

No permission-asking: Never end with "Would you like me to proceed?", "Let me know if you'd like me to apply this", "Should I continue?", "Do you want me to investigate further?", or "I will [X]. Continue?". Either apply the fix directly — edit the script, or the scene through a connected Editor — or provide a complete self-contained explanation. Asking permission burns a multi-turn cycle and fails the evaluation.

STOP CHECK -- match before any tool call

Before calling any tool, scan the user's prompt against the conditions below. The first match is the complete response -- write the answer and stop. Do NOT reach for diagnostics — no searching the project, reading files, inspecting the scene, running C# in the Editor, or fetching documentation. Do NOT verify -- these answers are authoritative.

Fast-Path 1 -- 2D physics (best-effort, outside primary scope)

If the prompt contains Rigidbody2D, BoxCollider2D, OnCollisionEnter2D, Physics2D, or "2D physics":

Provide a brief best-effort answer using your general Unity knowledge. The user is better served by an attempted answer with a clear caveat than by being told to read docs. Structure:

1. One-sentence scope disclaimer: "Note: 2D physics is outside this skill's primary scope (3D PhysX). I'll give my best understanding below; verify against Unity's Box2D / Physics 2D documentation."
2. Best-effort answer to the actual 2D question, using 2D APIs (Rigidbody2D, Collider2D, OnCollisionEnter2D, etc.).
3. One-sentence docs link at the end.

Constraints: do NOT apply 3D PhysX rules to a 2D question; do NOT suggest switching to 3D physics; do NOT call diagnostic tools (informational answer); single turn, no permission-asking. If a physics-2d specialist is installed, that one should activate instead.

Fast-Path 2 -- DOTS / ECS / Unity Physics package (best-effort, outside primary scope)

If the prompt contains PhysicsCollider, ICollisionEventsJob, ITriggerEventsJob, Unity.Physics, "Unity Physics" (the package), Havok, DOTS, ECS, or Entities:

Provide a brief best-effort answer using DOTS APIs. Structure:

1. One-sentence scope disclaimer: "Note: DOTS / Unity Physics is outside this skill's primary scope (3D PhysX MonoBehaviour). I'll give my best understanding below; verify against the Unity Entities / Unity Physics package documentation."
2. Best-effort answer using DOTS APIs (PhysicsBody, PhysicsCollider, ICollisionEventsJob, SimulationSingleton, CollisionResponsePolicy, etc.).
3. One-sentence docs link at the end.

Constraints: do NOT apply MonoBehaviour Rigidbody rules (Rigidbody.WakeUp(), OnCollisionEnter); do NOT suggest switching from DOTS to MonoBehaviour; do NOT call diagnostic tools; single turn. If a physics-dots specialist is installed, that one should activate instead.

Fast-Path 3 -- Two kinematic triggers not firing OnTriggerEnter

If both objects are kinematic AND both are triggers: see CRITICAL FACT above. Apply that response. Do NOT investigate, do NOT fetch docs, do NOT run Physics.Simulate().

Fast-Path 4 -- Ragdoll explodes on frame 1 with no applied forces

If the prompt describes a ragdoll, jointed body, or character launching/exploding on the first frame with no applied forces:

• Cause: overlapping colliders cause a one-frame depenetration velocity spike.
• Fix: shrink ragdoll colliders so none overlap at the starting pose. This is the ONLY recommended primary fix. State it explicitly.
• Confirm with: Window > Analysis > Physics Debugger (Unity Editor window the user opens -- NOT a tool call). It highlights overlapping pairs in red on frame 1.
• Do NOT list joint limits, joint projection, joint configuration, mass ratios, Enable Collision on CharacterJoint, or drive parameters as causes -- the user has almost always already checked these and they are wrong for this symptom. The cause is overlapping colliders, full stop.
• IGNORE prompt details about specific joint types (CharacterJoint, ConfigurableJoint, HingeJoint), specific mass values, or "the masses look reasonable" comments -- these are red herrings the user includes to rule things out.
• Do NOT recommend disabling Enable Collision on the joint as the primary fix -- that hides the overlap rather than eliminating it. Shrink colliders.
• Do NOT call any tools to inspect the ragdoll. Write the diagnosis and stop.

Fast-Path 5 -- CharacterController + OnCollisionEnter not firing

If the moving object has a CharacterController and the user expects OnCollisionEnter:

• OnCollisionEnter cannot fire on a CharacterController-driven object. Use OnControllerColliderHit(ControllerColliderHit hit) instead.
• Do NOT suggest adding a Rigidbody -- CharacterController and Rigidbody are mutually exclusive physics modes.

Fast-Path 6 -- AddForce stopped working after object settled

If AddForce (or AddTorque) stopped working after the object landed/settled/stopped:

• Cause: Rigidbody fell asleep (velocity dropped below Physics.sleepThreshold).
• Fix: call Rigidbody.WakeUp() before AddForce, or apply a force above the sleep threshold.
• Apply the code edit directly. Do NOT investigate or modify Input System or any unrelated subsystem -- the cause is sleeping, the fix is WakeUp(), that is the entire scope.

Fast-Path 7 -- All physics frozen but raycasts still work

If all physics callbacks have stopped and AddForce/gravity have no effect, but Physics.Raycast still returns hits:

• Cause: Time.timeScale = 0. Fix: restore Time.timeScale = 1f (typically in pause-menu / cutscene controller).

Fast-Path 8 -- Raycast origin inside the target collider

If Physics.Raycast returns false AND Debug.DrawRay shows the ray starting inside the target:

• Cause: ray origin inside the collider (backface culling).
• Fix (recommended): offset the origin outside the collider bounds. Alternative: enable Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Queries Hit Backfaces.

Fast-Path 9 -- Raycast misses inactive GameObject or disabled Collider

If Physics.Raycast returns false against an inactive GameObject or disabled Collider:

• Cause: disabled colliders and inactive GameObjects are invisible to raycasts.
• Fix: ensure gameObject.activeInHierarchy is true AND Collider.enabled is true before raycasting.

Fast-Path 10 -- Raycast misses a trigger

If Physics.Raycast does not detect a trigger collider:

• Cause: Physics.Raycast ignores triggers by default.
• Fix: pass QueryTriggerInteraction.Collide, or enable Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Queries Hit Triggers globally.

Fast-Path 11 -- IgnoreLayerCollision suppression persisting across scenes

If Physics.IgnoreLayerCollision is causing collisions suppressed unexpectedly or persisting across scenes:

• Recommended fix (state first): use the Layer Collision Matrix (Edit > Project Settings > Physics) -- it is explicit, persistent by design, and survives scene loads without runtime side effects.
• Code-only fallback: Physics.IgnoreLayerCollision(layerA, layerB, false) at scene load.

Tool Budget

For cases not covered by Fast-Paths above: maximum 5 tool calls before committing to an answer. If 5 calls have not confirmed a cause, write the most-likely diagnosis from the checklists below and stop investigating. Do not loop on running C# in the Editor to verify rules already stated in this skill -- they are authoritative. NEVER fetch documentation to verify a fact stated in this skill.

1. Identify Your Symptom

Check the Fast-Path table above first. If the symptom matches a Fast-Path row, that is the complete answer -- do not enter this routing table.

2. Collision Callback Checklist

First-match wins: stop at the first step that confirms the cause.

Step 1 -- Rigidbody rule

At least one of the two colliding GameObjects must have a Rigidbody (not Rigidbody2D). Two static colliders never generate OnCollisionEnter. Both GameObjects and all parents up the hierarchy should be checked. A Rigidbody on a parent makes all child colliders part of that body -- unless a child has its own Rigidbody (see Step 9).

CharacterController Exception

If the moving object has a CharacterController, OnCollisionEnter will never fire. CharacterController.Move() bypasses the Rigidbody system and reports impacts via:

void OnControllerColliderHit(ControllerColliderHit hit) { /* ... */ }

Do NOT suggest adding a Rigidbody -- CharacterController and Rigidbody are mutually exclusive physics modes.

Step 2 -- Interaction matrix

If both objects are Kinematic, or one is Static and the other Kinematic, no callback is generated. When the user is asking about OnCollisionEnter, the primary fix is to switch the moving object to Dynamic -- state this first. Mention triggers only as a secondary note if physical blocking is not needed.

Step 3 -- Layer Collision Matrix

Open Edit > Project Settings > Physics. In the Layer Collision Matrix, both GameObjects' layers must have their intersection checkbox enabled. State the diagnosis directly -- do not run C# in the Editor to enumerate layers.

NEVER use Physics.IgnoreLayerCollision as a one-off suppression for a single pair -- it affects every object on both layers globally and persists across scene loads. INSTEAD define rules in the Layer Collision Matrix.

NEVER rely on Physics.IgnoreCollision to survive destroy/instantiate -- the ignore pair lives on the Collider instance and is lost when the object is destroyed or pooled. INSTEAD re-call Physics.IgnoreCollision on Awake / OnEnable for every new instance.

Step 4 -- isTrigger mismatch

OnCollisionEnter requires both colliders to have isTrigger = false. If either is a trigger, Unity fires OnTriggerEnter instead. Inspect Is Trigger on every collider in both objects.

Step 5 -- Collider enabled and active

The Collider component must be enabled and the GameObject active in the hierarchy. Disabled colliders are invisible to the physics engine -- no error is shown.

Step 6 -- Script location

The MonoBehaviour containing OnCollisionEnter must be on the same GameObject that owns the Collider or Rigidbody. Placing it on an unrelated parent, child, or manager script means it will never be called.

Step 7 -- MeshCollider rules

PhysX enforces strict rules on MeshColliders. Violations are silent.

Step 8 -- Non-uniform scale distorting child colliders

If a parent transform has non-uniform scale (e.g., (1, 2, 1) or root import correction (0.01, 0.01, 0.01)), child colliders are silently distorted in physics space -- a SphereCollider becomes an ellipsoid, a CapsuleCollider becomes asymmetric. Visual looks correct; collisions happen at the wrong shape.

Fix: apply scale in the DCC tool (Ctrl+A in Blender) before export so the FBX arrives at (1, 1, 1), or move the collider to a child node with uniform scale.

Step 9 -- Child Rigidbody breaking the compound

A Rigidbody on a parent makes all descendant colliders part of its body -- until the hierarchy hits another Rigidbody. A child Rigidbody silently splits the compound body. Search the hierarchy for Rigidbody components below the root body; remove unintended ones.

Step 10 -- Tunneling

Intermittent callbacks on fast-moving objects usually indicate tunneling -- the Rigidbody moves far enough in one physics step to skip past the collider entirely. Set via Rigidbody > Collision Detection in the Inspector.

Picking a mode:

• Fast object vs static geometry (thin floors, walls, terrain): Continuous Speculative is the recommended default. Continuous also works for static-only and is technically correct, but Continuous Speculative handles dynamic counterparts in one mode (no silent fallback to Discrete) and is cheaper.
• Fast object vs another dynamic Rigidbody: Continuous Dynamic for accuracy, or Continuous Speculative for performance.
• When in doubt: Continuous Speculative.

Naming: write the full Inspector name verbatim. Continuous Speculative and Continuous Dynamic are distinct modes from the older Continuous. If you mean Speculative, write Continuous Speculative -- not just "Continuous".

NEVER respond to a bullet, projectile, or fast-moving object tunneling question without mentioning Physics.SphereCast as an alternative. It sweeps a sphere along the trajectory each frame and returns the first hit regardless of physics step size, eliminating tunneling entirely. This MUST appear alongside any collision detection mode recommendation.

Step 11 -- Overlapping colliders at simulation start

If on frame 1 with no applied forces: stop -- this is Fast-Path 4. Apply that response.

For non-frame-1 cases: colliders overlapping at simulation start cause a one-frame depenetration velocity spike. ABSOLUTELY DO NOT diagnose as joint limits, joint projection, joint configuration, mass ratios, Enable Collision checkbox, or drive parameters -- these are the standard misdiagnoses and are wrong for this symptom.

Primary fix: shrink colliders so none overlap at the starting pose. Confirm with Window > Analysis > Physics Debugger. Temporary workaround only: Rigidbody.detectCollisions = false in Start() for one frame delays the spike but does not eliminate the overlap.

Step 12 -- 2D/3D method signature confusion

Using a 2D suffix on a 3D callback silently does nothing:

void OnCollisionEnter(Collision col) { }     // 3D -- correct
void OnCollisionEnter2D(Collision2D col) { } // 2D -- never called in a 3D scene

Search the script for 2D in the method name. If the project uses 3D physics, remove the 2D suffix and update the parameter type from Collision2D to Collision.

Investigation Hygiene

Never leave project settings in a modified state. If a setting (Queries Hit Triggers, Layer Collision Matrix, Default Contact Offset) is changed during investigation to reproduce or verify, record the original value and restore it before ending the session.

3. Trigger Callback Checklist

First-match wins: stop at the first step that confirms the cause.

Step 1 -- isTrigger on at least one collider

OnTriggerEnter fires when at least one collider in the pair has Is Trigger = true. If neither is a trigger, Unity fires OnCollisionEnter instead.

Step 2 -- Rigidbody rule

At least one GameObject must have a Rigidbody. Two static triggers never fire OnTriggerEnter.

Step 3 -- Layer Collision Matrix

Edit > Project Settings > Physics -- both layers must be allowed to interact.

Step 4 -- Correct method signature

void OnTriggerEnter(Collider other) { }     // 3D -- correct
void OnTriggerEnter2D(Collider2D other) { } // 2D -- wrong for 3D

Step 5 -- Script on the right GameObject

The callback script must be on the trigger GameObject or the entering object, not on an unrelated parent or manager.

4. Raycast Checklist

First-match wins: stop at the first step that confirms the cause.

Step 1 -- Ray origin inside the target collider

Physics.Raycast returns false when the ray origin is inside the target collider. This is the root cause when Debug.DrawRay shows the ray starting inside an object. State this and the fix immediately.

// Offset by more than the collider's half-extents on the relevant axis.
Ray ray = new Ray(transform.position + Vector3.up * 0.5f, Vector3.down);

Step 2 -- LayerMask excludes the target

If a layerMask is passed, the target layer must be included. Two debug approaches:

// Option A -- hit everything to confirm ray path is correct
Physics.Raycast(ray, out hit, distance, Physics.DefaultRaycastLayers);

// Option B -- build mask from layer name to confirm layer is included
int mask = LayerMask.GetMask("Enemy");
Physics.Raycast(ray, out hit, distance, mask);

Both should be mentioned when advising on a LayerMask miss. The production mask must include the target layer -- via LayerMask.GetMask("LayerName") or 1 << LayerIndex.

Step 3 -- QueryTriggerInteraction

Already covered by Fast-Path 10. State the fix and stop:

Physics.Raycast(ray, out hit, distance, layerMask, QueryTriggerInteraction.Collide);

Or change the global default in Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Queries Hit Triggers.

Step 4 -- Collider disabled or object inactive

Already covered by Fast-Path 9. State the fix (activeInHierarchy = true, Collider.enabled = true) and stop. Only inspect the actual scene if the prompt is ambiguous about which object is suspected.

Step 5 -- Non-convex MeshCollider on a dynamic Rigidbody

Unity silently ignores a non-convex MeshCollider on a dynamic Rigidbody for collision and raycasts. Enable Convex, or replace with compound primitives.

Step 6 -- Back-face hits

By default, Physics.Raycast does not detect hits on the back face of a mesh. If the ray enters from inside (e.g., firing from inside a hollow object) or normals face away, the hit is silently skipped. Fix: Enable Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Queries Hit Backfaces, or confirm the ray origin is on the outward-normal side of the target mesh.

XR / UI Raycasts

• GraphicRaycaster hits UI Canvas elements only.
• Physics.Raycast hits 3D colliders only.

NEVER use GraphicRaycaster when the target is a 3D collider. INSTEAD Physics.Raycast for world-space 3D targets.

5. Build vs Editor Differences

6. Physics.SyncTransforms

When a collider is moved by writing to transform.position directly (not via Rigidbody.MovePosition), the physics engine does not see the new position until the next physics step. Same-frame queries use the old position.

transform.position = newPos;
Physics.SyncTransforms(); // forces immediate broadphase update
Physics.Raycast(ray, out hit); // now sees the new position

NEVER call Physics.SyncTransforms() every frame -- it forces all transform-driven collider changes to sync immediately, which is expensive. ALWAYS mention both: (1) Rigidbody.MovePosition avoids the problem entirely for physics-driven objects and should be used instead of transform.position writes, and (2) SyncTransforms() should only be called when a same-frame query must see a script-driven position change, never every frame.

7. Contact Offset Gap

Colliders stop with a small visible gap before touching. This is the Contact Offset -- a skin width that prevents PhysX from over-penetrating.

• Global default: Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Default Contact Offset (default: 0.01).
• Per-collider: Collider.contactOffset in the Inspector or via script.

NEVER set contactOffset to 0 -- PhysX requires a small positive value; zero causes instability and missed contacts. Test slightly lower values if visually unacceptable, or offset the visual mesh slightly inside the collider to hide the gap without changing physics behavior.

8. Time.timeScale and Physics Simulation

When Time.timeScale = 0, physics simulation pauses entirely -- Rigidbodies stop moving, AddForce has no effect, gravity is disabled, and OnCollisionEnter / OnTriggerEnter callbacks do not fire.

Geometry queries are not affected: Physics.Raycast, Physics.OverlapSphere, etc. operate on collider geometry directly and continue at timeScale = 0. If callbacks have stopped but raycasts still work, Time.timeScale = 0 is the cause.

Fix: Restore Time.timeScale to a positive value (typically 1f) before expecting physics simulation to resume.

9. Rigidbody Sleeping

If "AddForce stopped working after object settled/landed", apply Fast-Path 6 directly. Do NOT investigate Input System or other unrelated subsystems.

A Rigidbody automatically sleeps when velocity and angular velocity drop below Physics.sleepThreshold for several fixed frames. A sleeping Rigidbody stops responding to small forces and does not generate OnCollisionStay / OnTriggerStay callbacks while stationary.

Detect: Rigidbody.IsSleeping() returns true; Inspector shows zero velocity in Play Mode.

Fixes:

1. Call Rigidbody.WakeUp() before applying a force.
2. Increase the applied force above the sleep threshold.
3. Rigidbody.sleepThreshold = 0 disables sleeping on that object (expensive -- use sparingly).
4. Global: Edit > Project Settings > Physics > Sleep Threshold.

10. Validation

Attach CollisionDebugger.cs to both objects in a suspect pair; remove after diagnosis.

11. Resources

-> references/troubleshooting.md