Content Quality & E-E-A-T Analysis
Google's "Who / How / Why" Test (canonical heuristic)
Before scoring E-E-A-T sub-factors, every page audit should pass Google's
own three-question heuristic from the helpful-content guide:
| Question |
What to look for |
| Who created it? |
Visible byline, author bio page, professional credentials. Required where readers expect it; non-negotiable for YMYL. |
| How was it created? |
Process disclosure where readers would reasonably ask, especially for AI-assisted content. Original research / first-hand evidence / lived experience. |
| Why does it exist? |
"To help people" rather than "to attract search clicks." Watch for niche entry without expertise, content churn for freshness signals, content written to a word-count target. |
Primary source:
https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content
When all three answers are weak, the page is at risk under the core ranking
system's helpfulness signals (formerly the standalone Helpful Content System,
merged into core during the March 2024 update).
E-E-A-T Framework (updated Sept 2025 QRG)
Read skills/seo/references/eeat-framework.md for full criteria.
Experience (first-hand signals)
- Original research, case studies, before/after results
- Personal anecdotes, process documentation
- Unique data, proprietary insights
- Photos/videos from direct experience
Expertise
- Author credentials, certifications, bio
- Professional background relevant to topic
- Technical depth appropriate for audience
- Accurate, well-sourced claims
Authoritativeness
- External citations, backlinks from authoritative sources
- Brand mentions, industry recognition
- Published in recognized outlets
- Cited by other experts
Trustworthiness
- Contact information, physical address
- Privacy policy, terms of service
- Customer testimonials, reviews
- Date stamps, transparent corrections
- Secure site (HTTPS)
Content Metrics
Word Count Analysis
Compare against page type minimums:
| Page Type |
Minimum |
| Homepage |
500 |
| Service page |
800 |
| Blog post |
1,500 |
| Product page |
300+ (400+ for complex products) |
| Location page |
500-600 |
Important: These are topical coverage floors, not targets. Google has confirmed word count is NOT a direct ranking factor. The goal is comprehensive topical coverage; a 500-word page that thoroughly answers the query will outrank a 2,000-word page that doesn't. Use these as guidelines for adequate coverage depth, not rigid requirements.
Readability
- Flesch Reading Ease: target 60-70 for general audience
Note: Flesch Reading Ease is a useful proxy for content accessibility but is NOT a direct Google ranking factor. John Mueller has confirmed Google does not use basic readability scores for ranking. Yoast deprioritized Flesch scores in v19.3. Use readability analysis as a content quality indicator, not as an SEO metric to optimize directly.
- Grade level: match target audience
- Sentence length: average 15-20 words
- Paragraph length: 2-4 sentences
Keyword Optimization
- Primary keyword in title, H1, first 100 words
- Natural density (1-3%)
- Semantic variations present
- No keyword stuffing
Content Structure
- Logical heading hierarchy (H1 -> H2 -> H3)
- Scannable sections with descriptive headings
- Bullet/numbered lists where appropriate
- Table of contents for long-form content
Multimedia
- Relevant images with proper alt text
- Videos where appropriate
- Infographics for complex data
- Charts/graphs for statistics
Internal Linking
- 3-5 relevant internal links per 1000 words
- Descriptive anchor text
- Links to related content
- No orphan pages
External Linking
- Cite authoritative sources
- Open in new tab for user experience
- Reasonable count (not excessive)
AI Content Assessment (Sept 2025 QRG addition)
Google's raters assess low-quality, scaled, copied, or AI-generated main content patterns rather than AI authorship as a standalone issue.
Acceptable AI Content
- Demonstrates genuine E-E-A-T
- Provides unique value
- Has human oversight and editing
- Contains original insights
Low-Quality AI Content Markers
- Generic phrasing, lack of specificity
- No original insight
- Repetitive structure across pages
- No author attribution
- Factual inaccuracies
Helpful Content System (March 2024): The Helpful Content System was merged into Google's core ranking algorithm during the March 2024 core update. It no longer operates as a standalone classifier. Helpfulness signals are now weighted within every core update. The same principles apply (people-first content, demonstrating E-E-A-T, satisfying user intent), but enforcement is continuous rather than through separate HCU updates. Google now also documents continuous, smaller unannounced core updates between major ones (changelog 2025-12-09).
Gen-AI optimization is SEO (Google docs, 2026-06-29): the official "optimizing for generative AI features" guide states you do not need new AI files, markup, Markdown, content chunking, or AI-specific rewrites; chasing inauthentic "mentions" is unhelpful. AEO/GEO is rebranded SEO rooted in core ranking/quality.
Honest scoping (Google docs, 2026-06-05): per "Using third-party SEO tools, services, and advice," no tool guarantees rankings and third-party tools have no access to Google's internal ranking data. claude-seo's scores are heuristics, not Google-internal signals, so say so in reports, and validate GEO/AEO findings against Google's official guidance (Search Console is the first-party source).
AI Citation Readiness (GEO signals)
Optimize for AI search engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews):
- Clear, quotable statements with statistics/facts
- Structured data (especially for data points)
- Strong heading hierarchy (H1->H2->H3 flow)
- Answer-first formatting for key questions
- Tables and lists for comparative data
- Clear attribution and source citations
AI Search Visibility & GEO (2025-2026)
Google AI Mode is Google's conversational AI search surface. Google's last official model naming for AI Mode / AI Overviews is a custom version of Gemini 2.5. Treat third-party AI Mode usage, citation, and link-share figures as methodology-dependent unless primary-sourced, and optimize for both AI Mode and AI Overviews (see the seo-geo skill).
Key optimization strategies for AI citation:
- Structured answers: Clear question-answer formats, definition patterns, and step-by-step instructions that AI systems can extract and cite
- First-party data: Original research, statistics, case studies, and unique datasets are highly cited by AI systems
- Schema markup: Article and other relevant structured content. FAQPage no longer produces Google FAQ rich results; use QAPage only for genuine user Q&A where appropriate
- Topical authority: AI systems preferentially cite sources that demonstrate deep expertise. Build content clusters, not isolated pages
- Entity clarity: Ensure brand, authors, and key concepts are clearly defined with structured data (Organization, Person schema)
- Multi-platform tracking: Monitor visibility across Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Bing Copilot, not just traditional rankings. Treat AI citation as a standalone KPI alongside organic rankings and traffic.
Generative Engine Optimization (GEO):
Per Google's AI optimization guide, "AEO" and "GEO" are rebranded labels for SEO: AI Overviews and AI Mode are grounded in the same ranking and quality systems as classic Search. The optimization signals that matter (quotability, attribution, heading hierarchy, freshness) are SEO fundamentals applied to AI-search surfaces, not a separate discipline. Cross-reference the seo-geo skill for detailed workflows; both surfaces share the primary-source synthesis in skills/seo-geo/references/google-ai-optimization-guide.md.
Content Freshness
- Publication date visible
- Last updated date if content has been revised
- Flag content older than 12 months without update for fast-changing topics
Output
Content Quality Score: XX/100
E-E-A-T Breakdown
| Factor |
Score |
Key Signals |
| Experience |
XX/20 |
... |
| Expertise |
XX/25 |
... |
| Authoritativeness |
XX/25 |
... |
| Trustworthiness |
XX/30 |
... |
Weights are this skill's own scoring model, ordered to reflect Google's
stated hierarchy: Trust is most important (30), then Expertise/
Authoritativeness (25 each), then Experience (20); maxima sum to 100. Google
publishes no numeric E-E-A-T weights (only that trust is most important), so
treat the split as our internal model. Do not use an equal 25/25/25/25 split
(it contradicts Google's "trust is most important").
AI Citation Readiness: XX/100
Issues Found
Recommendations
DataForSEO Integration (Optional)
If DataForSEO MCP tools are available, use kw_data_google_ads_search_volume for real keyword volume data, dataforseo_labs_bulk_keyword_difficulty for difficulty scores, dataforseo_labs_search_intent for intent classification, and content_analysis_summary for content quality analysis.
Error Handling
| Scenario |
Action |
| URL unreachable (DNS failure, connection refused) |
Report the error clearly. Do not guess page content. Suggest the user verify the URL and try again. |
| Content behind paywall (402/403, login wall) |
Report that the content is not publicly accessible. Analyze only the visible portion (meta tags, headers) and note the limitation. |
| Thin content (fewer than 100 words retrievable) |
Report the findings as-is rather than guessing. Flag the page as potentially JavaScript-rendered or gated, and suggest the user provide the full text directly. |
FLOW Framework Integration
For prompt-guided content optimization, use /seo flow optimize <url> and /seo flow win <url>: FLOW's optimize and win prompts provide structured E-E-A-T improvement and BOFU conversion workflows.
1---
2name: seo-content
3description: >
4 Content quality and E-E-A-T analysis with AI citation readiness assessment.
5 Use when user says "content quality", "E-E-A-T", "content analysis",
6 "readability check", "thin content", or "content audit".
7user-invocable: true
8argument-hint: "[url]"
9license: MIT
10metadata:
11 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/gabrielmoreira/seo-content
12 author: AgriciDaniel
13 version: "2.2.5"
14 category: seo
15---
16
17# Content Quality & E-E-A-T Analysis
18
19## Google's "Who / How / Why" Test (canonical heuristic)
20
21Before scoring E-E-A-T sub-factors, every page audit should pass Google's
22own three-question heuristic from the helpful-content guide:
23
24| Question | What to look for |
25|---|---|
26| **Who** created it? | Visible byline, author bio page, professional credentials. Required where readers expect it; non-negotiable for YMYL. |
27| **How** was it created? | Process disclosure where readers would reasonably ask, especially for AI-assisted content. Original research / first-hand evidence / lived experience. |
28| **Why** does it exist? | "To help people" rather than "to attract search clicks." Watch for niche entry without expertise, content churn for freshness signals, content written to a word-count target. |
29
30Primary source:
31https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content
32
33When all three answers are weak, the page is at risk under the core ranking
34system's helpfulness signals (formerly the standalone Helpful Content System,
35merged into core during the March 2024 update).
36
37## E-E-A-T Framework (updated Sept 2025 QRG)
38
39Read `skills/seo/references/eeat-framework.md` for full criteria.
40
41### Experience (first-hand signals)
42- Original research, case studies, before/after results
43- Personal anecdotes, process documentation
44- Unique data, proprietary insights
45- Photos/videos from direct experience
46
47### Expertise
48- Author credentials, certifications, bio
49- Professional background relevant to topic
50- Technical depth appropriate for audience
51- Accurate, well-sourced claims
52
53### Authoritativeness
54- External citations, backlinks from authoritative sources
55- Brand mentions, industry recognition
56- Published in recognized outlets
57- Cited by other experts
58
59### Trustworthiness
60- Contact information, physical address
61- Privacy policy, terms of service
62- Customer testimonials, reviews
63- Date stamps, transparent corrections
64- Secure site (HTTPS)
65
66## Content Metrics
67
68### Word Count Analysis
69Compare against page type minimums:
70| Page Type | Minimum |
71|-----------|---------|
72| Homepage | 500 |
73| Service page | 800 |
74| Blog post | 1,500 |
75| Product page | 300+ (400+ for complex products) |
76| Location page | 500-600 |
77
78> **Important:** These are **topical coverage floors**, not targets. Google has confirmed word count is NOT a direct ranking factor. The goal is comprehensive topical coverage; a 500-word page that thoroughly answers the query will outrank a 2,000-word page that doesn't. Use these as guidelines for adequate coverage depth, not rigid requirements.
79
80### Readability
81- Flesch Reading Ease: target 60-70 for general audience
82
83> **Note:** Flesch Reading Ease is a useful proxy for content accessibility but is NOT a direct Google ranking factor. John Mueller has confirmed Google does not use basic readability scores for ranking. Yoast deprioritized Flesch scores in v19.3. Use readability analysis as a content quality indicator, not as an SEO metric to optimize directly.
84- Grade level: match target audience
85- Sentence length: average 15-20 words
86- Paragraph length: 2-4 sentences
87
88### Keyword Optimization
89- Primary keyword in title, H1, first 100 words
90- Natural density (1-3%)
91- Semantic variations present
92- No keyword stuffing
93
94### Content Structure
95- Logical heading hierarchy (H1 -> H2 -> H3)
96- Scannable sections with descriptive headings
97- Bullet/numbered lists where appropriate
98- Table of contents for long-form content
99
100### Multimedia
101- Relevant images with proper alt text
102- Videos where appropriate
103- Infographics for complex data
104- Charts/graphs for statistics
105
106### Internal Linking
107- 3-5 relevant internal links per 1000 words
108- Descriptive anchor text
109- Links to related content
110- No orphan pages
111
112### External Linking
113- Cite authoritative sources
114- Open in new tab for user experience
115- Reasonable count (not excessive)
116
117## AI Content Assessment (Sept 2025 QRG addition)
118
119Google's raters assess low-quality, scaled, copied, or AI-generated main content patterns rather than AI authorship as a standalone issue.
120
121### Acceptable AI Content
122- Demonstrates genuine E-E-A-T
123- Provides unique value
124- Has human oversight and editing
125- Contains original insights
126
127### Low-Quality AI Content Markers
128- Generic phrasing, lack of specificity
129- No original insight
130- Repetitive structure across pages
131- No author attribution
132- Factual inaccuracies
133
134> **Helpful Content System (March 2024):** The Helpful Content System was merged into Google's core ranking algorithm during the March 2024 core update. It no longer operates as a standalone classifier. Helpfulness signals are now weighted within every core update. The same principles apply (people-first content, demonstrating E-E-A-T, satisfying user intent), but enforcement is continuous rather than through separate HCU updates. Google now also documents **continuous, smaller unannounced core updates** between major ones (changelog 2025-12-09).
135
136> **Gen-AI optimization is SEO (Google docs, 2026-06-29):** the official "optimizing for generative AI features" guide states you do **not** need new AI files, markup, Markdown, content chunking, or AI-specific rewrites; chasing inauthentic "mentions" is unhelpful. AEO/GEO is rebranded SEO rooted in core ranking/quality.
137
138> **Honest scoping (Google docs, 2026-06-05):** per "Using third-party SEO tools, services, and advice," no tool guarantees rankings and third-party tools have no access to Google's internal ranking data. claude-seo's scores are **heuristics**, not Google-internal signals, so say so in reports, and validate GEO/AEO findings against Google's official guidance (Search Console is the first-party source).
139
140## AI Citation Readiness (GEO signals)
141
142Optimize for AI search engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews):
143
144- Clear, quotable statements with statistics/facts
145- Structured data (especially for data points)
146- Strong heading hierarchy (H1->H2->H3 flow)
147- Answer-first formatting for key questions
148- Tables and lists for comparative data
149- Clear attribution and source citations
150
151### AI Search Visibility & GEO (2025-2026)
152
153**Google AI Mode** is Google's conversational AI search surface. Google's last official model naming for AI Mode / AI Overviews is a custom version of **Gemini 2.5**. Treat third-party AI Mode usage, citation, and link-share figures as methodology-dependent unless primary-sourced, and optimize for both AI Mode and AI Overviews (see the `seo-geo` skill).
154
155**Key optimization strategies for AI citation:**
156- **Structured answers:** Clear question-answer formats, definition patterns, and step-by-step instructions that AI systems can extract and cite
157- **First-party data:** Original research, statistics, case studies, and unique datasets are highly cited by AI systems
158- **Schema markup:** Article and other relevant structured content. FAQPage no longer produces Google FAQ rich results; use QAPage only for genuine user Q&A where appropriate
159- **Topical authority:** AI systems preferentially cite sources that demonstrate deep expertise. Build content clusters, not isolated pages
160- **Entity clarity:** Ensure brand, authors, and key concepts are clearly defined with structured data (Organization, Person schema)
161- **Multi-platform tracking:** Monitor visibility across Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Bing Copilot, not just traditional rankings. Treat AI citation as a standalone KPI alongside organic rankings and traffic.
162
163**Generative Engine Optimization (GEO):**
164Per Google's AI optimization guide, "AEO" and "GEO" are rebranded labels for SEO: AI Overviews and AI Mode are grounded in the same ranking and quality systems as classic Search. The optimization signals that matter (quotability, attribution, heading hierarchy, freshness) are SEO fundamentals applied to AI-search surfaces, not a separate discipline. Cross-reference the `seo-geo` skill for detailed workflows; both surfaces share the primary-source synthesis in `skills/seo-geo/references/google-ai-optimization-guide.md`.
165
166## Content Freshness
167
168- Publication date visible
169- Last updated date if content has been revised
170- Flag content older than 12 months without update for fast-changing topics
171
172## Output
173
174### Content Quality Score: XX/100
175
176### E-E-A-T Breakdown
177| Factor | Score | Key Signals |
178|--------|-------|-------------|
179| Experience | XX/20 | ... |
180| Expertise | XX/25 | ... |
181| Authoritativeness | XX/25 | ... |
182| Trustworthiness | XX/30 | ... |
183
184> Weights are **this skill's own scoring model**, ordered to reflect Google's
185> stated hierarchy: **Trust is most important** (30), then Expertise/
186> Authoritativeness (25 each), then Experience (20); maxima sum to 100. Google
187> publishes no numeric E-E-A-T weights (only that trust is most important), so
188> treat the split as our internal model. Do not use an equal 25/25/25/25 split
189> (it contradicts Google's "trust is most important").
190
191### AI Citation Readiness: XX/100
192
193### Issues Found
194### Recommendations
195
196## DataForSEO Integration (Optional)
197
198If DataForSEO MCP tools are available, use `kw_data_google_ads_search_volume` for real keyword volume data, `dataforseo_labs_bulk_keyword_difficulty` for difficulty scores, `dataforseo_labs_search_intent` for intent classification, and `content_analysis_summary` for content quality analysis.
199
200## Error Handling
201
202| Scenario | Action |
203|----------|--------|
204| URL unreachable (DNS failure, connection refused) | Report the error clearly. Do not guess page content. Suggest the user verify the URL and try again. |
205| Content behind paywall (402/403, login wall) | Report that the content is not publicly accessible. Analyze only the visible portion (meta tags, headers) and note the limitation. |
206| Thin content (fewer than 100 words retrievable) | Report the findings as-is rather than guessing. Flag the page as potentially JavaScript-rendered or gated, and suggest the user provide the full text directly. |
207
208## FLOW Framework Integration
209
210For prompt-guided content optimization, use `/seo flow optimize <url>` and `/seo flow win <url>`: FLOW's optimize and win prompts provide structured E-E-A-T improvement and BOFU conversion workflows.