Macos Window Management Workflow

macOS Window Management Workflow

Purpose

Own concrete macOS window behavior that sits below broad app architecture: scene selection, chrome, drag affordances, sizing, placement, restoration, utility windows, and validation. Keep application-wide ownership and AppKit controller architecture with swiftui-app-architecture-workflow and appkit-app-architecture-workflow.

Workflow

1. Identify the window's job: main content, document, settings, inspector, utility, transient activity, or external display. Start from WindowGroup, Window, Settings, or DocumentGroup; do not start by hiding the title bar.
2. Define the window's ownership and identity. Give independently openable windows stable scene values and user-facing titles so Window-menu, restoration, and focus behavior remain understandable.
3. Choose the least-custom chrome. Prefer normal title bars and standard toolbars; use windowToolbarStyle, toolbarBackgroundVisibility, toolbarVisibility, or windowStyle only to support the window's job.
4. If custom chrome removes a normal drag surface, add WindowDragGesture only in a region that does not steal content controls. Use allowsWindowActivationEvents(true) only when the window must activate and drag from the same gesture.
5. Treat placement, resizing, and zoom as behavioral contracts. Use scene-level placement APIs only when the content has a real ideal size or position; do not force a fixed geometry that fights user resizing or display changes.
6. Respect state restoration by default. Disable restoration only for a truly transient, expensive, or unsafe-to-reconstruct window, and explain what opens instead on relaunch.
7. Escalate to AppKit only for an actual AppKit-owned requirement such as NSWindow behavior, panels, responder-chain menus, or a controller lifecycle that SwiftUI cannot represent cleanly.
8. Validate on the oldest supported macOS plus the current target: launch, open another window, focus switching, resize/zoom, full screen, close/reopen, restoration, VoiceOver title, and Window-menu state.

Guards

• Do not use borderless or hidden-title-bar styling as a generic design upgrade.
• Do not make an app non-draggable when removing its toolbar background or toolbar.
• Do not replace user restoration preferences with app policy without a concrete transient-window reason.
• Do not push AppKit window-controller ownership into a SwiftUI view just to reach a window property.
• Do not claim Simulator, preview, or screenshot proof covers keyboard focus, restoration, or multiwindow behavior without exercising it.

References

• references/window-scene-and-chrome-rules.md
• references/placement-restoration-and-validation.md