Prompt Review

Prompt Review

Review prompt quality first. Use /prompt-principles and /llm-writing as the default lens.

What to Look For

Read all four /prompt-principles resource files before reviewing. The body routes; the resources carry the actual heuristics:

• resources/prompt-level.md: attention, structure, leading words, heuristic altitude
• resources/skill-level.md: loading model, extraction, decomposition
• resources/agent-level.md: cognitive mode, body focus, reuse
• resources/system-level.md: handoffs, verification, coordination altitude

Review against each layer that applies. Focus on high-leverage issues: no-op lines, misplaced knowledge, overloaded bodies, weak routing, brittle prescription, and missing reasons. A good finding points to the exact text, explains the failure mode, and suggests a better direction.

After the prompt-quality pass, do a lighter mechanics pass when relevant. For that second angle, load resources/mechanics.md.

Report

Start with a short overall assessment. Then list the findings and include the severity of each. End with a verdict: approve, approve with notes, or request changes.