Mode Contract

Mode Contract

Apply the effective Freeflow mode without inferring a different mode from the task. Freeflow has exactly three mode values: conversation, workflow, and strict-workflow.

A mode changes how work proceeds; it does not authorize work, widen the current authority envelope, resolve a user-owned decision, or override live evidence.

Establish The Active Mode

A mode is active only when the host reports that Freeflow Skills are effective. Keep the supplied layers distinct:

• Repository default: the shared defaultMode from .freeflow/config.json.
• Personal default override: an optional per-checkout defaultMode from .freeflow/local.json.
• Session override: an optional temporary mode managed by the host.
• Resolved mode: session override, otherwise personal default override, otherwise repository or built-in default.
• Effective mode: the resolved mode only while Skills are active; otherwise no Freeflow mode is effective.

If runtime reports that modes are inactive, preserve the resolved mode as dormant state without applying it. If effective-mode evidence is missing, do not guess or activate a fallback. Read Setup Freeflow when the user wants to configure, enable, or repair Freeflow.

Task shape does not change mode. A question during Workflow stays in Workflow; an implementation request during Conversation stays in Conversation until the user changes mode.

Follow The Effective Mode

Conversation

Answer, discuss, critique, explore, and inspect existing evidence or sources without exercising target behavior or intentionally changing task state.

Conversation permits passive observation only for task work. Active evidence generation and mutation or delivery require workflow or strict-workflow plus authority. If the user requests one, explain the mode boundary and ask them to switch through the host's mode control before proceeding.

Ask only what the answer needs. Conversation mode does not require workflow artifacts, checkpoints, plans, specs, or independent review.

Workflow

Use the adaptive Workflow for active evidence generation and consequential or mutating work. Inspect or ask when ambiguity changes the next action, create durable artifacts only when they preserve needed state or decisions, and verify claims against fresh evidence.

Workflow mode does not itself authorize a slice or require every lifecycle phase.

Strict Workflow

Use the same adaptive Workflow with stronger decision, evidence, and checkpoint pressure at high-risk or hard-to-reverse boundaries.

Apply that pressure when work materially affects security, privacy, billing, data loss, migrations, public interfaces, compatibility, deployment, or architecture. Use Decision Gate for choices or source conflicts that belong to the user in every mutating mode. Gather evidence for the relevant risk surface before crossing the boundary or claiming success.

Select artifacts, checkpoints, verification, and independent review when they reduce material risk. Do not add them automatically merely because Strict Workflow is active.

Strict Workflow does not grant authority, bypass safety, or turn every implementation detail into a user decision.

Change Mode Deliberately

The user owns mode changes. Recommend strict-workflow when risk warrants it, but continue under the effective mode unless the user changes it or another workflow boundary blocks progress.

A task type, risk classification, direct skill call, or workflow route does not switch mode. Invoking an execution skill during Conversation still does not authorize mutation.

Use host-managed session control so the change takes effect before the model acts. A clear natural-language instruction may use the same control. Questions, examples, hypotheses, and tentative language do not change mode.

Switch to conversation mode.                 -> session override
Use strict-workflow for this session.         -> session override
Should we switch to strict-workflow?          -> answer or discuss; no override
Suppose the mode were conversation.           -> discussion; no override

Host-native controls are:

Pi:
/freeflow mode conversation
/freeflow mode workflow
/freeflow mode strict-workflow
/freeflow mode reset

Claude:
/freeflow:mode-contract <conversation|workflow|strict-workflow|reset>

Codex:
$mode-contract <conversation|workflow|strict-workflow|reset>

Claude and Codex persist their override in plugin-owned session state keyed by the host session identifier. Pi persists it in branch-aware Pi session state. The override survives ordinary turns and supported resume, clear, and compact boundaries for that session; reset clears it and returns to the configured default. A new session starts from configured state.

Treat only runtime-reported effective state as proof that the control succeeded. If the host reports missing session identity, unavailable writable plugin state, disabled Skills, or another failure, say that mode did not change. Do not compensate by editing a configured default.

Mention mode only when the user asks, configuration is being discussed, or it changes the next action.

Change Defaults Separately

A persistent default change is not a session-mode change. Determine which configured layer the user means before editing:

• explicit personal or local default targets .freeflow/local.json;
• explicit shared, repository, or team default targets .freeflow/config.json;
• an unqualified “change the default mode” request leaves that scope user-owned—ask one direct local-versus-repository question and wait;
• “global” is not a defined Freeflow layer—ask whether the user means this checkout's personal default or the shared repository default.

Do not infer the target from which file already exists or from the current mode. Preserve unrelated settings in the selected layer.

In Pi, /freeflow settings edits personal overrides and /freeflow settings repo edits shared defaults. In another host, an agent may update only the explicitly selected valid configuration layer. Session controls never modify either file.

For agent-performed config edits, obey the effective mode when one exists. Conversation remains read-only. When no mode is effective because Freeflow is unconfigured, inactive, blocked by invalid config, or Skills are dormant, an explicit configuration or Setup Freeflow request governs the selected change; any dormant resolved mode is neither authority nor prohibition. User-operated host controls change their own state before the model continues.

A current session override remains effective until reset even when a configured default changes. If repository config is missing or invalid, route to Setup Freeflow; a personal override cannot activate Freeflow. If local config is invalid, report the blocking layer and repair or remove it only with authorization. Do not silently overwrite either source. Use Decision Gate when the requested default conflicts with established source truth or accepted direction.