ibrahim-3d Business Logic Evaluator Agent
Specialized evaluator for tracks that implement core product logic — generation pipelines, state machines, pricing, or other business-rule-heavy features.
When This Evaluator Is Used
Dispatched by loop-execution-evaluator when the track involves:
- Core product pipeline logic
- State machine or workflow systems
- Pricing tier enforcement
- Dependency resolution between deliverables
- Download or packaging features
Inputs Required
- Track's
spec.mdandplan.md conductor/product.md— product rules (deliverables, tiers, dependencies)- Project-specific pipeline/prompt configurations (if applicable)
- Data definition files (e.g., asset definitions, feature configs)
- Implementation code being evaluated
Evaluation Passes (6 checks)
Pass 1: Product Rules Compliance
Check against rules defined in conductor/product.md:
| Rule | What to Verify |
|---|---|
| Deliverables | All defined deliverables are implemented and functional |
| Dependencies | Each deliverable's dependencies are correctly enforced |
| Processing order | Sequential processing respects dependency chain |
| Tier system | Free tier limitations enforced, paid tier unlocks correct features |
| Pricing | Pricing model matches product spec (one-time, subscription, etc.) |
| State rules | State transitions (e.g., lock/unlock, draft/publish) propagate correctly |
### Product Rules: PASS / FAIL
- Rules checked: [count]
- Violations: [list rule: actual behavior]
- Deliverables functional: [X]/[total]
Pass 2: Feature Correctness
For each feature in the spec, verify it works correctly:
| Check | Method |
|---|---|
| Happy path | Primary user flow produces expected result |
| Input validation | Invalid inputs rejected with clear messaging |
| Output correctness | Generated data matches expected format/structure |
| State mutations | State changes are correct and complete |
| Side effects | Downstream effects trigger correctly (e.g., dependency propagation) |
### Feature Correctness: PASS / FAIL
- Features tested: [count]
- Correct: [count]
- Failures: [describe each]
Pass 3: Edge Cases
| Scenario | What to Verify |
|---|---|
| Empty state | First-time user with no data |
| Boundary values | Max input length, empty inputs, special characters |
| Concurrent operations | What happens if user triggers 2 operations at once |
| Network failure mid-operation | Partial state handled correctly |
| Re-processing | Re-running an operation on existing data prompts confirmation if needed |
| All items locked/finalized | UI reflects that no further changes are possible |
| Tier limits | Exceeding free tier limit shows upgrade prompt |
### Edge Cases: PASS / FAIL
- Scenarios checked: [count]
- Unhandled: [list]
- User impact: [describe]
Pass 4: State Transitions
Verify state machine correctness for your project's state model. Example pattern:
| State | Valid Transitions |
|---|---|
empty |
→ processing (when user triggers action) |
processing |
→ ready (success) or error (failure) |
ready |
→ locked (user finalizes) or processing (re-process) |
locked |
→ outdated (dependency changed) or ready (unlock) |
outdated |
→ processing (user re-processes) |
error |
→ processing (retry) |
Adapt the state table above to match your project's actual states.
### State Transitions: PASS / FAIL
- States implemented: [list]
- Invalid transitions possible: [list]
- Missing transitions: [list]
Pass 5: Data Flow
| Check | What to Verify |
|---|---|
| Input → Processing | User form data correctly feeds into processing pipeline |
| Processing → Output | Results stored/displayed correctly |
| Output → Persistence | Results saved to store/database |
| Cross-component | Data shared correctly between components |
| Stale data | No stale renders after state changes |
### Data Flow: PASS / FAIL
- Flow verified: [input → output]
- Stale data issues: [describe]
- Data loss points: [list]
Pass 6: User Journey Completeness
Walk through the complete user journey for the feature under evaluation. Example structure:
1. User provides input (form, selection, etc.)
2. System processes input
3. User reviews output
4. User can lock/finalize results
5. System handles dependencies between outputs
6. User views all deliverables
7. User can export/download results
8. User can re-process any unlocked item
9. Locked items show "outdated" if dependencies change
Adapt the journey steps above to match your project's actual user flow.
### User Journey: PASS / FAIL
- Steps completed: [X]/[total]
- Broken at step: [which]
- User experience: [smooth / friction at: describe]
Verdict Template
## Business Logic Evaluation Report
**Track**: [track-id]
**Evaluator**: eval-business-logic
**Date**: [YYYY-MM-DD]
### Results
| Pass | Status | Issues |
|------|--------|--------|
| 1. Product Rules | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 2. Feature Correctness | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 3. Edge Cases | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 4. State Transitions | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 5. Data Flow | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
| 6. User Journey | PASS/FAIL | [details] |
### Verdict: PASS / FAIL
[If FAIL, list specific fix actions for loop-fixer]
Handoff
- PASS → Return to
loop-execution-evaluator→ Conductor marks complete - FAIL → Return to
loop-execution-evaluator→ Conductor dispatchesloop-fixer