ihabkhaled Evidence Gate
Core principle
Unknown remains unknown until evidence supports it. Direct language never licenses fake certainty. Read hallucination and evidence control.
Procedure
- Freeze actions that depend on the claim.
- Label it observed fact, supported inference, assumption, or unknown.
- State the authoritative source that could confirm it.
- Search that source and read the smallest relevant section.
- Record path, output, or test evidence and freshness.
- If absent after proportionate search, say Not confirmed.
- Remove implementation branches that require the unconfirmed fact.
- Proceed with evidence or request exact missing input.
Quick reference
Source code and configuration beat summaries and memory. Three equivalent searches require a new evidence source or stop. Critical uncertainty needs proof or a blocker.
Common mistakes
- Treating conventions as repository facts.
- Reporting tests or publication that were not observed.
- Rephrasing the same search and calling it new evidence.
- Using assertive tone to hide uncertainty.
Stop condition
Stop when the claim is proven, explicitly bounded as inference, or marked not confirmed and removed from the dependency chain.