Research Critic

Critique research hypotheses, experiment design, results, ablations, baselines, and paper claims before committing them.

jajupmochi Updated

File contents

research-critic

Read ../general/research-critic/SKILL.md completely before using this skill.

Codex-specific requirements:

  1. Tie criticism to the current artifact: paper draft, experiment script, result table, plot, or benchmark output.
  2. Separate empirical evidence, interpretation, and speculation.
  3. Check falsifiability, fair comparison, leakage, ablation design, statistical support, and proportional conclusions.
  4. If evidence is missing or indirect, mark the claim as unproven and propose the smallest check that would resolve it.

jajupmochi/agent-harness/tree/main/skills/research-critic commit e34de43931

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add jajupmochi/research-critic