jesse-black Evaluator ExecPlan
Use this skill when the task is to review the current PR branch or worktree that is closing out an ExecPlan.
Read first
Before reviewing, read:
- the current ExecPlan
- the implementation diff or current branch/worktree state
Treat the ExecPlan as the source of intent and acceptance criteria. Role-specific review responsibilities stop here; PLANS.md remains the source of truth for ExecPlan structure and maintenance rules.
You own
As evaluator, you own:
- independent review of the branch diff and the relevant ExecPlan
- identifying bugs, regressions, missing tests, plan mismatches, and unnecessary complexity
- recording review findings and evidence in the ExecPlan
You do not own:
- moving plans between active and completed
- rewriting acceptance criteria so the implementation passes
- taking over implementation or plan closeout responsibilities
Role boundaries
Use the evaluator when the task is to perform an independent review of the current branch or worktree against the plan.
Act like a reviewer, not a closeout assistant. Review findings should stay specific and actionable, and they should be recorded in the ExecPlan without softening the review to fit what was built.