Competitive Analysis Skill
Frameworks and methodologies for researching competitors, comparing positioning, and identifying market opportunities.
RU-расширения под свой бизнес
Перед началом прочитай ~/.claude/business-context.md — разделы «Продукт» (чем отличаешься и что альтернативы делают лучше), «Позиционирование» (в какой категории тебя ищут и с кем сравнивают) и «Цены». Файла нет — заведи из ~/.claude/templates/business-context.md.
Без него сравнение выйдет односторонним: получится досье на конкурента без колонки «мы», а именно эта колонка идёт потом в vs-страницу и в battlecard. Строку «что конкуренты делают лучше нас» не пропускай — на ней держится работа с возражениями.
Дальше используй references:
references/comparison-pages-ru.md — форматы сравнительных / alternative-страниц для SEO + продаж: «ваша академия vs другие курсы по AI», «AI-консультант vs нанять inhouse», «воркшоп vs самообучение», «Concierge vs прямые подписки». Шаблоны секций (TL;DR, цены в ₽, кому подходит, миграция). SEO/публикация — seo-machine-ru + tilda, FAQ-разметка — schema-markup-ru.
references/competitor-profiling-ru.md — профилирование RU-конкурентов в AI-образовании/консалтинге из их URL. Инструменты-замены: Яндекс Wordstat/Вебмастер + similarweb-analytics (вместо DataForSEO), otzovik/startpack/CNews/Яндекс Бизнес (вместо G2/Capterra). Шаблон профиля + сводка.
Связки: competitive-intelligence (sales-battlecard) · sales-enablement-ru · pricing-strategy-ru (анализ цен конкурентов).
Анализ рекламы конкурентов: для разведки рекламных кампаний/креативов конкурентов используй ad-spy (Facebook/Google/LinkedIn ad libraries + российские каналы Яндекс/VK/TG + Atria для Meta-креативов с оценкой бюджета). Этот скилл — про продуктовую/рыночную конкурентную разведку, ad-spy — про рекламную.
Competitive Research Methodology
Research Sources
Gather intelligence from these categories of sources:
Primary Sources (Direct from Competitor)
- Website: homepage, product pages, pricing, about page, careers
- Blog and resource center: content themes, publishing frequency, depth
- Social media profiles: messaging, engagement, content strategy
- Product demos and free trials: UX, features, onboarding experience
- Webinars and events: topics, speakers, audience engagement
- Press releases and newsroom: announcements, partnerships, milestones
- Job postings: hiring signals that reveal strategic priorities (e.g., hiring for a new product line or market)
Secondary Sources (Third-Party)
- Review sites: G2, Capterra, TrustRadius, Product Hunt — customer sentiment themes
- Analyst reports: Gartner, Forrester, IDC — market positioning and category placement
- News coverage: TechCrunch, industry publications — funding, partnerships, narrative
- Social listening: mentions, sentiment, share of voice across social platforms
- SEO tools: keyword rankings, organic traffic estimates, content gaps
- Financial filings: revenue, growth rate, investment areas (for public companies)
- Community forums: community forums (e.g. Reddit, Discourse), industry chat groups (e.g. Slack communities) — user sentiment
Research Process
- Set scope: define which competitors and what aspects to analyze
- Gather data: systematically collect information from sources above
- Organize findings: structure by competitor, then by dimension
- Analyze patterns: identify themes, strengths, weaknesses, and trends
- Compare to your position: map findings against your own positioning and capabilities
- Synthesize insights: extract actionable takeaways and opportunities
- Date-stamp everything: competitive intelligence has a short shelf life
Research Cadence
- Deep competitive analysis: quarterly (full research across all sources)
- Competitive monitoring: monthly (scan for new announcements, content, messaging changes)
- Real-time alerts: ongoing (set up alerts for competitor brand mentions, press, job postings)
Messaging Comparison Frameworks
Messaging Matrix
Compare messaging across competitors on key dimensions:
| Dimension |
Your Company |
Competitor A |
Competitor B |
Competitor C |
| Tagline/Headline |
|
|
|
|
| Core value proposition |
|
|
|
|
| Primary audience |
|
|
|
|
| Key differentiator claim |
|
|
|
|
| Tone/Voice |
|
|
|
|
| Proof points used |
|
|
|
|
| Category framing |
|
|
|
|
| Primary CTA |
|
|
|
|
Value Proposition Comparison
For each competitor, document:
- Promise: what they promise the customer will achieve
- Evidence: how they prove the promise (data, testimonials, demos)
- Mechanism: how their product delivers on the promise (the "how it works")
- Uniqueness: what they claim only they can do
Narrative Analysis
Identify each competitor's story arc:
- Villain: what problem or enemy they position against (status quo, legacy tools, complexity)
- Hero: who is the hero in their story (the customer? the product? the team?)
- Transformation: what before/after do they promise?
- Stakes: what happens if you do not act?
This reveals positioning strategy and emotional appeals.
Messaging Strengths and Vulnerabilities
For each competitor's messaging, assess:
- Clarity: can a first-time visitor understand what they do in 5 seconds?
- Differentiation: is their positioning distinct or generic?
- Proof: do they back up claims with evidence?
- Consistency: is messaging consistent across channels?
- Resonance: does their messaging address real customer pain points?
Content Gap Analysis
Content Audit Comparison
Map content across competitors by:
| Topic/Theme |
Your Content |
Competitor A |
Competitor B |
Gap? |
| [Topic 1] |
Blog post, ebook |
Blog series, webinar |
Nothing |
Opportunity for B |
| [Topic 2] |
Nothing |
Whitepaper |
Blog post, video |
Gap for you |
| [Topic 3] |
Case study |
Nothing |
Case study |
Parity |
Content Type Coverage
| Content Format |
You |
Comp A |
Comp B |
Comp C |
| Blog posts |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
| Case studies |
Y |
Y |
N |
Y |
| Ebooks/Whitepapers |
N |
Y |
Y |
N |
| Webinars |
Y |
Y |
Y |
N |
| Podcast |
N |
N |
Y |
N |
| Video content |
N |
Y |
Y |
Y |
| Interactive tools |
N |
N |
N |
Y |
| Templates/Resources |
Y |
N |
Y |
N |
Identifying Content Opportunities
- Topics they cover that you do not: potential gaps in your content strategy
- Topics you cover that they do not: potential differentiators to amplify
- Formats they use that you do not: format gaps that could reach new audiences
- Audience segments they address that you do not: underserved audiences
- Search terms they rank for that you do not: SEO content gaps
Content Quality Assessment
- Depth: surface-level or comprehensive?
- Freshness: regularly updated or stale?
- Engagement: do posts get comments, shares, links?
- Production value: text-only or multimedia?
- Thought leadership: original insights or rehashed content?
Positioning Strategy
Positioning Statement Framework
For your company and each competitor, define (or reverse-engineer) their positioning statement:
For [target audience], [product/company] is the [category] that [key benefit/differentiator] because [reason to believe].
Example:
For mid-market SaaS marketing teams, Acme is the campaign management platform that unifies planning and execution in one workspace because it is built on a single data model that eliminates tool fragmentation.
Positioning Map
Plot competitors on a 2x2 matrix using the two most important dimensions for your market:
Common axis pairs:
- Price vs. Capability (low cost / basic vs. premium / full-featured)
- Ease of Use vs. Power (simple / limited vs. complex / flexible)
- SMB Focus vs. Enterprise Focus (self-serve / individual vs. sales-led / team)
- Point Solution vs. Platform (does one thing well vs. does many things)
- Innovative vs. Established (new approach vs. proven track record)
Identify which quadrant is underserved or where your differentiation is strongest.
Category Strategy
- Create a new category: if you do something genuinely different, define and own the category (high risk, high reward)
- Reframe the existing category: change how buyers evaluate the category to favor your strengths
- Win the existing category: compete directly on recognized criteria and out-execute
- Niche within the category: own a specific segment, use case, or audience
Positioning Pitfalls to Avoid
- Positioning against a competitor rather than for a customer need
- Claiming too many differentiators (pick 1-2 that matter most)
- Using category jargon the customer does not use
- Positioning on features rather than outcomes
- Changing positioning too frequently (confuses the market)
Battlecard Creation
Battlecard Structure
A competitive battlecard is a one-page reference for sales and marketing teams. Include:
Header
- Competitor name and logo
- Last updated date
- Competitive win rate (if tracked)
Quick Overview
- What they do (one sentence)
- Their target customer
- Pricing model summary
- Key recent developments
Their Pitch
- How they describe themselves
- Their primary tagline
- Their top 3 claimed differentiators
Strengths (Be Honest)
- Where they genuinely compete well
- What customers like about them (from reviews)
- Features or capabilities where they lead
Weaknesses
- Consistent customer complaints (from reviews)
- Technical limitations
- Gaps in their offering
- Areas where customers report dissatisfaction
Our Differentiators
- 3-5 specific ways your product or approach is different
- For each: the differentiator, why it matters to the customer, and proof
Objection Handling
| If the prospect says... |
Respond with... |
| "[Competitor] does X too" |
"Here is how our approach differs..." |
| "[Competitor] is cheaper" |
"Here is what that price difference gets you..." |
| "I've heard good things about [Competitor]" |
"They are strong at X. Where we differ is..." |
Landmines to Set
Questions to ask prospects early that highlight your advantages:
- "How do you currently handle [area where competitor is weak]?"
- "How important is [capability you have that they lack]?"
- "Have you considered [risk that your product mitigates]?"
Landmines to Defuse
Questions competitors might encourage prospects to ask you, with prepared responses.
Win/Loss Themes
- Common reasons deals are won against this competitor
- Common reasons deals are lost to this competitor
- What types of prospects favor them vs. you
Battlecard Maintenance
- Review and update quarterly at minimum
- Update immediately after major competitor announcements
- Incorporate win/loss feedback from sales team
- Track which objection-handling responses are most effective
1---2name: competitive-analysis-mktg3description: "Конкуренты в маркетинге: месседжинг, контент-гэпы, vs/alternative-страницы под SEO. Триггеры: «vs страница», «профиль конкурента»."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/jhamidun/competitive-analysis-mktg6 version: 1.1.07 updated: 2026-05-298 ported_from: coreyhaines31/marketingskills (competitors + competitor-profiling references)9 reuses: seo-machine-ru, tilda, schema-markup-ru, similarweb-analytics, yandex10---1112# Competitive Analysis Skill1314Frameworks and methodologies for researching competitors, comparing positioning, and identifying market opportunities.1516## RU-расширения под свой бизнес1718**Перед началом прочитай `~/.claude/business-context.md`** — разделы «Продукт» (чем отличаешься и что альтернативы делают лучше), «Позиционирование» (в какой категории тебя ищут и с кем сравнивают) и «Цены». Файла нет — заведи из `~/.claude/templates/business-context.md`.1920Без него сравнение выйдет односторонним: получится досье на конкурента без колонки «мы», а именно эта колонка идёт потом в vs-страницу и в battlecard. Строку «что конкуренты делают лучше нас» не пропускай — на ней держится работа с возражениями.2122Дальше используй references:2324- **`references/comparison-pages-ru.md`** — форматы сравнительных / alternative-страниц для SEO + продаж: «ваша академия vs другие курсы по AI», «AI-консультант vs нанять inhouse», «воркшоп vs самообучение», «Concierge vs прямые подписки». Шаблоны секций (TL;DR, цены в ₽, кому подходит, миграция). SEO/публикация — `seo-machine-ru` + `tilda`, FAQ-разметка — `schema-markup-ru`.25- **`references/competitor-profiling-ru.md`** — профилирование RU-конкурентов в AI-образовании/консалтинге из их URL. Инструменты-замены: Яндекс Wordstat/Вебмастер + `similarweb-analytics` (вместо DataForSEO), otzovik/startpack/CNews/Яндекс Бизнес (вместо G2/Capterra). Шаблон профиля + сводка.2627Связки: `competitive-intelligence` (sales-battlecard) · `sales-enablement-ru` · `pricing-strategy-ru` (анализ цен конкурентов).2829> **Анализ рекламы конкурентов**: для разведки рекламных кампаний/креативов конкурентов используй `ad-spy` (Facebook/Google/LinkedIn ad libraries + российские каналы Яндекс/VK/TG + Atria для Meta-креативов с оценкой бюджета). Этот скилл — про продуктовую/рыночную конкурентную разведку, ad-spy — про рекламную.3031## Competitive Research Methodology3233### Research Sources3435Gather intelligence from these categories of sources:3637#### Primary Sources (Direct from Competitor)38- **Website**: homepage, product pages, pricing, about page, careers39- **Blog and resource center**: content themes, publishing frequency, depth40- **Social media profiles**: messaging, engagement, content strategy41- **Product demos and free trials**: UX, features, onboarding experience42- **Webinars and events**: topics, speakers, audience engagement43- **Press releases and newsroom**: announcements, partnerships, milestones44- **Job postings**: hiring signals that reveal strategic priorities (e.g., hiring for a new product line or market)4546#### Secondary Sources (Third-Party)47- **Review sites**: G2, Capterra, TrustRadius, Product Hunt — customer sentiment themes48- **Analyst reports**: Gartner, Forrester, IDC — market positioning and category placement49- **News coverage**: TechCrunch, industry publications — funding, partnerships, narrative50- **Social listening**: mentions, sentiment, share of voice across social platforms51- **SEO tools**: keyword rankings, organic traffic estimates, content gaps52- **Financial filings**: revenue, growth rate, investment areas (for public companies)53- **Community forums**: community forums (e.g. Reddit, Discourse), industry chat groups (e.g. Slack communities) — user sentiment5455### Research Process561. **Set scope**: define which competitors and what aspects to analyze572. **Gather data**: systematically collect information from sources above583. **Organize findings**: structure by competitor, then by dimension594. **Analyze patterns**: identify themes, strengths, weaknesses, and trends605. **Compare to your position**: map findings against your own positioning and capabilities616. **Synthesize insights**: extract actionable takeaways and opportunities627. **Date-stamp everything**: competitive intelligence has a short shelf life6364### Research Cadence65- **Deep competitive analysis**: quarterly (full research across all sources)66- **Competitive monitoring**: monthly (scan for new announcements, content, messaging changes)67- **Real-time alerts**: ongoing (set up alerts for competitor brand mentions, press, job postings)6869## Messaging Comparison Frameworks7071### Messaging Matrix7273Compare messaging across competitors on key dimensions:7475| Dimension | Your Company | Competitor A | Competitor B | Competitor C |76|-----------|-------------|--------------|--------------|--------------|77| Tagline/Headline | | | | |78| Core value proposition | | | | |79| Primary audience | | | | |80| Key differentiator claim | | | | |81| Tone/Voice | | | | |82| Proof points used | | | | |83| Category framing | | | | |84| Primary CTA | | | | |8586### Value Proposition Comparison8788For each competitor, document:89- **Promise**: what they promise the customer will achieve90- **Evidence**: how they prove the promise (data, testimonials, demos)91- **Mechanism**: how their product delivers on the promise (the "how it works")92- **Uniqueness**: what they claim only they can do9394### Narrative Analysis9596Identify each competitor's story arc:97- **Villain**: what problem or enemy they position against (status quo, legacy tools, complexity)98- **Hero**: who is the hero in their story (the customer? the product? the team?)99- **Transformation**: what before/after do they promise?100- **Stakes**: what happens if you do not act?101102This reveals positioning strategy and emotional appeals.103104### Messaging Strengths and Vulnerabilities105106For each competitor's messaging, assess:107- **Clarity**: can a first-time visitor understand what they do in 5 seconds?108- **Differentiation**: is their positioning distinct or generic?109- **Proof**: do they back up claims with evidence?110- **Consistency**: is messaging consistent across channels?111- **Resonance**: does their messaging address real customer pain points?112113## Content Gap Analysis114115### Content Audit Comparison116117Map content across competitors by:118119| Topic/Theme | Your Content | Competitor A | Competitor B | Gap? |120|-------------|-------------|--------------|--------------|------|121| [Topic 1] | Blog post, ebook | Blog series, webinar | Nothing | Opportunity for B |122| [Topic 2] | Nothing | Whitepaper | Blog post, video | Gap for you |123| [Topic 3] | Case study | Nothing | Case study | Parity |124125### Content Type Coverage126127| Content Format | You | Comp A | Comp B | Comp C |128|----------------|-----|--------|--------|--------|129| Blog posts | Y | Y | Y | Y |130| Case studies | Y | Y | N | Y |131| Ebooks/Whitepapers | N | Y | Y | N |132| Webinars | Y | Y | Y | N |133| Podcast | N | N | Y | N |134| Video content | N | Y | Y | Y |135| Interactive tools | N | N | N | Y |136| Templates/Resources | Y | N | Y | N |137138### Identifying Content Opportunities1391. **Topics they cover that you do not**: potential gaps in your content strategy1402. **Topics you cover that they do not**: potential differentiators to amplify1413. **Formats they use that you do not**: format gaps that could reach new audiences1424. **Audience segments they address that you do not**: underserved audiences1435. **Search terms they rank for that you do not**: SEO content gaps144145### Content Quality Assessment146- Depth: surface-level or comprehensive?147- Freshness: regularly updated or stale?148- Engagement: do posts get comments, shares, links?149- Production value: text-only or multimedia?150- Thought leadership: original insights or rehashed content?151152## Positioning Strategy153154### Positioning Statement Framework155156For your company and each competitor, define (or reverse-engineer) their positioning statement:157158> For [target audience], [product/company] is the [category] that [key benefit/differentiator] because [reason to believe].159160Example:161> For mid-market SaaS marketing teams, Acme is the campaign management platform that unifies planning and execution in one workspace because it is built on a single data model that eliminates tool fragmentation.162163### Positioning Map164165Plot competitors on a 2x2 matrix using the two most important dimensions for your market:166167Common axis pairs:168- **Price vs. Capability** (low cost / basic vs. premium / full-featured)169- **Ease of Use vs. Power** (simple / limited vs. complex / flexible)170- **SMB Focus vs. Enterprise Focus** (self-serve / individual vs. sales-led / team)171- **Point Solution vs. Platform** (does one thing well vs. does many things)172- **Innovative vs. Established** (new approach vs. proven track record)173174Identify which quadrant is underserved or where your differentiation is strongest.175176### Category Strategy177- **Create a new category**: if you do something genuinely different, define and own the category (high risk, high reward)178- **Reframe the existing category**: change how buyers evaluate the category to favor your strengths179- **Win the existing category**: compete directly on recognized criteria and out-execute180- **Niche within the category**: own a specific segment, use case, or audience181182### Positioning Pitfalls to Avoid183- Positioning against a competitor rather than for a customer need184- Claiming too many differentiators (pick 1-2 that matter most)185- Using category jargon the customer does not use186- Positioning on features rather than outcomes187- Changing positioning too frequently (confuses the market)188189## Battlecard Creation190191### Battlecard Structure192193A competitive battlecard is a one-page reference for sales and marketing teams. Include:194195#### Header196- Competitor name and logo197- Last updated date198- Competitive win rate (if tracked)199200#### Quick Overview201- What they do (one sentence)202- Their target customer203- Pricing model summary204- Key recent developments205206#### Their Pitch207- How they describe themselves208- Their primary tagline209- Their top 3 claimed differentiators210211#### Strengths (Be Honest)212- Where they genuinely compete well213- What customers like about them (from reviews)214- Features or capabilities where they lead215216#### Weaknesses217- Consistent customer complaints (from reviews)218- Technical limitations219- Gaps in their offering220- Areas where customers report dissatisfaction221222#### Our Differentiators223- 3-5 specific ways your product or approach is different224- For each: the differentiator, why it matters to the customer, and proof225226#### Objection Handling227| If the prospect says... | Respond with... |228|------------------------|----------------|229| "[Competitor] does X too" | "Here is how our approach differs..." |230| "[Competitor] is cheaper" | "Here is what that price difference gets you..." |231| "I've heard good things about [Competitor]" | "They are strong at X. Where we differ is..." |232233#### Landmines to Set234Questions to ask prospects early that highlight your advantages:235- "How do you currently handle [area where competitor is weak]?"236- "How important is [capability you have that they lack]?"237- "Have you considered [risk that your product mitigates]?"238239#### Landmines to Defuse240Questions competitors might encourage prospects to ask you, with prepared responses.241242#### Win/Loss Themes243- Common reasons deals are won against this competitor244- Common reasons deals are lost to this competitor245- What types of prospects favor them vs. you246247### Battlecard Maintenance248- Review and update quarterly at minimum249- Update immediately after major competitor announcements250- Incorporate win/loss feedback from sales team251- Track which objection-handling responses are most effective