Jiachen-T-Wang Instruction Tuning with GPT-4
One-line decision
Use this skill when you want to generate high-quality instruction data using GPT-4 for fine-tuning smaller models. Avoid it when you cannot afford GPT-4 API calls or have sufficient human-written data.
Skill metadata
- Skill type: gpt4-instruction-distillation
- Paper kind: operational-method
- Actionability: high
- Evidence quality: full_paper
Goal
Generate high-quality instruction-following data using GPT-4, producing both English and Chinese instruction datasets for training smaller models.
Problem signature
- Modality: text instruction-response pairs from GPT-4.
- Data state: 52K GPT-4-generated instruction-response pairs.
- Scale regime: 52K instruction samples.
- Model requirement: GPT-4 for generation; any LLM for fine-tuning.
Use when
- You want high-quality instruction data from GPT-4.
- You need instruction data in English and Chinese.
- You are fine-tuning a smaller model.
Do not use when
- You cannot afford GPT-4 API calls.
- You have sufficient human-written instruction data.
- You need domain-specific instructions GPT-4 cannot generate.
Required inputs
- gpt4_api: GPT-4 for generating instruction-response pairs.
- seed_instructions: Seed instructions for prompting GPT-4.
- language_config: Configuration for English and/or Chinese generation.
Optional inputs
- quality_filter: Filter for removing low-quality generations.
Outputs
- gpt4_instructions: 52K GPT-4-generated instruction samples.
- fine_tuned_model: Model trained on GPT-4 instruction data.
Assumptions and prerequisites
- GPT-4 generates higher quality instruction data than GPT-3.5.
- Quality instruction data from GPT-4 enables effective distillation.
- Both English and Chinese benefit from GPT-4 instruction generation.
Procedure
- Design instruction prompts Action: Create prompts for diverse instruction generation. Why: Prompt design controls instruction diversity and quality. Note: See paper for details.
- Generate with GPT-4 Action: Use GPT-4 to generate instruction-response pairs. Why: GPT-4 produces higher quality than weaker models. Note: See paper for details.
- Quality filter Action: Remove low-quality or harmful generations. Why: Basic filtering ensures data quality. Note: See paper for details.
- Fine-tune smaller model Action: Train a smaller model on GPT-4 instruction data. Why: Distills GPT-4's instruction-following to a smaller model. Note: See paper for details.
Parameters to set
- generation_model — Role: LLM for instruction generation. How to set: Use GPT-4 for highest quality. Default/range: GPT-4. Effect: Better teacher produces better instruction data.
- sample_count — Role: Number of instruction samples. How to set: 52K for diverse coverage. Default/range: 52K. Effect: More samples improve instruction diversity.
Validation checks
- GPT-4-generated data should produce better students than GPT-3.5 data.
- Instruction quality should be higher than Self-Instruct.
- The fine-tuned model should follow diverse instructions.
Failure modes
- GPT-4 API costs are significant.
- Generated data inherits GPT-4's biases.
- Some instruction types may be poorly generated.
Adaptation notes for VLM training
- Extend to visual instruction generation for VLMs.
- Replace GPT-4 with Claude for alternative instruction generation.
- Combine with Evol-Instruct for complexity scaling.
Implementation notes
- Batch API calls for cost efficiency.
- Generate in both English and Chinese for multilingual coverage.
- Compare GPT-4 vs GPT-3.5 instruction quality.
Evidence from the paper
- GPT-4 instruction data produces significantly better student models than GPT-3.5 data.
- 52K GPT-4-generated instructions cover diverse task types.
- The quality gap between GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 instruction data is significant.
- Instruction tuning with GPT-4 data is a standard practice.
Source paper
- Title: Instruction Tuning with GPT-4
- Year: 2023
- Venue: arXiv
- Paper ID: arxiv-2304.03277v1
- URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.03277v1
- arXiv ID: 2304.03277v1