Scaling Instruction Finetuned Language Models Arxiv 2210 11416v5

Scaling Instruction-Finetuned Language Models

One-line decision

Use this skill when you want to understand how to scale instruction fine-tuning across number of tasks, model size, and chain-of-thought data for maximum benefit. Avoid it when you are doing single-task fine-tuning.

Skill metadata

• Skill type: instruction-finetuning-at-scale
• Paper kind: operational-method
• Actionability: high
• Evidence quality: full_paper

Goal

Study the scaling behavior of instruction fine-tuning (Flan) across three dimensions: number of tasks, model size, and inclusion of chain-of-thought data, providing guidance for optimal instruction tuning at scale.

Problem signature

• Modality: text instruction data across 1,836 tasks.
• Data state: 1,836 tasks formatted as instructions with optional chain-of-thought.
• Scale regime: 1,836 tasks scaling up to 540B parameters.
• Model requirement: PaLM models at various scales for scaling studies.

Use when

• You want to understand instruction tuning scaling laws.
• You are designing a multi-task instruction tuning recipe.
• You want to add chain-of-thought data to instruction tuning.

Do not use when

• You are doing single-task fine-tuning.
• You have a fixed, small instruction dataset.
• You cannot run scaling experiments.

Required inputs

• task_collection: 1,836 tasks formatted as instructions.
• scaling_models: Models at multiple scales for ablation.
• cot_data: Chain-of-thought data for selected tasks.

Optional inputs

• task_mixing: Mixing ratios across task categories.

Outputs

• scaling_insights: Insights on instruction tuning scaling behavior.
• flan_palm: Instruction-tuned PaLM models.

Assumptions and prerequisites

• More tasks improve instruction-following generalization.
• Larger models benefit more from instruction tuning.
• Chain-of-thought data improves reasoning capabilities.

Procedure

1. Aggregate 1,836 tasks Action: Collect and format 1,836 tasks as instruction-response pairs. Why: Massive task diversity improves generalization. Note: See paper for details.
2. Add chain-of-thought data Action: Include step-by-step reasoning for 9 tasks. Why: CoT data teaches reasoning process. Note: See paper for details.
3. Scale across dimensions Action: Vary number of tasks, model size, and CoT inclusion. Why: Systematic scaling reveals optimal configurations. Note: See paper for details.
4. Evaluate generalization Action: Test on held-out tasks and benchmarks. Why: Measures instruction-following generalization. Note: See paper for details.

Parameters to set

• num_tasks — Role: Number of instruction tasks. How to set: As many as available. Default/range: 1836. Effect: More tasks improve generalization.
• model_scale — Role: Model parameter count. How to set: Larger models benefit more. Default/range: 8B-540B. Effect: Larger models show bigger gains from instruction tuning.
• cot_inclusion — Role: Whether to include chain-of-thought data. How to set: Include CoT for reasoning tasks. Default/range: 9 CoT tasks. Effect: CoT significantly improves reasoning.

Validation checks

• More tasks should improve held-out task performance.
• Larger models should show bigger gains from instruction tuning.
• CoT data should improve reasoning benchmarks.

Failure modes

• Too many low-quality tasks may dilute training signal.
• Task mixing ratios need careful tuning.
• CoT benefits may be limited to reasoning-specific tasks.

Adaptation notes for VLM training

• Flan's scaling insights apply to VLM instruction tuning.
• Include CoT data for VLM reasoning improvement.
• The task diversity principle applies to multimodal instruction data.

Implementation notes

• Use Flan templates for instruction formatting.
• Balance task sampling during training.
• Track per-task performance for analysis.

Evidence from the paper

• Scaling instruction tuning to 1,836 tasks significantly improves generalization.
• Larger models benefit more from instruction tuning.
• Chain-of-thought data substantially improves reasoning capabilities.
• Flan-PaLM 540B achieves state-of-the-art on multiple benchmarks.

Source paper

• Title: Scaling Instruction-Finetuned Language Models
• Year: 2022
• Venue: JMLR
• Paper ID: arxiv-2210.11416v5
• URL: http://arxiv.org/abs/2210.11416v5
• arXiv ID: 2210.11416v5