Ideation
Overview
Two different jobs hide under "brainstorming": generating many options, and cutting them down to a few worth testing. They must not share a meeting, because judgment kills generation. This skill runs both as separate passes: frame the question, diverge, converge, capture, and leave a written record so the session survives its own author.
When to use
- Someone asks for options: "brainstorm this", "generate options", "we need ideas", "how might we".
- A team or a solo operator is stuck and needs a wider set of alternatives before choosing.
- A long list of ideas needs to be shortlisted honestly, with scores and a next test.
When NOT to use
Attacking an existing plan is outside; ac-interrogation covers that. Writing requirements is outside; ac-spec-writing covers that. Deciding alone is outside: this skill produces options and a shortlist, never the decision. A routine single-answer question needs one idea, not a session.
Subskill index
| Leaf | Domain segment | Scope (one line) |
|---|---|---|
subskills/framing-the-question.md |
critical-thinking/framing-the-question |
Turn a topic into a decision brief: the decision, the decider, walls versus fences, and the scope |
subskills/divergence-rules.md |
critical-thinking/divergence-rules |
Rules that raise quantity and variety: defer judgment, build on others, silence-then-share, a quota |
subskills/prompt-techniques.md |
critical-thinking/prompt-techniques |
A technique bank with when-to-use: SCAMPER, analogy, inversion, constraints, worst-idea flip, morphology, 10x |
subskills/nominal-group.md |
critical-thinking/nominal-group |
Structured convergence without anchoring: silent generation, round-robin, clarification only, independent ranking |
subskills/convergence-scoring.md |
critical-thinking/convergence-scoring |
Filtering: criteria before scoring, coarse scales, now/later/two-list, kill criteria, the cheap-test tiebreak |
subskills/idea-capture.md |
critical-thinking/idea-capture |
Normalize each survivor to one line plus a so-that clause, its assumption, and its cheapest test |
subskills/session-record.md |
critical-thinking/session-record |
The record: question, constraints, honest count, clusters, shortlist with scores, decisions, next test |
Status and honest limits
- Seedling: built from the public canon cited in each leaf; the full pass order has not been stress-tested across many live sessions.
- The skill raises the quantity and quality of options and makes the shortlist defensible. It does not make the choice, and it cannot guarantee a good idea exists in the space searched.
- The quantity rules rest partly on lab studies of face-to-face groups (⚠️, divergence-rules); treat those as directional, not law.