Interrogation
Overview
The craft of interrogating an idea, plan, spec, or decision before commitment: the "grill me" pattern. The reader runs a structured session that reads the plan cold, surfaces assumptions, tests evidence, maps failure modes, forces alternatives, and then closes on purpose. The output is a revised plan plus a written record, not a verdict from the questioner.
When to use
- Someone asks to be grilled: "grill me on my plan", "stress-test this idea", "poke holes in this", "what am I missing".
- A decision is approaching commitment and nobody has attacked it yet.
- An idea feels settled too early, or its author cannot state what would change their mind.
When NOT to use
Reviewing an existing artifact is outside; ac-code-review covers that. Open-ended research is outside; ac-deep-researcher covers that. Writing requirements is outside; ac-spec-writing covers that. Routine two-way-door choices with small stakes need one question, not a session.
Subskill index
| Leaf |
domain segment |
scope (one line) |
subskills/interrogation-protocol.md |
critical-thinking/interrogation-protocol |
Session order and pacing: purpose, assumptions, evidence, failure modes, alternatives, commitment; serial vs batch; time-box |
subskills/question-craft.md |
critical-thinking/question-craft |
How to ask: past behaviour over hypotheticals, "what would have to be true", open vs leading questions, follow-up probes, silence |
subskills/assumption-audit.md |
critical-thinking/assumption-audit |
Inventory unstated assumptions; separate load-bearing from incidental; premise check; cheap tests; confidence labels |
subskills/failure-mapping.md |
critical-thinking/failure-mapping |
Pre-mortem, inversion, weakest link, reference-class base rates, and the failure that actually ends the plan |
subskills/evidence-dial.md |
critical-thinking/evidence-dial |
Evidence that exists vs evidence needed; falsification test; decide-vs-research-more gate; calibrated confidence |
subskills/alternative-forcing.md |
critical-thinking/alternative-forcing |
At least three alternatives including do-nothing; one-way vs two-way doors; opportunity cost; fake alternatives |
subskills/steelman-discipline.md |
critical-thinking/steelman-discipline |
Steelman before attacking; attack the strongest version; separate person from proposition; straw-man and motte-and-bailey traps |
subskills/close-and-stop.md |
critical-thinking/close-and-stop |
When to stop: repeated answers, diminishing returns, decision ready, fatigue; anti-loop cap; assumption ledger; kill criteria |
Status and honest limits
- Seedling: built from the public canon cited in each leaf; the full session order has not yet been stress-tested across many live grilling sessions.
- The protocol produces better questions and a written record. It does not produce certainty; the plan owner still decides.
- Questioning works on a willing subject. Against someone defending a fixed position, the session can only surface the disagreement, not resolve it.
1---2name: ac-interrogation3description: "Interrogate an idea, plan, or decision before commitment: structured questioning that surfaces assumptions, maps failure modes, tests evidence, forces alternatives, and closes without looping. Eight leaves: interrogation-protocol (session order, cold read, time-box), question-craft (past behaviour over hypotheticals, follow-ups), assumption-audit (load-bearing assumptions, confidence labels), failure-mapping (pre-mortem, inversion, base rates), evidence-dial (falsification test, decide-vs-research gate), alternative-forcing (three alternatives plus do-nothing), steelman-discipline (attack the strongest version), close-and-stop (stop criteria, anti-loop cap, assumption ledger, kill criteria). Use when asking 'grill me on my plan', 'stress-test this idea', 'poke holes in this', 'interrogate this decision', 'what am I missing', 'challenge my assumptions'. Not for: reviewing an existing artifact (use ac-code-review), open-ended research (use ac-deep-researcher), or writing requirements (use ac-spec-writing)."4license: MIT5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/jiayaoqijia/ac-interrogation7 domain: critical-thinking8---910# Interrogation1112## Overview1314The craft of interrogating an idea, plan, spec, or decision before commitment: the "grill me" pattern. The reader runs a structured session that reads the plan cold, surfaces assumptions, tests evidence, maps failure modes, forces alternatives, and then closes on purpose. The output is a revised plan plus a written record, not a verdict from the questioner.1516## When to use1718- Someone asks to be grilled: "grill me on my plan", "stress-test this idea", "poke holes in this", "what am I missing".19- A decision is approaching commitment and nobody has attacked it yet.20- An idea feels settled too early, or its author cannot state what would change their mind.2122## When NOT to use2324Reviewing an existing artifact is outside; ac-code-review covers that. Open-ended research is outside; ac-deep-researcher covers that. Writing requirements is outside; ac-spec-writing covers that. Routine two-way-door choices with small stakes need one question, not a session.2526## Subskill index2728| Leaf | domain segment | scope (one line) |29|---|---|---|30| `subskills/interrogation-protocol.md` | `critical-thinking/interrogation-protocol` | Session order and pacing: purpose, assumptions, evidence, failure modes, alternatives, commitment; serial vs batch; time-box |31| `subskills/question-craft.md` | `critical-thinking/question-craft` | How to ask: past behaviour over hypotheticals, "what would have to be true", open vs leading questions, follow-up probes, silence |32| `subskills/assumption-audit.md` | `critical-thinking/assumption-audit` | Inventory unstated assumptions; separate load-bearing from incidental; premise check; cheap tests; confidence labels |33| `subskills/failure-mapping.md` | `critical-thinking/failure-mapping` | Pre-mortem, inversion, weakest link, reference-class base rates, and the failure that actually ends the plan |34| `subskills/evidence-dial.md` | `critical-thinking/evidence-dial` | Evidence that exists vs evidence needed; falsification test; decide-vs-research-more gate; calibrated confidence |35| `subskills/alternative-forcing.md` | `critical-thinking/alternative-forcing` | At least three alternatives including do-nothing; one-way vs two-way doors; opportunity cost; fake alternatives |36| `subskills/steelman-discipline.md` | `critical-thinking/steelman-discipline` | Steelman before attacking; attack the strongest version; separate person from proposition; straw-man and motte-and-bailey traps |37| `subskills/close-and-stop.md` | `critical-thinking/close-and-stop` | When to stop: repeated answers, diminishing returns, decision ready, fatigue; anti-loop cap; assumption ledger; kill criteria |3839## Status and honest limits4041- Seedling: built from the public canon cited in each leaf; the full session order has not yet been stress-tested across many live grilling sessions.42- The protocol produces better questions and a written record. It does not produce certainty; the plan owner still decides.43- Questioning works on a willing subject. Against someone defending a fixed position, the session can only surface the disagreement, not resolve it.