Tax-aware investing
Overview
Tax is not a separate topic from portfolio construction; it is a constraint on every decision that involves selling, holding, or choosing where an asset lives. Two portfolios with identical holdings can deliver materially different after-tax outcomes depending on which account holds what, when gains are realised, and how losses are used — and those choices are made before the return is known.
This skill frames those choices and the arithmetic behind them. It does not compute a liability, does not interpret a jurisdiction's rules, and does not replace a professional. What it does is make the trade-offs explicit: the value of deferral, the cost of a wash-sale reset, the price of liquidity in a taxable account, and the fact that a tax decision is a portfolio decision with a deadline.
Primary sources: https://www.irs.gov/ and https://www.investor.gov/introduction-investing.
When to use
- When deciding which account should hold which asset.
- When a loss is available and harvesting is being considered.
- When rebalancing would realise gains.
- When a disposition is being planned and the route matters.
When NOT to use
- For assembling records and a tax pack (use ac-trading-records-and-tax).
- For retirement withdrawal arithmetic (use ac-retirement-and-drawdown).
- For a specific jurisdiction's rules presented as advice: consult a professional.
Subskill Index
| Leaf | Domain segment | Scope (one line) |
|---|---|---|
subskills/asset-location.md |
investing/asset-location |
Which assets belong in taxable, deferred, and exempt accounts. |
subskills/loss-harvesting.md |
investing/loss-harvesting |
Realising losses, the wash-sale trap, and the basis reset. |
subskills/gain-deferral.md |
investing/gain-deferral |
Holding period effects, deferral value, and the step-up question. |
subskills/charitable-routes.md |
investing/charitable-routes |
Donating appreciated assets and the vehicles that hold them. |
subskills/rebalancing-with-tax.md |
investing/rebalancing-with-tax |
Rebalancing with new money, in-kind, and the realised-gain cost. |
subskills/withdrawal-ordering.md |
investing/withdrawal-ordering |
Which account to draw from, and the bracket interaction. |
subskills/tax-aware-policy.md |
investing/tax-aware-policy |
The written policy: location rules, harvesting rules, and review triggers. |
Status and honest limits
Tax rules are jurisdictional, change with legislation, and depend on facts a skill cannot see. Every figure here is arithmetic on assumptions rather than a liability, and a decision that matters should be checked with a professional who can see the whole position. The wider caution is that tax should not drive an investment into a worse one: a deferral that requires holding an unsuitable asset is a saving measured against a larger loss.