Valuation
Overview
A valuation is an argument whose conclusion is a number. The number is the least important part; the assumptions that move it are the analysis. Two analysts can agree on every fact and disagree by a factor of three because they assume different growth, margins, or discount rates — and the useful output is not a point estimate but a range tied to named assumptions.
This skill builds valuations that can be checked and falsified. It does not produce recommendations, and it does not pretend that precision is accuracy: a model that reports a value to the cent has hidden its assumptions behind arithmetic.
Primary sources: https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/ and https://www.sec.gov/edgar/search/.
When to use
- After research has established that the reported numbers are trustworthy.
- When comparing two businesses as candidates for capital.
- When a held position's price implies assumptions worth testing.
- Before writing any purchase or sale memo.
When NOT to use
- Before the financial statements and red flags have been examined (use ac-equity-research).
- For deciding how much of the portfolio a position may occupy (use ac-investment-policy-statement).
- For pricing a crypto token's supply schedule (use ac-token-diligence).
Subskill Index
| Leaf |
Domain segment |
Scope (one line) |
subskills/valuation-methods.md |
investing/valuation-methods |
Discounted cash flow, multiples, asset-based, and sum-of-parts, and when each is the honest choice. |
subskills/dcf-construction.md |
investing/dcf-construction |
Forecast horizon, cash-flow definition, discount rate, and terminal value, built with assumption discipline. |
subskills/multiples.md |
investing/multiples |
Peer selection, multiple choice, and why every multiple embeds a set of assumptions. |
subskills/terminal-value-and-growth.md |
investing/terminal-value-and-growth |
Why terminal assumptions dominate the answer, and the sanity checks that keep them honest. |
subskills/discount-rate.md |
investing/discount-rate |
Cost of capital, risk-free rate, equity premium, and the sensitivity that follows from beta. |
subskills/scenarios-and-sensitivity.md |
investing/scenarios-and-sensitivity |
Bull, base, and bear cases as driver tables, and the sensitivity that shows what actually moves the value. |
subskills/valuation-record.md |
investing/valuation-record |
The written valuation: assumptions, outputs, ranges, and the facts that would falsify it. |
Status and honest limits
Every valuation is wrong, and the useful ones are wrong in a stated direction with stated bounds. Discounted cash flow rewards precision it does not have; multiples are shortcuts that hide their assumptions; and a terminal value that grows faster than the economy forever is a modelling error, not an assumption. Record the range, name the drivers, and treat the output as a hypothesis about the future rather than a fact about the present.
1---2name: ac-valuation3description: "Estimating what a business is worth and stating the assumptions that carry the answer: choosing a method, constructing a discounted cash-flow model, using multiples honestly, terminal value and growth discipline, cost of capital, scenarios and sensitivity, and the written valuation record with its falsifiers. It produces ranges and assumptions, never a price target recommendation. Use when asking \"what is this worth\", \"run a DCF\", \"which multiple\", \"discount rate\", \"terminal value\", \"valuation model\". Not for gathering the underlying facts (ac-equity-research), not for allocation policy (ac-investment-policy-statement), not for trade sizing (ac-crypto-trading-discipline)."4license: MIT5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/jiayaoqijia/ac-valuation7 domain: investing8status: seedling9---1011# Valuation1213## Overview1415A valuation is an argument whose conclusion is a number. The number is the least important part; the assumptions that move it are the analysis. Two analysts can agree on every fact and disagree by a factor of three because they assume different growth, margins, or discount rates — and the useful output is not a point estimate but a range tied to named assumptions.1617This skill builds valuations that can be checked and falsified. It does not produce recommendations, and it does not pretend that precision is accuracy: a model that reports a value to the cent has hidden its assumptions behind arithmetic.1819Primary sources: <https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/> and <https://www.sec.gov/edgar/search/>.2021## When to use2223- After research has established that the reported numbers are trustworthy.24- When comparing two businesses as candidates for capital.25- When a held position's price implies assumptions worth testing.26- Before writing any purchase or sale memo.2728## When NOT to use2930- Before the financial statements and red flags have been examined (use ac-equity-research).31- For deciding how much of the portfolio a position may occupy (use ac-investment-policy-statement).32- For pricing a crypto token's supply schedule (use ac-token-diligence).3334## Subskill Index3536| Leaf | Domain segment | Scope (one line) |37|---|---|---|38| `subskills/valuation-methods.md` | `investing/valuation-methods` | Discounted cash flow, multiples, asset-based, and sum-of-parts, and when each is the honest choice. |39| `subskills/dcf-construction.md` | `investing/dcf-construction` | Forecast horizon, cash-flow definition, discount rate, and terminal value, built with assumption discipline. |40| `subskills/multiples.md` | `investing/multiples` | Peer selection, multiple choice, and why every multiple embeds a set of assumptions. |41| `subskills/terminal-value-and-growth.md` | `investing/terminal-value-and-growth` | Why terminal assumptions dominate the answer, and the sanity checks that keep them honest. |42| `subskills/discount-rate.md` | `investing/discount-rate` | Cost of capital, risk-free rate, equity premium, and the sensitivity that follows from beta. |43| `subskills/scenarios-and-sensitivity.md` | `investing/scenarios-and-sensitivity` | Bull, base, and bear cases as driver tables, and the sensitivity that shows what actually moves the value. |44| `subskills/valuation-record.md` | `investing/valuation-record` | The written valuation: assumptions, outputs, ranges, and the facts that would falsify it. |4546## Status and honest limits4748Every valuation is wrong, and the useful ones are wrong in a stated direction with stated bounds. Discounted cash flow rewards precision it does not have; multiples are shortcuts that hide their assumptions; and a terminal value that grows faster than the economy forever is a modelling error, not an assumption. Record the range, name the drivers, and treat the output as a hypothesis about the future rather than a fact about the present.