Arbitrate Conflicting Children
Two children disagreeing is information, not noise. Resolve it by weighing their evidence against the same standard — never by averaging claims or trusting the more confident voice.
Procedure
- Restate each child's claim as a single falsifiable sentence, side by side.
- Find what the claims actually disagree about: method, source, scope, or a definition. Many conflicts dissolve once the axis is named.
- Check each child against its brief: a child that answered a different question is not a valid comparator.
- Ask each for its evidence — the command run, its output, the source — not just the conclusion.
- Re-run the decisive check yourself, once, from a neutral process, so neither child's log is taken on faith.
- Prefer the claim backed by a reproducible command over the claim backed by reasoning alone.
- If the evidence is genuinely symmetric, examine scope: the narrower, more testable claim usually wins.
- Where they conflict on a fact neither can settle, mark it UNRESOLVED and escalate; do not fabricate a tiebreak.
- Write the decision and its basis in
notes/arbitration.md: axis, winner, evidence, loser-dismissed-because. - Feed the resolution back so descendants do not re-litigate the same conflict.
Pitfalls
- Averaging two contradictory numbers into a third that no child computed and no evidence supports.
- Picking the child whose message sounded more confident or ran longer.
- Letting the child that reported last win, when order has nothing to do with correctness.
- Declaring a tie and shipping both values, leaving the consumer to guess.
- Resolving on a definition dispute without noticing the children meant different things by the same word.
Verification
test -s notes/arbitration.md && grep -c 'evidence' notes/arbitration.md
# passes when the decision names the axis, the winning evidence, and the re-run command
Report to the user: the axis of disagreement, the winner with its evidence, and any fact left UNRESOLVED.