Edit Your Own Slop
First drafts read as slop for mechanical reasons: empty openers, hedge stacking, and abstract nouns where a number or a name belongs. Fix them by rule.
Procedure
- Delete the first sentence of every section; it is almost always throat-clearing that restates the heading. Read from sentence two and see if meaning survives.
- Strike stock phrases on sight: "note that", "it should be noted", "plays a crucial role", "in order to" (use "to"). Keep a list of your own repeated openers.
- Replace abstract nouns with verbs: "provide assistance to" becomes "help"; "perform a review of" becomes "review".
- Cut adverbs and intensifiers that carry no measurement: "very", "quite", "extremely", "significantly", "robustly". If it matters, give the number.
- Hunt the tricolon and four-item lists that only pad; if two items suffice, keep two.
- Find every sentence over 30 words and split it, or delete its weakest clause.
- Kill nominalisations: "utilise" becomes "use", "leverage" becomes "use".
- Replace a claim with its evidence: "much faster" becomes "3.1s to 0.4s". One concrete figure beats a paragraph of adjectives.
- Remove the hedge that fills space but asserts nothing, while keeping the hedge that carries real uncertainty.
- Read it aloud; every place you stumble is a sentence to rewrite.
- Diff against the draft to confirm the word count fell and no required fact was dropped.
Pitfalls
- Over-editing into clipped fragments that lose the connective logic between ideas.
- Removing the hedge that carried genuine uncertainty ("roughly 40%") and asserting a false precision.
- Making everything terse so the tone reads as curt rather than clear.
- Rewriting to match a style guide at the cost of meaning.
- Trusting a spellchecker over the read-aloud, which catches clause pileup the checker ignores.
- Trading a long word for a shorter synonym that changes the technical meaning.
- Deleting a caveat because it weakened the sentence, then shipping the overstated claim.
Verification
wc -w draft.md final.md
grep -niE "note that|it should be noted|plays a crucial role" final.md
The word count must fall and the grep must return nothing. Report the before/after count and the deleted filler phrases by name.