Review a plan before committing
Committing a plan you have not audited is how you inherit surprises. Run the same checklist every time, so the gaps that matter — an unbounded assumption, an unpriced dependency, a missing done-definition — are caught before the plan leaves your hands, not after.
Procedure
Work the checklist in
notes/plan-review.mdagainst the plan file. Each line must have a real answer or be explicitly waived:notes/plan-review.md [ ] every estimate is a range with a confidence [ ] each assumption is written with a date and status [ ] each external dependency has owner + lead time + trigger [ ] buffer exists and is sized, not round [ ] done-definition is testable; exclusions listed [ ] critical path identified; nearest slack known [ ] risks priced or spiked; top risk has a fallback [ ] a confidence date is stated, not a promiseFor any unchecked line, fix it now or record the waiver and why. A waiver is a note in the file, not a silent gap.
Verify the plan is internally consistent with one script, not by reading:
python3 - <<'PY' import re t=open('notes/plan.md').read() for h in ['assumption','deadline','milestone','scope v']: print(h, t.lower().count(h)) PYSanity-check the summary number against the parts (sum of ranges vs stated total).
Run a pre-mortem on the top three risks: "it is three months later and this failed — why?" Add mitigations for any answer not already covered.
Only after every line is answered or waived do you commit the plan to stakeholders.
Pitfalls
- Reviewing your own plan alone under deadline and rubber-stamping the comfortable items.
- Treating an unchecked line as "probably fine" instead of fixing or explicitly waiving it.
- Checking structure (headings present) while missing substance (an assumption with no date).
- Pre-mortems that list only tidy risks, omitting the uncomfortable ones nobody wants to name.
- Committing the plan and doing the review "after," which is just documenting a decision already made.
Verification
python3 - <<'PY'
import re
t=open('notes/plan-review.md').read()
print('open_items', t.count('[ ]'), 'waived', t.lower().count('waiver'))
PY
# passes when open_items minus waived equals zero before the plan is committed
Report the checklist with each line's answer or waiver, the internal-consistency check output, and the top three pre-mortem risks.