Tear down a competitor price sheet
A competitor's headline price is a marketing number, not a comparison. Normalise both sides to the same unit, seat count and term before drawing any conclusion from it.
Procedure
Capture the full sheet, not the headline: base price, per-seat or per-usage rates, overages, onboarding, support tier, and minimum term.
Normalise the unit. Vendor A charges $99 per seat with a 20-seat minimum; Vendor B charges $2,400 a month flat for "unlimited". Turn both into cost per active user per month.
Normalise the term. An annual prepay at $990/seat is $82.50/seat/month only if you use it all twelve months; a nine-month user pays $110.00/seat/month.
Add the add-ons people actually buy: onboarding, SSO, priority support. A $99 headline often lands past $130 with the governance features a serious account needs.
Compute the like-for-like three-year total for a stated profile, say 40 users:
``` python3 -c "from decimal import Decimal as D A=D('99')*40*36 + D('2000'); B=D('2400')*36 print(A, B)" # 144560 vs 86400 minor-unit dollars -> A is 67% dearer over three years ```Confirm the profile matches real usage; the crossover often sits at a seat count where per-seat pricing loses to flat pricing.
Solve for the crossover: the seat count where per-seat total equals flat total, and hand it to sales as a competitive fact.
Keep both sheets as integer minor units with the unit and term recorded; a float per-seat figure times seats drifts the crossover seat count.
Check the "unlimited" clause for fair-use caps before treating it as unbounded.
Re-run quarterly; headline prices change and the add-on list changes more.
Pitfalls
- Comparing headline to headline and missing the add-ons that flip the ranking.
- Ignoring the term; a monthly list price against an annual prepay is not a comparison.
- Picking a seat count that flatters your own pricing rather than the profile customers have.
- Forgetting onboarding, which is often 10-20% of first-year cost.
- Assuming "unlimited" is unlimited without reading the fair-use clause.
- Float per-seat figures that drift the crossover seat count.
Verification
```
python3 -c "from decimal import Decimal as D; print(D('99')*40*36+D('2000'), D('2400')*36)"
# 144560 vs 86400 -> the three-year gap at the stated profile
```
Pass when both sheets share a unit, a term and a named profile. Report the like-for-like total, the add-ons included, and the crossover seat count.