Triangulate Independent Sources
A claim is only as strong as the number of independent places it survives. Two articles quoting the same press release are one source, not two.
Procedure
- List every load-bearing factual claim in the answer. A claim is load-bearing when deleting it changes the conclusion.
- For each claim record: URL, publisher, named author, publication date, and — critically — the origin that source cites.
- Trace citations to their root. Run
curl -sL "<url>" | grep -oE 'https?://[^" ]+' | head, then follow the first upstream link. If two sources resolve to the same root document, count them once. - Score independence. Two sources are independent only if they differ in at least two of: publisher, underlying data, named author, funding source.
- Label each claim
[triangulated: N],[single-source], or[contradicted]inline. - When sources disagree, keep both figures and name the disagreement. Never average two conflicting numbers into one.
- If no second independent source exists, write
single-sourced from <X>rather than quietly deleting the hedge.
A cheap independence probe:
import hashlib, urllib.request
def fingerprint(url):
body = urllib.request.urlopen(url, timeout=10).read()
return hashlib.sha256(body).hexdigest()[:12]
# equal digests -> same upstream text -> one source
Pitfalls
- Syndication: one wire story printed in 40 outlets reads like 40 sources. Grep for the wire credit ("Reuters", "AP") and collapse them.
- Circular reporting: an aggregator cites a blog that cites the aggregator back.
- Date collapse: several pieces from the same 24-hour news cycle usually share one origin.
- Silence is not denial — a source failing to mention a claim does not refute it.
- Two papers by the same group on the same cohort are not independent replications.
Verification
grep -c '\[single-source\]' answer.md
Every load-bearing claim is either triangulated across 2+ independent sources or explicitly marked single-source. Report: "Claim X triangulated across 2 independent sources (common origin suppressed); claim Z remains single-sourced and is flagged."