Local Transcript

Local Transcript

Overview

Use this skill to turn a local media file into cleaned final transcript files in .txt, .pdf, or .docx format. Extract audio with ffmpeg, transcribe with mlx-whisper (Apple Silicon GPU) or faster-whisper (CPU fallback), then clean the transcript with deterministic replacements for known ASR bugs. LLM contextual proofreading is an opt-in second layer (--llm-backend local|claude) — see §LLM Proofreading Is Opt-In for why it is not the default.

Workflow

1. Validate the input path.
2. Confirm the requested output format.
3. Check dependencies.
4. Resolve the ASR mode: fast, balanced, or accurate.
5. Reuse cached audio/raw transcript/clean transcript layers when available.
6. Extract or reuse 16 kHz mono WAV audio.
7. Transcribe with the selected ASR backend (language auto-detected or user-specified via --language).
8. Clean the transcript: simplified Chinese → deterministic replacements → (opt-in) LLM proofreading → post-LLM safety replacements.
9. Paragraphize and write the requested final file(s).

Format Resolution Gate

• If the user explicitly requests txt, pdf, or word/docx, use that format directly.
• If the user requests multiple formats, generate all requested formats from the same cleaned transcript.
• If the user asks to transcribe a file but does not specify an output format, ask a short follow-up question before execution: Which output format do you want: txt, pdf, or docx?
• Do not guess the output format from context alone when the user did not say.

Dependency Gate

Before running, verify:

• ffmpeg
• local Python execution for scripts/local_transcript.py This is an Apple-Silicon-first tool. Say so rather than presenting the fallbacks as an equivalent path — they are usable, not seamless.

Packages by platform — do not install the whole list on a non-Mac:

• Always: opencc-python-reimplemented, reportlab, python-docx, plus ffmpeg
• Apple Silicon: mlx-whisper, mlx-lm
• Elsewhere: faster-whisper (mlx-* will not install and are not needed)

On a non-Apple-Silicon machine pass --backend faster-whisper, or the run fails on a missing mlx import. Proofreading needs no flag now that it is off by default; if you opt in there, it must be --llm-backend claude — local is MLX-only.

The script bootstraps ASR models automatically if missing (downloaded from HuggingFace Hub).

Cache writes go through a temp file and an atomic rename, and a cache file that fails to parse is discarded and treated as a miss — an interrupted run degrades to a re-run rather than to a corrupt transcript.

Quality Evaluation

scripts/run_quality_eval.py measures CER and proper-noun recall against a hand-checked corpus, per mode, and separately for the raw ASR text and the proofread text — so a proofreading pass that lowers CER overall while corrupting names shows up rather than averaging out.

No corpus ships with the skill: audio cannot be committed, and a reference transcript means nothing without its audio. Point --corpus at your own; without one the script exits 2 and grades nothing.

Build a reproducible corpus first — the reference transcript is exact by construction, so no hand-transcription is needed:

python3 scripts/make_reference_corpus.py --out ./corpus          # macOS `say`
python3 scripts/run_quality_eval.py --corpus ./corpus --modes fast,balanced,accurate

Synthetic speech has no accent, noise or disfluency, so its CER is a floor, not an accuracy estimate. Use it to compare configurations and catch regressions, not to claim a real-world number. For that, point --corpus at real recordings with hand-checked references.

The evaluator compares baseline vs proofread, where the baseline is --no-llm-proofread — the pipeline minus the LLM, not raw ASR (OpenCC, replacements, punctuation and re-segmentation still run). Use the transcriber's --emit-raw-asr if you need the untouched ASR text.

Run it with uv run so the transcriber's PEP 723 dependencies are honoured (the evaluator does this by default and refuses to proceed without uv unless you pass --no-uv and provide the packages yourself):

python3 scripts/run_quality_eval.py --corpus /path/to/corpus --modes balanced,accurate

Both cache and model roots honour LOCAL_TRANSCRIPT_CACHE and LOCAL_TRANSCRIPT_MODELS; the defaults under /tmp are unchanged. Set them where /tmp is not writable.

Not yet measured: the regression suite proves the wiring (that accurate really requests beam search, that each configuration gets its own cache key, that a hallucinating chunk is rejected). It does not prove that accurate yields a lower CER than balanced on real audio, or that proofreading removes more errors than it introduces. Those need the eval above, run on a real corpus. Running it needs a machine that this repository's development sandbox does not provide: MLX requires a Metal device (absent in a headless session) and any backend must reach huggingface.co to fetch its model. The harness reports both as setup: failures and exits 2 rather than emitting a number, so an environment that cannot measure never looks like an environment that measured well.

If a dependency is missing, stop and say which dependency is unavailable.

LLM Proofreading Is Opt-In

--llm-backend defaults to none. Pass --llm-backend local (mlx-lm) or --llm-backend claude to turn the second correction layer on.

The default was flipped after measuring the local backend (Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct-4bit) on three 30-minute Chinese podcast transcripts:

• It corrected none of the ~130 homophone errors a human reader found across the three (需求策/需求侧, 地域难度/地狱难度, 天王/天网, 万物被裹/万物百吉饼, …).
• Three chunks across two runs failed output validation, exhausted their retries, and fell back to the unproofread original — the documented behaviour, but it means the pass cost time and returned nothing.
• One chunk copied the prompt's own 待校对文本: label into the transcript body. Validation now rejects that (§Output validation), but it had shipped.
• It dominated wall-clock: 350s of a 510s run.

Three transcripts from one speaker is not a general verdict on LLM proofreading, and it says nothing about the claude backend, which was not measured. It is enough to stop paying for it by default.

Not attributable to the LLM: a run also produced 128–185 ,， artifacts per transcript. Those came from join_lines() treating a halfwidth comma as unpunctuated and appending a full-width one — a bug in this skill, now fixed and covered by regression tests. Do not cite it as evidence against the model.

Known Risks and Their Switches

Default Behavior

• Input: one local media file path
• Default output format for direct script usage: txt
• Default output file: same directory as the media file, named <stem>-transcript.<ext>
• Default ASR backend: mlx (Apple Silicon GPU acceleration via mlx-whisper)
• Default and recommended ASR mode: balanced
• Mode presets:
  • fast: mlx-whisper with whisper-small, no LLM proofreading override needed
  • balanced: mlx-whisper with whisper-large-v3-turbo + LLM proofreading (recommended)
  • accurate: mlx-whisper with whisper-large-v3-turbo, decoded with beam_size=5 (same model as balanced; the difference is the search, not the weights) + LLM proofreading
• Fallback backend: --backend faster-whisper for non-Apple-Silicon machines (CPU-only, slower)
• Default cache behavior: reuse three cache layers for the same unchanged media file
  • extracted WAV audio (validated by RIFF/WAVE header, not merely non-empty)
  • raw ASR transcript
  • cleaned final transcript (separate caches for LLM-proofread and non-proofread)
• LLM proofreading: off by default (--llm-backend none); opt in per run
  • Optional backend: local — uses mlx-lm on Apple Silicon GPU. No API key, no network, no cost.
    • balanced/accurate mode: Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct-4bit (higher quality)
    • fast mode: Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct-4bit (faster, ~50% less proofreading time)
  • Alternative backend: claude — uses claude -p CLI (requires API access)
  • Splits text into ~2500-char chunks with 400-char context overlap from the previous chunk
  • Short tail chunks (<500 chars) are automatically merged into the previous chunk to avoid validation failures
  • Video/audio title is passed to the LLM as domain context for better proper-noun correction
  • Output validation: rejects a response that is too short/long, opens with meta-commentary, collapses the line structure, loops on one line, invents a number, or echoes one of the prompt's own field labels (待校对文本, …) anywhere in the body — the label check ignores labels the source text already contained
  • Retry: failed/invalid chunks are retried up to 2 times before falling back to the original text
  • Already the default; --no-llm-proofread and --llm-backend none remain accepted
  • English transcripts need a second gate: --llm-proofread-en in addition to --llm-backend, since English is skipped even when a backend is selected
  • Custom model: --llm-model <hf-repo> to use a different MLX model
• Language: auto-detected from speech, or user-specified via --language zh / --language en
• Three-layer Chinese correction pipeline:
  1. Deterministic replacements: a curated table of universal Whisper ASR bugs (not video-specific). Supports extra replacements via --replacements-file <path.json>.
  2. LLM contextual proofreading: handles domain-specific terms, proper nouns, idioms, and homophones
  3. Post-LLM safety pass: deterministic replacements applied again to catch any regressions
  4. Proper noun unification (only with --unify-names; off by default): detects near-duplicate CJK names (e.g. 哈萨迪/哈塔尼→哈萨尼) and unifies low-frequency variants to the dominant form. See §Known Risks — it can rewrite a legitimate word.
• Final deliverable: cleaned transcript in the user-requested format(s) only
• PDF output: use a Chinese-capable font when the inferred transcript language is Chinese
• PDF and DOCX output: emit transcript body only, without prepending headers

Execution

Run (default: mlx backend, balanced mode, no LLM proofreading):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4"

Request PDF output:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --format pdf

Prioritize speed (smaller model, still fast on Apple Silicon):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --mode fast

Enable local LLM proofreading (off by default — read §LLM Proofreading Is Opt-In first):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --llm-backend local

Use claude CLI for proofreading (requires API access):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --llm-backend claude

Use a different local LLM model:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --llm-model mlx-community/Qwen2.5-14B-Instruct-4bit

Specify language explicitly (skip auto-detection):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --language zh

Enable LLM proofreading for English transcripts (needs both flags — --llm-proofread-en alone does nothing while the backend is none):

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/english-video.mp4" --llm-backend local --llm-proofread-en

Use CPU fallback backend:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --backend faster-whisper

Force a fresh transcription and ignore cache:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --format pdf --force-transcribe

Load extra replacements from a JSON file:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --replacements-file custom_fixes.json

Request multiple formats:

uv run /absolute/path/to/skills/local-transcript/scripts/local_transcript.py "/absolute/path/to/video.mp4" --format txt --format pdf --format docx

Cleaning Rules

• Remove timestamps if present.
• Collapse caption-style short lines into natural paragraphs.
• Paragraph breaks are layout, not sentence boundaries. Whisper's Chinese output carries almost no sentence terminators — 5 periods in a 10,000-character transcript is typical — so paragraphize() cannot always break where a sentence ends. It prefers a real terminator, overflows up to PARAGRAPH_HARD_RATIO× the soft limit waiting for one, and then breaks anyway without inventing a period. A paragraph that ends without punctuation is continuing into the next one; that is honest, where the old behaviour (stamping 。 on every length-based cut) split single sentences in two and asserted a boundary the speaker never uttered.
• For Chinese:
  1. Convert traditional to simplified Chinese.
  2. Apply deterministic replacements for universal Whisper ASR bugs (curated, cross-video).
  3. Run LLM-based contextual proofreading with video title as domain context.
  4. Apply deterministic replacements again as a post-LLM safety net.
  5. Normalize Chinese punctuation.
• The deterministic replacement table contains only universal, cross-video Whisper errors (also available as scripts/zh_replacements.json). Video-specific corrections (proper nouns, domain terms) are handled by the LLM layer and proper noun unification pass.
• Users can supply additional replacements via --replacements-file for domain-specific corrections.
• Preserve English output as English.
• Strip trailing ASR garbage: repetitive patterns (e.g. "www www www...") from video credits or silence are auto-removed.
• Do not invent missing content.

Output Contract

For every run, report:

1. Input file
2. Detected or inferred transcript language
3. ASR backend used (mlx or faster-whisper)
4. ASR mode used
5. Model used
6. LLM proofreading status (enabled/disabled)
7. Requested output format(s)
8. Cache status for audio/raw transcript/clean transcript
9. Final output path(s)
10. Total processing time
11. Whether the transcript was cleaned successfully

If execution fails, report the exact failed step and stop.

Script

Use scripts/local_transcript.py for the workflow. Prefer the script over retyping the pipeline manually.