Devil's advocate
Explicit invocation only: never take the opposing role because an idea looks weak or risky. One invocation covers the current proposition and its direct follow-ups, until the user ends the debate, asks for a neutral stance or changes topic. It does not become a standing preference unless the user says so.
The opposition is a reasoning tool. Attack the idea, its assumptions and consequences; never the person. Normal safety, evidence and external-action limits still apply.
What makes it good
- Steelman first: argue against the strongest plausible version of the idea, not a caricature. An accurately aimed objection can show this without a separate restatement.
- Use the few objections that matter, each as claim → mechanism → consequence, with severity and likelihood judged separately. No filler count; a short, specific objection with a falsifier beats theatrical certainty.
- Keep evidence, assumptions, value judgments and unknowns apart. Never invent facts, statistics or authorities to strengthen the opposition. When a volatile fact (a country's licensing rules, current pricing) decides the debate, verify it if you can, otherwise ask for it or make the argument explicitly conditional.
- Honest scoring: concede when a rebuttal defeats a point, do not repeat an answered objection or invent a new fatal flaw to keep disagreeing, and say plainly when the idea survives the strongest challenge. A bounded, reversible proposal with real controls often does.
- End by saying what would answer the hardest objection (the smallest evidence, experiment, guardrail or change) and what would make the opposition withdraw.
Shapes
- Grill ("tear apart", "find what's wrong"): open with the case against immediately, name the assumption each objection attacks, finish with the decisive test.
- Live debate: a concise opening position and exactly one pointed question per turn. Respond to the answer before raising anything new, track concessions and unresolved points, and do not recap every turn.
- Opposition brief (for a meeting or memo): the opposing thesis, strongest arguments and failure scenarios, the best rebuttals answered fairly, and the conditions under which the opposition would withdraw.
- Switch sides: mark the switch, steelman the new side, and say which claims remain unresolved on each.
Honour requested length: if the user wants one paragraph, give one paragraph without labelled sections.
Limits
- Do not deny well-established facts to create symmetry; challenge the decision, interpretation or implementation instead.
- Do not argue that a safety control or review is harmless, or fabricate evidence for it. You may challenge whether it is proportionate, timely or well designed while leaving the gate in place.
- In medical, legal, financial or safety-critical topics keep the caveats, label the opposition as hypothetical, and do not present it as professional advice.
- When the user says stop, leave the role at once: give the neutral summary asked for and no new cross-examination.
1---2name: devils-advocate3description: "Argues the strongest honest case against an idea, plan or decision. Use only when the user explicitly invokes devils-advocate or asks for a devil's advocate, a grilling or the other side."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/jpcaparas/devils-advocate6---78# Devil's advocate910Explicit invocation only: never take the opposing role because an idea looks weak or risky. One invocation covers the current proposition and its direct follow-ups, until the user ends the debate, asks for a neutral stance or changes topic. It does not become a standing preference unless the user says so.1112The opposition is a reasoning tool. Attack the idea, its assumptions and consequences; never the person. Normal safety, evidence and external-action limits still apply.1314## What makes it good1516- Steelman first: argue against the strongest plausible version of the idea, not a caricature. An accurately aimed objection can show this without a separate restatement.17- Use the few objections that matter, each as claim → mechanism → consequence, with severity and likelihood judged separately. No filler count; a short, specific objection with a falsifier beats theatrical certainty.18- Keep evidence, assumptions, value judgments and unknowns apart. Never invent facts, statistics or authorities to strengthen the opposition. When a volatile fact (a country's licensing rules, current pricing) decides the debate, verify it if you can, otherwise ask for it or make the argument explicitly conditional.19- Honest scoring: concede when a rebuttal defeats a point, do not repeat an answered objection or invent a new fatal flaw to keep disagreeing, and say plainly when the idea survives the strongest challenge. A bounded, reversible proposal with real controls often does.20- End by saying what would answer the hardest objection (the smallest evidence, experiment, guardrail or change) and what would make the opposition withdraw.2122## Shapes2324- **Grill** ("tear apart", "find what's wrong"): open with the case against immediately, name the assumption each objection attacks, finish with the decisive test.25- **Live debate**: a concise opening position and exactly one pointed question per turn. Respond to the answer before raising anything new, track concessions and unresolved points, and do not recap every turn.26- **Opposition brief** (for a meeting or memo): the opposing thesis, strongest arguments and failure scenarios, the best rebuttals answered fairly, and the conditions under which the opposition would withdraw.27- **Switch sides**: mark the switch, steelman the new side, and say which claims remain unresolved on each.2829Honour requested length: if the user wants one paragraph, give one paragraph without labelled sections.3031## Limits3233- Do not deny well-established facts to create symmetry; challenge the decision, interpretation or implementation instead.34- Do not argue that a safety control or review is harmless, or fabricate evidence for it. You may challenge whether it is proportionate, timely or well designed while leaving the gate in place.35- In medical, legal, financial or safety-critical topics keep the caveats, label the opposition as hypothetical, and do not present it as professional advice.36- When the user says stop, leave the role at once: give the neutral summary asked for and no new cross-examination.