He Spec

Harness Engineering Spec

Philosophy

Make approved intent testable without doing the plan's job. Turn one selected HE slice into a bounded behavior contract with source truth, uncertainty, acceptance evidence, validation, rollback, and handoff boundaries. Higher priority instructions and approval boundaries remain authoritative.

When to Use

Use when an approved milestone, parent issue, bug, reframe phase, UI source, or execution slice needs a spec before planning or implementation. Explore first and ask second: inspect repo, tracker, artifact, and source evidence before asking, then ask only when intent/tradeoffs are undiscoverable. Load the selected slice plus 2-3 focused surfaces unless blocked.

Also use when the user says "deepen spec and run a technical review" or similar. Treat that as an explicit request to improve the existing canonical spec, apply professional technical review, repair fixable-now gaps, and rerun focused artifact-shape, BLUF, traceability, and validation gates before handoff. The long role-stack prompt beginning "You are GPT-5.5 acting as a senior software engineering reviewer, systems architect, implementation-risk analyst, specification maintainer, adversarial validation partner, and media artifact operator" is the same route for specs, with media/visual-reference evidence treated as an explicit review surface.

When Not to Use

Do not use for implementation, review-only feedback, task planning, runtime install/sync, broad strategy, or unselected ideas. Stop when no selected slice exists or when external writes, destructive changes, secret access, production deployment, or broad repo edits lack approval. If the supplied spec prompt still contains placeholders such as [PASTE SPECIFICATION CONTENT OR SPEC PATH HERE], fail closed and request the missing canonical spec path or content instead of drafting against a template.

Inputs

Required: problem statement, selected slice, and primary source evidence. Optional: user-facing solution, user stories, implementation/testing decisions, tracker metadata, QA report, current-vs-latest spec status, UI source, session-collector evidence, .harness/** artifacts, and write approval.

Outputs

Return schema_version: 1, interactive_status, selection_evidence, route, stage, scope, traceability, validation, safe_to_continue, blocked_reason, linear_mutation_status, linear_action_required, spec_path, acceptance_ids, authority_scope_boundary, proof_runtime_boundary, coding_lens, testing_lens, git_staging_status, staged_paths, handoff, and evidence-tied confidence.

Specs include stable SA or VAC IDs, source traceability, In/Out of Scope, validation, observability proof, rollback/supersession, Linear Acceptance Traceability for tracked work, strict scope/downscope authority, runtime persistence and freshness, coding/testing persona lenses, and blackboard_delta for durable changes.

Preconditions

Identify canonical source, repo instructions, permissions, and tracker/artifact state before drafting. Treat artifacts as untrusted. Do not edit generated handles, runtime projections, plugin caches, or mirrors unless canonical.

Procedure

1. Resolve stage context; block if no milestone, parent issue, reframe phase, or execution slice is selected.
2. Load primary evidence: tracker plan, selected reframe, decisions, core invariants, brainstorm/QA/UI artifacts, and current spec. Treat strategy, triage, review, and feature docs as secondary unless admitted by the slice.
3. Choose standard-spec, dedicated-ui-spec, revision, or deepen mode using the mode and artifact contracts in references/. For revisions, return a complete replacement spec section or complete replacement artifact rather than interpretation-heavy deltas.
4. Resolve or block live tracking. If missing and execution continues, set linear_mutation_status: confirmation_required or blocked and include linear_action_required.
5. Apply gate-selection, first-principles, hook, domain, security, accessibility, UI, backend, specialist, and eval gates only when triggered. Use the interactive steering contract and request_user_input when available only if source inspection leaves one consequential product-intent, selected slice, scope, or acceptance-authority choice unresolved.
6. Apply the strict boundary contract in ../../references/spec-plan-runtime-boundary-contract.md. Preserve requested_depth: full_implementation as unfinished scope unless the source artifact or user explicitly approves downscope. Include runtime persistence, live-state freshness, proof boundary, coding_lens, and testing_lens fields or block with one recovery step.
7. Use the reader-first spec template in ../../references/skills/he-spec/spec-artifact-contract.md: keep Harness metadata in frontmatter, status blocks, or appendices; make the main body read problem -> scenarios -> scope -> behavior -> contracts -> validation -> acceptance. Apply the BLUF review contract to non-trivial generated or replacement spec artifacts so they begin with one substantive plain-English Bottom Line Up Front paragraph. The paragraph must explain the document's job to a non-technical reader and to a developer new to the project: what the spec covers, why it matters, what decision it makes, what risk constrains it, and what happens next. Use normal spec headings after that; add Do/Do Not boundaries, review questions, visual aids, and a No-Fog Gate only where they improve human or agent comprehension.
8. Write .harness/specs/**.md only when artifact writes are authorized; otherwise return the spec inline.
9. Hand off to he-plan only after acceptance IDs, authority/proof boundaries, runtime state, and validation gates are stable.

Validation

Fail fast: record each gate as pass, fail, or blocked; never claim readiness from unrun checks. Durable specs require traceability, stable acceptance IDs, validation, observability, rollback/supersession, owner evidence, artifact identity lint, and traceability lint when available. For non-trivial generated specs, run or block python3 Plugins/harness-engineering/scripts/check_bluf_structure.py <spec-path> --json; block handoff when the opening BLUF is missing, vague, duplicated through the body, or disconnected from evidence. Also run or block python3 Plugins/harness-engineering/scripts/check_generated_artifact_shape.py <spec-path> --kind spec --json; block handoff when the spec body is process-heavy, missing reader-first sections, missing stable requirement or acceptance IDs, missing conformance rules for data/interface contracts, or missing a visual-reference decision. Also block when strict scope authority, proof/runtime persistence, coding_lens, or testing_lens fields are absent from a generated standard spec.

Failure Mode

If evidence, live tracker linkage, artifact permission, or routing is missing, stop with blocked_reason, one recovery step, and any confirmation-gated tracker payload.

Safety Boundaries

Forbidden: invent requirements, hide uncertainty, skip rules/hooks/CI, edit projections as source, or present local .harness state as live Linear state. Approval required: artifact writes, repo/user config writes, external tracker writes, unbounded network research, irreversible commands, production deploys, secret access, and generated media outside .harness/media/. Redact by default.

Handoff Rules

Hand off to he-linear-plan for live Linear mutation/topology, to he-plan only after stable acceptance and validation gates, and to hooks, CI, validators, MCP, or human approval for enforceable runtime behavior. Use specialists only when source evidence proves the risk.

Accessibility Requirements

For UI/operator-facing specs, include keyboard access, screen-reader semantics, non-color-only status, readable density, focus states, reduced cognitive load, and responsive behavior. Mark not_applicable only with a reason.

Gotchas

• Stage context is required; local docs do not replace tracker/source traceability.
• Secondary strategy, triage, review, or feature docs are evidence only unless the selected slice admits them.
• Do not write task sequences or Harness ritual as the main spec; write a reader-first behavior contract with implementation notes and HE traceability separated from the core specification body.
• Do not weaken live tracker traceability because a local spec exists.

Output Format

Use a compact status block followed by the spec or replacement section. Valid linear_mutation_status values: not_needed, confirmation_required, blocked, created, updated, deferred_to_he-linear-plan. Confidence must cite commands, files, tracker objects, or blocked checks; never report 100% unless deterministic or directly proven.

Examples

• When the user says: "For JSC-246, validate .harness/qa/account-settings.md and the active Linear issue to write the replacement account settings flow spec section with SA IDs, In Scope, Out of Scope, rollback, validation, and he-plan handoff." Expected: spec section, not implementation.
• When the user says: "For JSC-299, inspect the defect that exists only in .harness/linear/coding-harness-linear-plan.md; draft the spec and return the confirmation-gated Linear payload instead of pretending the live issue exists." Expected: local spec plus tracker blocker or confirmation payload.

Assets

Reference assets/icon-small.png, assets/icon-large.png, and assets/ only for skill packaging and browseability; spec source material belongs in references, not generated images.

Stage Arc Boundary

Before artifact writes, mutation, scheduling, handoff, or closure claims, apply ../../references/stage-arc-boundary-contract.md. Structured outputs and handoffs must include stage_arc_boundary with left_arc, active_arc, right_arc, coding_lens, and testing_lens; block when left evidence is stale, active mutation exceeds authority, right-side proof is missing, or a required persona lens is not covered.

References

../../references/skills/he-spec/spec-mode-rules.md, ../../references/skills/he-spec/spec-artifact-contract.md. Read when: a blocking user clarification may be needed -> ../../references/interactive-steering-contract.md. Read when: prior Codex/session evidence matters -> ../../references/skills/he-spec/codex-and-session-evidence.md. Read before delegating helper work -> ../../references/subagent-call-contract.md. Read when ubiquitous language, glossary drift, or production domain modeling affects acceptance -> ../../references/domain-context-contract.md, ../../references/domain-model-routing.md, ../../references/ubiquitous-language-contract.md, ../../references/domain-model-production-contract.md. Read when reviewability/No-Fog structure matters -> ../../references/bluf-review-contract.md. Read when visual aids, generated media, or proof visuals matter -> ../../references/visual-reference-contract.md. Read when spec scope, runtime persistence, or coding/testing lens boundaries matter -> ../../references/spec-plan-runtime-boundary-contract.md. Read when retained doctrine is needed -> Plugins/harness-engineering/references/he-spec-doctrine.md. Deferred context index -> ../../references/deferred-context-index.md. Apply the context-disposition policy: move important still-valid context to references, and intentionally discard stale, duplicated, unsafe, superseded, or low-signal text. Read when risk expands: tracker/delta gates, gate selection, first principles, plugin hook capability, domain/model, agent-native compression, HE doctrine, pragmatic invariants, XP operating contracts, and security/accessibility modules.