Documentation And Adrs

Documentation and ADRs

Overview

Document decisions, not just code. The most valuable documentation captures the why — the context, constraints, and trade-offs that led to a decision. Code shows what was built; documentation explains why it was built this way and what alternatives were considered. This context is essential for future humans and agents working in the codebase.

When to Use

• Making a significant architectural decision
• Choosing between competing approaches
• Adding or changing a public API
• Shipping a feature that changes user-facing behavior
• Onboarding new team members (or agents) to the project
• When you find yourself explaining the same thing repeatedly

When NOT to use: Don't document obvious code. Don't add comments that restate what the code already says. Don't write docs for throwaway prototypes.

Prerequisites

• A project repository with a docs/ directory (create one if missing)
• For ADRs: a docs/decisions/ subdirectory
• For API docs: type annotations or OpenAPI spec tooling already configured

Procedure

1. Decide Whether to Write an ADR

Write an ADR when any of the following apply:

• Choosing a framework, library, or major dependency
• Designing a data model or database schema
• Selecting an authentication strategy
• Deciding on an API architecture (REST vs. GraphQL vs. tRPC)
• Choosing between build tools, hosting platforms, or infrastructure
• Any decision that would be expensive to reverse

If the decision is trivial or easily reversible, skip the ADR.

2. Create the ADR File

Store ADRs in docs/decisions/ with sequential numbering.

Windows PowerShell — create the directory and next ADR file:

New-Item -ItemType Directory -Force -Path docs\decisions
$next = (Get-ChildItem docs\decisions -Filter "ADR-*.md" | Measure-Object).Count + 1
$num = $next.ToString("D3")
New-Item -ItemType File -Path "docs\decisions\ADR-$num-<short-slug>.md"

3. Fill in the ADR Template

Use this template:

# ADR-001: Use PostgreSQL for primary database

## Status
Accepted | Superseded by ADR-XXX | Deprecated

## Date
2025-01-15

## Context
We need a primary database for the task management application. Key requirements:
- Relational data model (users, tasks, teams with relationships)
- ACID transactions for task state changes
- Support for full-text search on task content
- Managed hosting available (for small team, limited ops capacity)

## Decision
Use PostgreSQL with Prisma ORM.

## Alternatives Considered

### MongoDB
- Pros: Flexible schema, easy to start with
- Cons: Our data is inherently relational; would need to manage relationships manually
- Rejected: Relational data in a document store leads to complex joins or data duplication

### SQLite
- Pros: Zero configuration, embedded, fast for reads
- Cons: Limited concurrent write support, no managed hosting for production
- Rejected: Not suitable for multi-user web application in production

### MySQL
- Pros: Mature, widely supported
- Cons: PostgreSQL has better JSON support, full-text search, and ecosystem tooling
- Rejected: PostgreSQL is the better fit for our feature requirements

## Consequences
- Prisma provides type-safe database access and migration management
- We can use PostgreSQL's full-text search instead of adding Elasticsearch
- Team needs PostgreSQL knowledge (standard skill, low risk)
- Hosting on managed service (Supabase, Neon, or RDS)

4. Manage the ADR Lifecycle

PROPOSED → ACCEPTED → (SUPERSEDED or DEPRECATED)

• HARD RULE: Don't delete old ADRs. They capture historical context.
• When a decision changes, write a new ADR that references and supersedes the old one.
• Update the old ADR's Status line to Superseded by ADR-XXX.

5. Write Inline Documentation

Comment the why, not the what:

// BAD: Restates the code
// Increment counter by 1
counter += 1;

// GOOD: Explains non-obvious intent
// Rate limit uses a sliding window — reset counter at window boundary,
// not on a fixed schedule, to prevent burst attacks at window edges
if (now - windowStart > WINDOW_SIZE_MS) {
  counter = 0;
  windowStart = now;
}

When NOT to comment:

// Don't comment self-explanatory code
function calculateTotal(items: CartItem[]): number {
  return items.reduce((sum, item) => sum + item.price * item.quantity, 0);
}

// Don't leave TODO comments for things you should just do now
// TODO: add error handling  ← Just add it

// Don't leave commented-out code
// const oldImplementation = () => { ... }  ← Delete it, git has history

Document known gotchas inline:

/**
 * IMPORTANT: This function must be called before the first render.
 * If called after hydration, it causes a flash of unstyled content
 * because the theme context isn't available during SSR.
 *
 * See ADR-003 for the full design rationale.
 */
export function initializeTheme(theme: Theme): void {
  // ...
}

6. Document Public APIs

For TypeScript, prefer inline TSDoc:

/**
 * Creates a new task.
 *
 * @param input - Task creation data (title required, description optional)
 * @returns The created task with server-generated ID and timestamps
 * @throws {ValidationError} If title is empty or exceeds 200 characters
 * @throws {AuthenticationError} If the user is not authenticated
 *
 * @example
 * const task = await createTask({ title: 'Buy groceries' });
 * console.log(task.id); // "task_abc123"
 */
export async function createTask(input: CreateTaskInput): Promise<Task> {
  // ...
}

For REST APIs, use OpenAPI / Swagger:

paths:
  /api/tasks:
    post:
      summary: Create a task
      requestBody:
        required: true
        content:
          application/json:
            schema:
              $ref: '#/components/schemas/CreateTaskInput'
      responses:
        '201':
          description: Task created
          content:
            application/json:
              schema:
                $ref: '#/components/schemas/Task'
        '422':
          description: Validation error

7. Maintain the README

Every project should have a README covering:

# Project Name

One-paragraph description of what this project does.

## Quick Start
1. Clone the repo
2. Install dependencies: `npm install`
3. Set up environment: `cp .env.example .env`
4. Run the dev server: `npm run dev`

## Commands
| Command | Description |
|---------|-------------|
| `npm run dev` | Start development server |
| `npm test` | Run tests |
| `npm run build` | Production build |
| `npm run lint` | Run linter |

## Architecture
Brief overview of the project structure and key design decisions.
Link to ADRs for details.

## Contributing
How to contribute, coding standards, PR process.

8. Maintain the Changelog

For shipped features:

# Changelog

## [1.2.0] - 2025-01-20
### Added
- Task sharing: users can share tasks with team members (#123)
- Email notifications for task assignments (#124)

### Fixed
- Duplicate tasks appearing when rapidly clicking create button (#125)

### Changed
- Task list now loads 50 items per page (was 20) for better UX (#126)

9. Document for Agents

Special consideration for AI agent context:

• CLAUDE.md / rules files — Document project conventions so agents follow them
• Spec files — Keep specs updated so agents build the right thing
• ADRs — Help agents understand why past decisions were made (prevents re-deciding)
• Inline gotchas — Prevent agents from falling into known traps

Pitfalls

Red flags to avoid:

• Architectural decisions with no written rationale
• Public APIs with no documentation or types
• README that doesn't explain how to run the project
• Commented-out code instead of deletion
• TODO comments that have been there for weeks
• No ADRs in a project with significant architectural choices
• Documentation that restates the code instead of explaining intent
• Deleting old ADRs instead of superseding them

Verification

After documenting, verify each item:

• ADRs exist for all significant architectural decisions
• README covers quick start, commands, and architecture overview
• API functions have parameter and return type documentation
• Known gotchas are documented inline where they matter
• No commented-out code remains
• Rules files (CLAUDE.md etc.) are current and accurate

Windows PowerShell — check for ADRs and stale TODOs:

# List all ADRs
Get-ChildItem docs\decisions -Filter "ADR-*.md" | Select-Object Name

# Find TODO comments older than today's git state
Select-String -Path "src\*.ts","src\*.tsx" -Pattern "TODO" -SimpleMatch

Expected output: A list of ADR filenames and any TODO matches that need resolution.