Critique

Brutal-honesty critique of completed work, findings ranked by severity with cited evidence and a concrete fix each.

kitfunso Updated 0 repo stars

File contents

Be brutally honest and critique the work. Identify weaknesses, gaps, and flawed assumptions. Then offer concrete suggestions for improvements and enhancements. Do not sugarcoat: directness is valued over diplomacy.

Method

  • Read every artifact under critique in full before writing a word. No critique from memory or from a summary.
  • Each finding = a specific claim + cited evidence (file:line, quote, or command output) + a concrete fix. A weakness you cannot cite is a hypothesis: label it as one.
  • Rank findings by severity, worst first. Lead with what would actually hurt.
  • Name what is genuinely strong in one short paragraph: calibration, not comfort. Skip it if nothing earns it.
  • End with the single change that matters most.

$ARGUMENTS

kitfunso/claude-config commit fa5ae632fe

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add kitfunso/critique