Citation Auditor
Evaluate claim-to-source support. Prefer primary, authoritative, and current sources
when the claim requires them; do not penalize a source merely for disagreeing with
the draft.
Audit contract
- Enumerate factual claims and the citations attached to each claim.
- Retrieve the cited source when access is available. Mark inaccessible material as
unverified rather than guessing from a title or snippet.
- Compare the full claim—including scope, population, date, quantity, causality, and
qualifiers—with what the source supports.
- Distinguish direct support, reasonable inference, partial support, contradiction,
and no support.
- Check author or institution, publication date, version, methodology, conflicts,
retractions or corrections, and whether a more primary source is required.
- Detect citation laundering, circular sourcing, quote distortion, broken anchors,
and one citation being stretched across unrelated claims.
Output
Return a table with claim ID, claim text, citation, accessibility, support status,
source-quality note, freshness, and required correction. End with counts by status
and a blocker list. Keep replacement-source suggestions separate and clearly labeled;
do not present an unreviewed replacement as verified support.
1---2name: citation-auditor-23domain: research4skill_type: skill5description: >-6 Audit whether each citation is reachable, authoritative enough, correctly7 attributed, and actually supports the nearby claim, including qualifiers and8 freshness. Use when reviewing a sourced draft, research report, technical memo,9 or evidence table before relying on or publishing its claims. Do not use to invent10 replacement evidence or rewrite the document.11license: MIT12tags: [research, citations, evidence, fact-checking, provenance]13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/knuckles-team/citation-auditor-215 version: '1.6.0'16 author: Genius17---1819# Citation Auditor2021Evaluate claim-to-source support. Prefer primary, authoritative, and current sources22when the claim requires them; do not penalize a source merely for disagreeing with23the draft.2425## Audit contract2627- Enumerate factual claims and the citations attached to each claim.28- Retrieve the cited source when access is available. Mark inaccessible material as29 unverified rather than guessing from a title or snippet.30- Compare the full claim—including scope, population, date, quantity, causality, and31 qualifiers—with what the source supports.32- Distinguish direct support, reasonable inference, partial support, contradiction,33 and no support.34- Check author or institution, publication date, version, methodology, conflicts,35 retractions or corrections, and whether a more primary source is required.36- Detect citation laundering, circular sourcing, quote distortion, broken anchors,37 and one citation being stretched across unrelated claims.3839## Output4041Return a table with claim ID, claim text, citation, accessibility, support status,42source-quality note, freshness, and required correction. End with counts by status43and a blocker list. Keep replacement-source suggestions separate and clearly labeled;44do not present an unreviewed replacement as verified support.