Openwrt Ssh Pct Remote

OpenWrt pct_remote Shell Syntax Rules

Shell Execution Through pct_remote

1. The community.proxmox.proxmox_pct_remote connection plugin builds /usr/sbin/pct exec <vmid> -- <cmd> and sends it as a single string via SSH to the Proxmox host. The HOST's bash interprets the entire string before pct exec runs.

Critical Shell Syntax Issues

2. Semicolons split at host level. cmd1; cmd2 becomes two separate commands on the Proxmox host — only cmd1 runs inside the container.

3. Pipes split at host level. cmd1 | cmd2 — cmd1 runs inside the container, cmd2 runs on the HOST (filtering stdout from the container). This happens to work for text processing but is fragile.

4. export is NOT a binary. lxc-attach tries to exec the first word of the command as a binary. export is a shell builtin — it fails with lxc-attach: Failed to exec "export".

5. PATH is not set inside the container. lxc-attach's execvp uses the default path (/bin:/usr/bin), which misses /sbin and /usr/sbin where OpenWrt puts uci, wifi, iw.

Solution: sh -c Wrapper Pattern

6. ALWAYS wrap all commands in /bin/sh -c '...'. The single quotes protect the payload from host bash. Inside the container, busybox ash provides its default PATH=/sbin:/usr/sbin:/bin:/usr/bin.

# BAD — semicolons split at host level, export is not a binary
- ansible.builtin.raw: >-
    export PATH="/usr/sbin:/usr/bin:/sbin:/bin:$PATH";
    opkg update

# BAD — for loops break (host bash tries to exec "for")
- ansible.builtin.raw: >-
    for mod in iwlwifi ath9k; do modprobe "$mod" 2>/dev/null; done

# GOOD — sh -c wraps everything in a container-side shell
- ansible.builtin.raw: >-
    /bin/sh -c 'opkg update'

# GOOD — complex commands with semicolons inside sh -c
- ansible.builtin.raw: >-
    /bin/sh -c
    'opkg list-installed 2>/dev/null | grep -c wpad-mesh || true'

# GOOD — multi-command chains use && inside sh -c
- ansible.builtin.raw: >-
    /bin/sh -c
    'uci set wireless.mesh0=wifi-iface &&
    uci set wireless.mesh0.device="radio0" &&
    uci commit wireless'

Quoting Rules for sh -c Through pct_remote

7. Outer single quotes protect the entire payload from host bash.

8. Inside, use double quotes for values: uci set foo.bar="value"

9. NEVER nest single quotes — use double quotes or drop quotes for simple alphanumeric values.

10. && and || inside single quotes are interpreted by container ash.

11. [ ... ] && echo x || echo y WITHOUT sh -c is OK — [ is exec'd by lxc-attach, &&/|| chain at host level (works for simple checks).

pct exec PATH Limitation

12. pct exec (and lxc-attach) uses a restricted PATH: /sbin:/bin:/usr/sbin:/usr/bin. Binaries in /usr/local/bin/ (e.g., pihole) are NOT found.

13. ALWAYS use full paths for binaries in /usr/local/bin/ or /opt/ when running via pct exec, pct_remote, or ansible.builtin.command on containers.

14. Previous bug: pihole -a -p via pct_remote failed with [Errno 2] No such file or directory: b'pihole'. The binary was at /usr/local/bin/pihole but PATH didn't include it.