Evidence Review Skill
Use this skill when reviewing evidence gathered during vendor due diligence.
Steps
- Source identification — For each claim, identify the source: vendor KB article, vendor database record, PDF capability statement, web search result, or sanctions screening.
- Verification status — Mark each claim as:
- Verified — claim is directly supported by the cited source
- Partially verified — claim is partially supported; note what's missing
- Unverified — claim has no supporting evidence; flag for follow-up
- Contradicted — evidence contradicts the claim; flag immediately
- Quality assessment — Rate evidence quality:
- High — official documentation, verified certifications, audited records
- Medium — vendor self-reported data, dated but plausible claims
- Low — unattributed claims, marketing language, stale data
- Gap analysis — List what's missing: certifications not confirmed, no financial data, no reference customers, no sanctions check
Output format
## Evidence Review: {vendor_name}
### Claims
| Claim | Source | Status | Quality |
|---|---|---|---|
| ... | ... | Verified/Partially verified/Unverified/Contradicted | High/Medium/Low |
### Gaps
- ...
### Recommendation
- ...
Source validation checklist
- Source is cited by name (KB article filename, vendor ID, PDF filename, URL)
- Claim is directly supported by the source content
- Source is current (not stale or outdated)
- No PII in the evidence (contact emails, phone numbers redacted)
- Sanctions screening has been run for the vendor