Scientist Review

scientist-review

Text-level Copilot-native review of a paper or PDF. Model judgment and review output are produced by Copilot in-session; NEVER call a workspace-custom model script.

Execution model

This is a Copilot-native model task. If only a PDF is supplied, extract text first, then have Copilot produce the review directly.

Workflow

1. Acquire the paper text: prefer existing Markdown / LaTeX / TXT; fall back to PDF-text extraction only if necessary.
2. Produce the review, scoring, and risk assessment directly in-session.
3. If the user requests structured output, generate JSON or write to a file.

Input

• pdf_path, LaTeX source, or already-extracted text
• Reviewer perspective and scoring dimensions the user wants applied

Output

• Review notes
• Optional structured JSON review result on request
• Explicit Strengths / Main Issues / Score / Risks

Forbidden

• NEVER call any workspace-custom review pipeline.
• NEVER use custom model calls in workspace scripts for reviewing.

Deliverable requirements

• Default to a "Strengths / Main Issues / Score / Risks" summary.
• If only a PDF is provided and text extraction fails, name the blocker explicitly.