Validate Problem Val

Stage 2 of the validation pipeline — problem validation. Use to verify the problem is real with evidence rather than opinion, using The Mom Test discipline. Triggers when the orchestrator routes to PROBLEM_VAL (MUST_RUN for greenfield/pivot; ASSERT when a live product already proves demand). Always run before validating any solution.

ldphuong-vn Updated

File contents

Problem Validation (Stage 2)

Evidence over opinion. Read dossier-schema.md if needed. Write only into the Dossier. Do not render.

Procedure (The Mom Test)

Validate the problem the way The Mom Test prescribes — talk about the customer's life and past behavior, never pitch the idea:

  • Ask about specifics in the past, not hypotheticals about the future ("when did this last happen" not "would you use this").
  • Seek evidence of cost: money, time, or workarounds already spent on the problem. That is the real signal of pain.
  • Discount compliments and "yes I'd buy that" — they are not evidence.

For each line of evidence, record it in the stage gates/notes with a source reference. The gate:

Gate

G2.1 — Is there real evidence of the pain AND of willingness to pay/change? Score 0..1 by strength of evidence (paying/working-around now = high; only stated interest = low). threshold: 0.65. ≥0.65 → PASSED; <0.5 → FAILED; between → REVIEW_NEEDED.

Writes

stages[] record (stage_id: 2, gate G2.1, status, score, evidence refs).

Console

[Tầng 2 · Xác thực vấn đề] (status) (score) — <bằng chứng chính>

ldphuong-vn/validate-suite/tree/main/stages/problem-val commit 47ec1571d9

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add ldphuong-vn/validate-problem-val