Solution Design Review

Solution Design Review

Use this skill before proposing or implementing a solution when the user asks for a plan, diagnosis, implementation approach, best solution, root-cause analysis, refactor strategy, or tradeoff discussion.

Use When

• The user asks "how would you implement this?"
• The user asks for the best solution, not just a minimal patch
• The user asks why a bug happens and how to fix it
• The user wants to compare implementation options
• The task involves UI consistency, interaction state, component boundaries, architecture, or refactoring
• A quick local patch may work but could hide a deeper ownership or design issue

Do Not Use

• When the user clearly asks for a direct small edit and no discussion is needed
• For purely mechanical file changes with no design decision
• For commit message generation
• For user-facing documentation writing

Workflow

1. Classify the problem

   • Bug fix
   • Feature implementation
   • Refactor
   • UI/design consistency
   • Interaction or state ownership
   • Architecture or module boundary
   • Platform or runtime behavior

2. Inspect the relevant context first

   • Read the relevant code, config, or existing patterns before proposing a solution.
   • Distinguish symptoms from root cause.
   • Do not infer from class names or surface behavior alone when rendered output, event flow, or ownership boundaries matter.

3. Separate quick fixes from durable solutions

   • If a quick fix exists, label it as such.
   • If a better long-term solution exists, explain why it is better.
   • Do not present a workaround as the best solution.

4. Recommend one approach

   • State the recommended solution clearly.
   • Explain the tradeoffs and blast radius.
   • Avoid overengineering small changes, but do not default to minimal edits when the user asks for the best solution.

5. State implementation impact

   • Files or modules likely affected
   • Behavior changes
   • Compatibility or migration concerns
   • Verification plan

6. When approved, implement the recommended approach

   • Do not silently downgrade to a quicker patch.
   • If implementation reveals a better approach, pause and explain the change before switching strategy.

Key Rules

• Root cause before fix.
• Ownership boundary before patch.
• Rendered behavior before class-name assumptions.
• Tradeoffs before recommendation.
• Best solution means durable, maintainable, and appropriate to the project, not necessarily the largest refactor.
• When the user explicitly asks for the best solution in a development-stage codebase, optimize for the target design even if that requires refactoring; do not bias the solution toward backward compatibility with existing code unless the user asks for compatibility.

Output

For small cases, answer with:

原因：
方案：
影响范围：
验证方式：

For larger cases, include:

问题类型：
根因判断：
可选方案：
推荐方案：
实施范围：
验证计划：