Skill Quality Check

Skill Quality Check

Evaluate Agent Skills against the helloandy 8-dimension quality framework.

Dimensions

Technical Quality (5 dimensions, 5 points each = 25 total)

1. Trigger Accuracy — Does the skill activate on the right inputs and ignore irrelevant ones?
2. Output Structure — Are outputs well-formatted, consistent, and follow expected schemas?
3. Error Tolerance — Does the skill handle edge cases gracefully without crashing?
4. Token Efficiency — Is the SKILL.md concise? Does it avoid unnecessary repetition?
5. Tool Integration — Are tool calls correct, efficient, and properly error-handled?

Output Quality (3 dimensions, 5 points each = 15 total)

6. Completeness — Does the skill fully address the user's request?
7. Actionability — Are the outputs immediately usable without further clarification?
8. Consistency — Are outputs deterministic across similar inputs?

Process

1. Read the target SKILL.md file
2. Score each dimension (1-5) with evidence
3. Calculate total score (max 40)
4. Provide specific improvement suggestions for any dimension scoring below 3
5. Output a structured report with scores, evidence, and recommendations

Report Format

## Quality Report: [Skill Name]

| Dimension | Score | Evidence |
|-----------|-------|----------|
| Trigger Accuracy | X/5 | ... |
| Output Structure | X/5 | ... |
| ... | ... | ... |

**Total: XX/40**
**Grade: [A/B/C/D/F]**

### Improvement Suggestions
- [Specific actionable suggestion for low-scoring dimensions]