Wp Security Audit

WordPress security audit

A defensive checklist-driven review for WP plugin and theme PHP. Goal: catch the boring, repeatable mistakes that ship to production because no one ran through the basics. This is not a substitute for a real security review of cryptography, business logic, or third-party deps.

When to use this skill

Trigger this skill when ANY of the following is true:

• The user asks for a security review, audit, or "is this safe".
• The diff or file under discussion contains: $_GET, $_POST, $_REQUEST, $_COOKIE, $_FILES, $_SERVER, wp_unslash, wp_verify_nonce, check_admin_referer, current_user_can, add_action( 'wp_ajax, add_action( 'admin_post, register_rest_route, $wpdb->, update_option, update_user_meta, wp_redirect, wp_safe_redirect, file_get_contents, move_uploaded_file.
• The user is preparing a plugin for release or wp.org submission.
• The user is reviewing a contributor's PR.

How to run the audit

Work through the Critical checks below in order. For each finding:

1. State the file and line.
2. Name the issue using its conventional WP terminology (e.g. "missing nonce", "unescaped output", "broken access control").
3. Show the offending code (1–3 lines).
4. Show the fix.
5. Mark severity: HIGH (exploitable now), MEDIUM (exploitable under conditions), LOW (hardening / best practice).
6. Mark the evidence status separately from severity:
   • Reproduced — a controlled test reached the sink or observed the effect;
   • Source-proven — the complete deterministic path and prerequisites are visible in the inspected code/core contracts;
   • Environment-dependent hypothesis — the effect needs a deployment property or integration that was not available to test.

Do not present an environment-dependent hypothesis as a confirmed finding. Put it under limitations or required validation, name the missing environment, and do not promote it into a reusable skill rule until it is reproduced or the relevant runtime contract is verified. Severity describes impact and exploitability; it does not compensate for weak evidence.

Do NOT silently rewrite the file. Produce a report first; only edit if the user asks you to apply fixes.

Critical checks

1. Nonce verification on state-changing requests

Any cookie-authenticated browser handler that writes (saves an option, updates meta, deletes a post, sends an email, or mutates anything) must verify request intent with a nonce.

• Forms: wp_nonce_field( 'action_name', '_wpnonce' ) → check_admin_referer( 'action_name' ) in handler.
• AJAX: wp_create_nonce( 'action_name' ) → check_ajax_referer( 'action_name', 'nonce' ).
• REST: rely on cookie auth + the built-in _wpnonce (wp-api nonce) for logged-in routes; for permission_callback use a real capability check.

A nonce is not authentication or authorization. Signed webhooks, Application Password/OAuth clients, cron, and WP-CLI use their own trust boundary instead of a WordPress nonce. Guest nonces do not identify a guest; public writes also need abuse controls such as throttling, replay protection, or CAPTCHA where appropriate. A cacheable, read-only public endpoint does not automatically need a nonce.

Common mistake: verifying the nonce inside an if whose else branch still does the write. The nonce check must short-circuit.

2. Capability checks (authorization)

Authentication ≠ authorization. A logged-in subscriber is still a user.

• Admin actions: current_user_can( 'manage_options' ) or a more specific capability (edit_posts, edit_post with object ID, manage_woocommerce etc.).
• Object-level actions MUST pass the object ID: current_user_can( 'edit_post', $post_id ) — the ID-less form is wrong.
• REST permission_callback must enforce the route's actual access policy. __return_true is dangerous on privileged writes, but can be intentional for genuinely public endpoints. Signed webhook routes should verify the signature before mutation, preferably in permission_callback.
• In multisite, is_user_member_of_blog() is a membership predicate, not a capability check. WordPress 7.1 adds the is_user_member_of_blog filter, but it runs only after both the user and an active site have resolved. Returning true can affect core REST user/application-password checks and admin UI visibility globally; do not use the filter to manufacture authorization. Keep an object-appropriate current_user_can() check at the protected sink.

3. Input: unslash → normalize when needed → validate

WordPress slashes superglobals. First recover the domain value, then choose lossy normalization only when the field's meaning permits it, and always validate the semantic contract:

$raw      = isset( $_POST['email'] ) ? wp_unslash( $_POST['email'] ) : '';
$email    = sanitize_email( $raw );
if ( ! is_email( $email ) ) { /* reject */ }

• Missing wp_unslash before normalization can leak transport slashes into stored data. Do not unslash values that did not come from a slashed boundary.
• Choose the normalizer by field meaning: text, textarea, email, URL, key, integer, allowed HTML, and filesystem path need different contracts. See the extended reference.md map.
• Never trust $_SERVER['HTTP_*'] headers without sanitizing; they're attacker-controlled.

Sanitization is not a ritual and is often lossy. Migration, import/export, database repair, code-editor, and opaque meta-value tools may need to preserve HTML, percent sequences, quotes, or backslashes exactly. Do not recommend sanitize_text_field() merely to silence a sniff. Require strict type/shape, encoding/size/domain validation, a safe sink, and escaped output. See reference.md for the exact-preservation pattern.

4. Output escaping (XSS)

Escape at the point of output, in the right context:

• HTML body: esc_html( $x )
• HTML attribute: esc_attr( $x )
• URL in href/src: esc_url( $x )
• Inside <script> JSON: wp_json_encode( $x ), never raw concatenation
• Translated strings with placeholders: escape the template AND the substituted value separately. esc_html__() only escapes the static template; printf( esc_html__( '%s', 'td' ), $name ) is XSS if $name contains markup. Correct form: printf( esc_html__( 'Hello, %s', 'td' ), esc_html( $name ) ).
• Already-HTML content (post content): wp_kses_post( $x )

echo $foo; where $foo came from input or DB without escaping → XSS. This is the most common finding in plugin audits.

WordPress 7.1 expanded what Core KSES accepts: tabindex is a global allowed attribute, and safe inline CSS recognizes additional gradient, transform, clip-path, and SVG presentation forms. This is not a bypass and does not make raw HTML safe, but code must not rely on older Core stripping those values as its business rule. When the product needs a narrower policy, pass an explicit allowlist to wp_kses() and test it on every supported Core version. Keep escaping at output even after KSES sanitization.

5. SQL: always prepare

// WRONG
$wpdb->get_results( "SELECT * FROM x WHERE id = $id" );

// RIGHT
$wpdb->get_results( $wpdb->prepare( "SELECT * FROM x WHERE id = %d", $id ) );

• %d integers, %f floats, %s strings, %i table/column identifiers (WordPress 6.2+). Still use a semantic allowlist for user-selected columns, tables, and sort directions: %i quotes an identifier but does not decide whether that identifier is allowed by the feature.
• LIKE needs $wpdb->esc_like() BEFORE prepare(): $like = '%' . $wpdb->esc_like( $term ) . '%';
• Prefer WP_Query / get_posts / get_users over raw SQL where possible.

6. AJAX endpoints

Two hooks, two meanings — confuse them and you ship a vulnerability:

• wp_ajax_{action} — fires only for logged-in users.
• wp_ajax_nopriv_{action} — fires for logged-out users.

Rules:

• Register nopriv ONLY if the feature is genuinely meant for guests (e.g. public search, login form). Never copy-paste both registrations "to be safe".
• Cookie-authenticated writes need check_ajax_referer(). Public read-only handlers do not automatically need a nonce; use one only when it protects a browser action, and never treat a guest nonce as authorization.
• The nopriv handler must NOT perform actions that only logged-in users should do (saving prefs, accessing other users' data, etc.).
• End with wp_send_json_success / wp_send_json_error, not echo + die.

7. admin-post and form handlers

admin_post_{action} and admin_post_nopriv_{action} follow the same rules as AJAX. Plus: redirect with wp_safe_redirect() + exit;. Never redirect with wp_redirect( $_GET['redirect_to'] ) without validating against an allowlist — that's an open-redirect.

8. REST API routes

register_rest_route( 'myplugin/v1', '/save', [
    'methods'             => 'POST',
    'callback'            => 'myplugin_save',
    'permission_callback' => function () {
        return current_user_can( 'manage_options' );
    },
    'args' => [
        'id' => [
            'required'          => true,
            'type'              => 'integer',
            'minimum'           => 1,
            'validate_callback' => 'rest_validate_request_arg',
            'sanitize_callback' => 'absint',
        ],
    ],
] );

Findings to flag:

• permission_callback missing, or __return_true on a non-public route.
• No args schema and no equivalent validation in the callback. A route may validate manually, but a schema is preferred because it is discoverable and runs consistently before permission and endpoint callbacks.
• Returning raw DB rows including sensitive columns (user_pass, user_activation_key, private meta).

9. File operations

• Uploads: validate MIME via wp_check_filetype_and_ext(), store via wp_handle_upload(), never trust the client-provided extension or MIME.
• Path joins with user input: after building, realpath() and check the result starts with the intended base dir. Otherwise: path traversal.
• Never include / require a path containing user input.

10. Secrets and information disclosure

• No API keys or DB credentials in the plugin source. Use options or constants in wp-config.php.
• WP_DEBUG_DISPLAY should be off in prod; flag any var_dump, print_r, error_log( $sensitive ) left in handlers.
• Don't leak stack traces, full SQL, or user enumeration via error messages ("user not found" vs "wrong password" — pick one).

11. Redirects

• Use wp_safe_redirect() for any URL that may be influenced by input.
• Always exit; after a redirect — execution continues otherwise.

12. Cron and background jobs

• wp_schedule_event callbacks run with no current user. If the job performs privileged work, do not trust any "stored intent" without re-validating; treat persisted user input as untrusted.

False-positive guards

• Accept exact preservation when its validation, sink, and output contracts are explicit.
• Do not require a nonce for read-only public endpoints, cron, WP-CLI, or signed non-cookie requests; identify the actual trust boundary.
• Do not flag code-generated IN placeholders as injection when the placeholder string contains only generated %s/%d tokens and all values reach $wpdb->prepare().

What this skill does NOT cover

• Cryptographic correctness (key derivation, signing schemes).
• Business-logic flaws (race conditions, IDOR beyond capability checks).
• Retry/idempotency/partial-failure flaws in bulk writes — use wp-batch-mutation-audit.
• Metadata slashing/revision/multi-row/serialization — use wp-metadata-api.
• Third-party library CVEs — run composer audit separately.
• Frontend JS XSS — different skill.
• Server / hosting hardening (file perms, disable_functions, etc.).
• Object injection, SSRF, CSRF on GET, mass assignment, file include, mail/zip injection, timing comparison, TOCTOU races — these are covered by wp-security-deep. Run it after this one.
• Hardcoded credentials, weak randomness for tokens, password storage, cookie flags, secrets in logs — covered by wp-security-secrets. Run it whenever auth or third-party integrations are in scope.

State this scope and recommend applicable deeper skills in the report footer.

Report format

# Security audit: <plugin name>
Scope: <files reviewed>
Date: <YYYY-MM-DD>

## HIGH
1. <file>:<line> — <issue>
   Evidence: <Reproduced | Source-proven>
   <code>
   Fix: <code>

## MEDIUM
...

## LOW / Hardening
...

## Out of scope
- <thing not checked>

## Requires environment validation
- <hypothesis, missing deployment property, exact acceptance test>

References

• Detailed examples of each finding type, before/after: reference.md
• Real-world snippets with the fix applied: examples/
• WordPress core: Plugin Security Handbook and Roles and Capabilities
• Official documentation: https://developer.wordpress.org/apis/security/
• Official documentation: https://developer.wordpress.org/reference/functions/wp_verify_nonce/
• Official documentation: https://developer.wordpress.org/reference/functions/current_user_can/
• WordPress 7.1 source: wp-includes/user.php (is_user_member_of_blog).