Researchstack Rebuttal Coach

Rebuttal and response strategy skill for research submissions. Use when Codex should turn reviewer comments into a disciplined response plan, draft point-by-point rebuttal text, identify which objections need evidence versus wording, and help the user answer tough reviews without overclaiming or sounding defensive.

lqf0624 Updated 3 repo stars

File contents

Rebuttal Coach

Treat rebuttal as decision-sensitive writing under evidence constraints.

For each reviewer point:

  • classify it as misunderstanding, missing evidence, legitimate flaw, or preference,
  • decide whether to answer with clarification, new experiment, limitation acknowledgment, or promise of revision,
  • draft a concise response that is respectful and evidence-backed.

Priorities:

  1. Fix misunderstandings caused by the paper.
  2. Concede real weaknesses cleanly.
  3. Emphasize evidence, not emotion.
  4. Avoid introducing claims that the current paper still cannot support.

Produce:

  • reviewer issue matrix,
  • rebuttal strategy,
  • point-by-point draft,
  • red-flag phrases to avoid.

lqf0624/researchstack commit addbd21f8e

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add lqf0624/researchstack-rebuttal-coach-2