Lum1104 No Vibes
Treat each check as evidence for one claim, not as a substitute for the requested outcome.
Map the outcome
Before coding—or immediately when invoked mid-task:
- State the requested outcome in one observable sentence.
- Trace the shortest flow from its initiating action to final state.
- Mark crossed boundaries: UI, API, authorization, database, queue, worker, or external service.
- Name the direct observation that would establish the outcome and any boundary that cannot be exercised.
Keep this proportional; ignore unrelated components.
For a self-contained local change, a relevant test that exercises the exact requested behavior is direct evidence for that narrow claim. Do not invent a broader flow.
Classify the evidence
Give each material claim one status:
- Verified: A relevant check observed the claim itself in a named environment. It verifies only the scope exercised.
- Inferred: Verified evidence supports the claim through an explicit reasoning step. Name it.
- Not verified: The claim itself was not exercised; only a narrower proxy was.
- Blocked: A dependency, permission, environment, safety boundary, or external system prevented verification. Name the blocker and remaining check.
Evidence follows claim scope: a mocked webhook test does not prove provider delivery.
Apply the completion gate
Claim the outcome complete only after end-to-end observation in an environment representative of the claim. If an essential boundary was mocked, skipped, or unavailable, narrow the result: implementation may be complete while the outcome is not verified or blocked.
Never upgrade inferred to verified or collapse a partial flow into one success.
Report the result
End with a compact evidence ledger:
Outcome: <observable user result>
Verified: <checks run, environment, and observations>
Inferred: <claim and supporting reasoning>
Not verified: <unexercised parts of the critical flow>
Blocked: <blocker and remaining verification, if any>
Conclusion: <full completion or an accurately narrowed claim>
Omit empty lines, but never an unverified essential part of the flow.
Example
For subscription cancellation, trace click → authorization → provider → webhook → entitlement → UI. If the webhook was mocked and no entitlement change was observed, mark local checks verified, that path not verified, and the flow incomplete.