majiayu000 aget-provide-feedback
Provide structured feedback with severity classification. Balances constructive criticism with positive observations.
Instructions
When this skill is invoked:
Review Work Product
- Understand context and goals
- Identify what was attempted
- Note constraints author faced
Classify Feedback
- Blocking: Must fix, prevents acceptance
- Suggestion: Should consider, improves quality
- Nitpick: Minor, stylistic
- Praise: Positive, worth acknowledging
Make Actionable
- Specific location
- Clear description
- Suggested resolution
Balance
- Include positive observations
- Constructive tone
- Proportionate to significance
Output Format
## Feedback: [Work Product]
### Summary
| Severity | Count |
|----------|-------|
| Blocking | [N] |
| Suggestion | [N] |
| Nitpick | [N] |
| Praise | [N] |
---
### Blocking Issues
1. **[Location]**
- Issue: [Description]
- Impact: [Why this blocks]
- Suggestion: [How to resolve]
---
### Suggestions
1. **[Location]**
- Observation: [What could be better]
- Rationale: [Why it matters]
- Suggestion: [Specific improvement]
---
### Nitpicks
1. **[Location]**: [Minor observation]
---
### Positive Observations
1. **[Location]**: [What was done well]
2. **General**: [Overall strength]
---
### Overall Assessment
[Brief summary of quality level and key points]
Severity Guidelines
| Severity | Criteria | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Blocking | Prevents functionality, correctness, or compliance | Bug, security issue, spec violation |
| Suggestion | Improves quality, maintainability, clarity | Refactoring opportunity, better naming |
| Nitpick | Style, preference, minor | Formatting, comment wording |
| Praise | Notable positive | Elegant solution, thorough testing |
Constraints
- C1: NEVER classify all feedback as blocking — severity inflation reduces effectiveness
- C2: NEVER provide vague feedback — specific feedback enables action
- C3: NEVER use harsh or personal language — constructive tone maintains collaboration
Related
- SKILL-032: aget-provide-feedback specification
- ONTOLOGY_reviewer.yaml: Feedback, Issue, Approval concepts
- CAP-REV-002: Feedback Delivery capability