Decision

/decision — Project Decision Records

You capture decisions the way software teams capture ADRs (Architecture Decision Records) — except these are for actual architecture. One file per decision, numbered, in decisions/ at the project root. The record survives the email thread, the meeting, and the personnel change that would otherwise lose it.

Usage

/decision                          → interview for a decision in the air, then record it
/decision we're going with X       → record it, asking only for what's missing
/decision supersede 0003           → mark 0003 superseded, record its replacement
/decision list                     → show the index with statuses

Hard rules

1. One decision per record. "Schemes B and code edition 2022" is two records.
2. Never renumber, never delete. Numbers are permanent references. Wrong decisions get superseded, not removed — the reasoning trail is the point.
3. Capture options honestly. A record with one option isn't a decision, it's an announcement. Ask what else was considered, even briefly.
4. Keep the dossier index in sync. Every create/supersede updates the Decisions table in PROJECT.md (create the dossier via /project-dossier init first if it doesn't exist).
5. Brevity. Context in 2–4 sentences, options as one line each, consequences as bullets. A record nobody reads records nothing.

Recording flow

1. Find the next number: Glob decisions/*.md, take max + 1, zero-padded to 4 digits.
2. Gather the pieces — from the conversation first, ask only for gaps (one grouped question): what was decided, what options were on the table, why, who made the call.
3. Write decisions/NNNN-{kebab-slug}.md from the template.
4. Update the Decisions index in PROJECT.md.
5. Confirm with the path and a one-line restatement of the decision.

Template

# NNNN — {Decision title, stated as the choice made}

- **Status:** decided
- **Date:** {YYYY-MM-DD}
- **Deciders:** {who made the call}

## Context

{2–4 sentences: the situation that forced a choice. Link the analysis that surfaced it if one exists.}

## Options considered

1. **{Option A}** — {one line: what it would mean}
2. **{Option B}** — {one line}

## Decision

{The choice, and the load-bearing reason in 1–3 sentences.}

## Consequences

- {What this enables, costs, or constrains downstream}
- {What must now happen as a result}

Statuses: proposed (on the table, not yet made — record it so the options aren't lost), decided, superseded by NNNN.

On supersede

1. Read the old record. Set its status to superseded by NNNN (naming the new record) — touch nothing else in it.
2. Record the new decision normally; its Context section names what it replaces and why the reversal.
3. Update both rows in the dossier index.

When analysis skills propose a decision

Skills in this marketplace surface choice points (zoning paths, code editions, GWP thresholds) and suggest running /decision. When that happens, the analysis is your Context — quote its numbers with their source rather than re-deriving them.

Collaboration

Records are plain files in the project folder — share them the way the project is already shared (git, Drive, Dropbox). Review happens in version control or in conversation; this skill imposes no workflow beyond the files.