Deepwork Jobs.implement

deepwork_jobs.implement

Step 3/4 in deepwork_jobs workflow

Creates and manages multi-step AI workflows. Use when defining, implementing, or improving DeepWork jobs.

Prerequisites (Verify First)

Before proceeding, confirm these steps are complete:

• /deepwork_jobs.review_job_spec

Instructions

Goal: Generates step instruction files and syncs slash commands from the job.yml specification. Use after job spec review passes.

Implement Job Steps

Objective

Generate the DeepWork job directory structure and instruction files for each step based on the validated job.yml specification from the review_job_spec step.

Task

Read the job.yml specification file and create all the necessary files to make the job functional, including directory structure and step instruction files. Then sync the commands to make them available.

Step 1: Create Directory Structure Using Script

Run the make_new_job.sh script to create the standard directory structure:

.deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/make_new_job.sh [job_name]

This creates:

• .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/ - Main job directory
• .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/steps/ - Step instruction files
• .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/hooks/ - Custom validation scripts (with .gitkeep)
• .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/templates/ - Example file formats (with .gitkeep)
• .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/AGENTS.md - Job management guidance

Note: If the directory already exists (e.g., job.yml was created by define step), you can skip this step or manually create the additional directories:

mkdir -p .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/hooks .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/templates
touch .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/hooks/.gitkeep .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/templates/.gitkeep

Step 2: Read and Validate the Specification

1. Locate the job.yml file

   • Read .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/job.yml from the review_job_spec step
   • Parse the YAML content

2. Validate the specification

   • Ensure it follows the schema (name, version, summary, description, steps)
   • Check that all dependencies reference existing steps
   • Verify no circular dependencies
   • Confirm file inputs match dependencies

3. Extract key information

   • Job name, version, summary, description
   • List of all steps with their details
   • Understand the workflow structure

Step 3: Generate Step Instruction Files

For each step in the job.yml, create a comprehensive instruction file at .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/steps/[step_id].md.

Template reference: See .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/templates/step_instruction.md.template for the standard structure.

Complete example: See .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/templates/step_instruction.md.example for a fully worked example.

Available templates in .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/templates/:

• job.yml.template - Job specification structure
• step_instruction.md.template - Step instruction file structure
• agents.md.template - AGENTS.md file structure
• job.yml.example - Complete job specification example
• step_instruction.md.example - Complete step instruction example

Guidelines for generating instructions:

1. Use the job description - The detailed description from job.yml provides crucial context
2. Be specific - Don't write generic instructions; tailor them to the step's purpose
3. Provide examples - Show what good output looks like
4. Explain the "why" - Help the user understand the step's role in the workflow
5. Quality over quantity - Detailed, actionable instructions are better than vague ones
6. Align with stop hooks - If the step has stop_hooks defined, ensure the quality criteria in the instruction file match the validation criteria in the hooks
7. Ask structured questions - When a step has user inputs, the instructions MUST explicitly tell the agent to "ask structured questions" using the AskUserQuestion tool to gather that information. Never use generic phrasing like "ask the user" - always use "ask structured questions"

Handling Stop Hooks

If a step in the job.yml has stop_hooks defined, the generated instruction file should:

1. Mirror the quality criteria - The "Quality Criteria" section should match what the stop hooks will validate
2. Be explicit about success - Help the agent understand when the step is truly complete
3. Include the promise pattern - Mention that <promise>✓ Quality Criteria Met</promise> should be included when criteria are met

Example: If the job.yml has:

- id: research_competitors
  name: "Research Competitors"
  stop_hooks:
    - prompt: |
        Verify the research meets criteria:
        1. Each competitor has at least 3 data points
        2. Sources are cited
        3. Information is current (within last year)

The instruction file should include:

## Quality Criteria

- Each competitor has at least 3 distinct data points
- All information is sourced with citations
- Data is current (from within the last year)
- When all criteria are met, include `<promise>✓ Quality Criteria Met</promise>` in your response

This alignment ensures the AI agent knows exactly what will be validated and can self-check before completing.

Using Supplementary Reference Files

Step instructions can include additional .md files in the steps/ directory for detailed examples, templates, or reference material. Reference them using the full path from the project root.

See .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/steps/supplemental_file_references.md for detailed documentation and examples.

Step 4: Verify job.yml Location

Verify that job.yml is in the correct location at .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/job.yml. The define and review_job_spec steps should have created and validated it. If for some reason it's not there, you may need to create or move it.

Step 5: Sync Skills

Run deepwork sync to generate the skills for this job:

deepwork sync

This will:

• Parse the job definition
• Generate skills for each step
• Make the skills available in .claude/skills/ (or appropriate platform directory)

Step 6: Relay Reload Instructions

After running deepwork sync, look at the "To use the new skills" section in the output. Relay these exact reload instructions to the user so they know how to pick up the new skills. Don't just reference the sync output - tell them directly what they need to do (e.g., "Type 'exit' then run 'claude --resume'" for Claude Code, or "Run '/memory refresh'" for Gemini CLI).

Step 7: Consider Rules for the New Job

After implementing the job, consider whether there are rules that would help enforce quality or consistency when working with this job's domain.

What are rules?

Rules are automated guardrails stored as markdown files in .deepwork/rules/ that trigger when certain files change during an AI session. They help ensure:

• Documentation stays in sync with code
• Team guidelines are followed
• Architectural decisions are respected
• Quality standards are maintained

When to suggest rules:

Think about the job you just implemented and ask:

• Does this job produce outputs that other files depend on?
• Are there documentation files that should be updated when this job's outputs change?
• Are there quality checks or reviews that should happen when certain files in this domain change?
• Could changes to the job's output files impact other parts of the project?

Examples of rules that might make sense:

How to offer rule creation:

If you identify one or more rules that would benefit the user, explain:

1. What the rule would do - What triggers it and what action it prompts
2. Why it would help - How it prevents common mistakes or keeps things in sync
3. What files it would watch - The trigger patterns

Then ask the user:

"Would you like me to create this rule for you? I can run /deepwork_rules.define to set it up."

If the user agrees, invoke the /deepwork_rules.define command to guide them through creating the rule.

Example dialogue:

Based on the competitive_research job you just created, I noticed that when
competitor analysis files change, it would be helpful to remind you to update
your strategy documentation.

I'd suggest a rule like:
- **Name**: "Update strategy when competitor analysis changes"
- **Trigger**: `**/positioning_report.md`
- **Action**: Prompt to review and update `docs/strategy.md`

Would you like me to create this rule? I can run `/deepwork_rules.define` to set it up.

Note: Not every job needs rules. Only suggest them when they would genuinely help maintain consistency or quality. Don't force rules where they don't make sense.

Example Implementation

For a complete worked example showing a job.yml and corresponding step instruction file, see:

• Job specification: .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/templates/job.yml.example
• Step instruction: .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/templates/step_instruction.md.example

Important Guidelines

1. Read the spec carefully - Understand the job's intent from the description
2. Generate complete instructions - Don't create placeholder or stub files
3. Maintain consistency - Use the same structure for all step instruction files
4. Provide examples - Show what good output looks like
5. Use context - The job description provides valuable context for each step
6. Be specific - Tailor instructions to the specific step, not generic advice

Validation Before Sync

Before running deepwork sync, verify:

• All directories exist
• job.yml is in place
• All step instruction files exist (one per step)
• No file system errors

Completion Checklist

Before marking this step complete, ensure:

• job.yml validated and copied to job directory
• All step instruction files created
• Each instruction file is complete and actionable
• deepwork sync executed successfully
• Skills generated in platform directory
• User informed to follow reload instructions from deepwork sync
• Considered whether rules would benefit this job (Step 7)
• If rules suggested, offered to run /deepwork_rules.define

Quality Criteria

• Job directory structure is correct
• All instruction files are complete (not stubs)
• Instructions are specific and actionable
• Output examples are provided in each instruction file
• Quality criteria defined for each step
• Steps with user inputs explicitly use "ask structured questions" phrasing
• Sync completed successfully
• Skills available for use
• Thoughtfully considered relevant rules for the job domain

Job Context

Core commands for managing DeepWork jobs. These commands help you define new multi-step workflows and learn from running them.

The define command guides you through an interactive process to create a new job by asking structured questions about your workflow, understanding each step's inputs and outputs, and generating all necessary files.

The learn command reflects on conversations where DeepWork jobs were run, identifies confusion or inefficiencies, and improves job instructions. It also captures bespoke learnings specific to the current run into AGENTS.md files in the working folder.

Required Inputs

Files from Previous Steps - Read these first:

• job.yml (from review_job_spec)

Work Branch

Use branch format: deepwork/deepwork_jobs-[instance]-YYYYMMDD

• If on a matching work branch: continue using it
• If on main/master: create new branch with git checkout -b deepwork/deepwork_jobs-[instance]-$(date +%Y%m%d)

Outputs

Required outputs:

• steps/ (directory)

Guardrails

• Do NOT skip prerequisite verification if this step has dependencies
• Do NOT produce partial outputs; complete all required outputs before finishing
• Do NOT proceed without required inputs; ask the user if any are missing
• Do NOT modify files outside the scope of this step's defined outputs

Quality Validation

Stop hooks will automatically validate your work. The loop continues until all criteria pass.

Criteria (all must be satisfied):

1. Directory Structure: Is .deepwork/jobs/[job_name]/ created correctly?
2. Complete Instructions: Are ALL step instruction files complete (not stubs or placeholders)?
3. Specific & Actionable: Are instructions tailored to each step's purpose, not generic?
4. Output Examples: Does each instruction file show what good output looks like?
5. Quality Criteria: Does each instruction file define quality criteria for its outputs?
6. Ask Structured Questions: Do step instructions that gather user input explicitly use the phrase "ask structured questions"?
7. Sync Complete: Has deepwork sync been run successfully?
8. Commands Available: Are the slash-commands generated in .claude/commands/?
9. Rules Considered: Has the agent thought about whether rules would benefit this job? If relevant rules were identified, did they explain them and offer to run /deepwork_rules.define? Not every job needs rules - only suggest when genuinely helpful.

To complete: Include <promise>✓ Quality Criteria Met</promise> in your final response only after verifying ALL criteria are satisfied.

On Completion

1. Verify outputs are created
2. Inform user: "Step 3/4 complete, outputs: steps/"
3. Continue workflow: Use Skill tool to invoke /deepwork_jobs.learn

Reference files: .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/job.yml, .deepwork/jobs/deepwork_jobs/steps/implement.md